For a nation obsessed with fair and lovely, are we really surprised at #Blackface?

Published: March 17, 2018
SHARES
Email

A segment on a morning show required participants to turn naturally fair-skinned models into a darker complexion. PHOTO: FACEBOOK/ THEPAKISTANIMARTHASTEWART

If there is one thing Pakistani TV is good at, it is never failing to surprise audiences with how low it can go in its attempts to “entertain”. The most recent instance of such an effort took place on Sanam Jung’s morning show, Jaago Pakistan Jaagowhere a bridal makeup competition segment required participants to turn naturally fair-skinned models into a darker complexion, and then give them a bridal makeover.

As I came across pictures of the models, with their faces transformed to dramatically darkened skin tones and dressed as brides, it disturbed me to see yet another racist message being propagated to Pakistani audiences. As if Sana Safinaz’s recent campaign had not been enough of a disaster in its depiction of our ignorance and casual attitude towards racism.

Before jumping to any conclusions, I found it essential to analyse the show after watching it. After doing so, it was clear the underlying motive of the segment was to show viewers that dark-skinned women can be beautiful brides too. The ladies discussed why it was implied that dark is not attractive, and what makeup techniques can be used to make darker women seem beautiful on their wedding day. However, this has prompted a discussion over why it was heavily implied that dark skin tones are actually not beautiful, and that giving a dark-skinned woman a bridal makeover would be a “challenge”.

It is ironic that a show titled Jaago Pakistan Jaago would be this ignorant when tackling a very prevalent and disconcerting issue in our country. While their words suggested that yes, dark is beautiful, their actions suggested no, it is actually not. After all, if they truly believed what they were preaching, would they not have brought actual dark-skinned girls to model? As a South Asian country, was it really that difficult to find young women of darker skin tones for the segment?

It is no secret that our colonial past has led to us shunning our natural dark skin and developing a fixation with “whiteness”. In our society, is a woman believed to be beautiful if she has dark skin? No, unfortunately; in South Asia, the notion of a woman’s beauty and desirability is directly linked to her “fairness”. Otherwise, why would every mother-in-law scramble for a gori bahu (fair daughter-in-law)? When is the last time we saw an advertisement not telling us to get “fairer in just seven days” or that “white is perfect”?

For a nation obsessed with fair and lovely, are we really surprised by this?

Not only were the models essentially wearing what is called “blackface”, the show used racial slurs such as “habshi”, “makrani” and “negro” throughout the episode, making this a shameful attempt at a “positive” message.

It is known that morning shows are viewed by a wide range of audiences comprising of women and young girls across the nation, and their hosts are looked up to as role models. Given their level of influence, it is not unreasonable to expect better. If influential figures such as Jung are seen casually promoting such a mindset, this will be deemed as acceptable behaviour in the minds of the masses.

What we need in our society are more women who actively encourage progress, not women who contribute to its regression. After all, this is certainly not the first time that such absurdity has been witnessed on morning shows. Then why does it continue to be acceptable for such shows to encourage women to expose extremely personal matters on national television? After all, social work cannot be done by sensationalising social issues.

What about the constant and unrealistic focus on weddings and physical appearances? Are women on television only meant to be eye candy, divested of intellect? Why have we restricted women to the circumference of family drama, wedding planning and dumbing themselves down?

There is no doubt that just as racism exists in every society, it exists in Pakistan too; however, it is evident that class discrimination accompanies racial discrimination here. Before this incident, when I heard Jung’s name, I imagined a soft-spoken, bubbly young woman adored by the masses. Unfortunately, the image was shattered as I viewed this episode. I was shocked to witness the way Jung interacted with the participants, which was drastically different from the typical sweet demeanour present when she interviews high profile celebrities. Throughout the episode, Jung, along with her companions, can constantly be seen harassing and disrespecting the make-up artists, who most likely belonged to middle to lower income areas in Karachi. Would this still be the case if these make-up artists belonged to the elite, or were famous? Is our media determined to prove that not only are we racist but also classist?

Had literally anyone present during recording realised or taken action against such flagrant discrimination, or had the hosts monitored their behaviour and their tone, the fate of the episode and the show’s reputation could have been saved. If our society truly wants freedom from the shackles of beauty standards rooted in our colonial past, then it must stop promoting the notion that “fair is lovely”.

Further, if morning shows really want to spread the message that dark is beautiful, then they should halt the fairness campaigns and start one for Pakistani women to embrace their skin as it is. There are, after all, other ways to spread positivity; ways that do not have to involve racial slurs or fair-skinned models with blackface.

Hira Hyder

Hira Hyder

The author is a journalist who strives to be a voice for those who struggle to voice themselves. She believes that any obstacle in life can be battled by the right amount of spirituality, positive energy and chocolate! She tweets @HiraHyder (twitter.com/HiraHyder)

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Aman Lodhi

    There are black men and women who are more and way attractive than any human being currently.Recommend

  • Parvez

    Interesting read …. I have not seen the Sanam Jung show, but from your write up I gather that the basic concept was sound but the execution was horribly flawed. The idea of turning natural fair skin to a darker shade through make up was utter stupidity…..natural is nature given and cosmetic comes out a jar or a tube, there’s no contest.
    If I watched a morning show it would be the Nadia Jameel Show ‘ …. she is intelligent, opinionated, sensible…..and very pleasant.Recommend

  • Leonard Harrison

    These morning shows are truly disgusting. How dare they discriminate on basis of race, class and color. It is shameful. This is why this sort of entertainment needs to be abolished from our society. It creates inferiority complex and promotes hate. We can not ridicule anyone on basis of color or class. Period. Women in our country are projected negatively through these shows and movies. Stop this rubbish. Project only such entertainment which is relate-able to the common people. Stop poisoning the minds of our people. Great article. These people need to be exposed for the shameful beings they really are.Recommend

  • Amra Sz

    Excellent post yet again by this journalist Hira Hyder!
    It takes a lot of patience to tolerate morning shows but I had to venture to watch this show to actually see what went wrong there.

    It was heart breaking to see them being treated that way. Class discrimination is so normal in Pakistan no one cares about it any more. She was so rude to each one of them that it was unbearable n unbelievable. She should learn to respect people before she does anything else
    To top it all, she and those two other women with her were all talking at the same time. Yelling on top of their voices, interrupting each other. Stepping on each others’ toes. They must go back n learn the basics/ethics of interaction. None deserves to be treated the way these women were treated.

    Keep up the good work Hira!
    Waiting for another masterpiece.
    Keep spreading compassion and awareness!!!Recommend

  • Manzoor Ahmed

    Its a great misconception amongst our masses that fair is lovely. A person can be lovely irrespective what color or creed they belong to. This unfortunate hype is very much woven in the fabric of our societies which needs to be correctedRecommend

  • sterry

    There are lots of pretty dark women in Pakistani dramas such as Maria Wasti. There should be no discrimination against dark skin vs lighter skin but since a lot of the media shows comes from Karachi they have the Indian bias against dark skin. In Pakistan there are many skin tones ranging from African sheedis to Gilgitis. A lot of people who migrated to Karachi from India still have the traditional Indian bias against darker skinned people. Native Pakistani races may be lighter but interestingly, they don’t care as much. Notice the poorer native Pakistanis from KPK or Upper Punjab or Northern Areas who are naturally fairer but do not appear on TV pr dramas because it is mostly Karachi based actors and actresses or people like the late Zubaida Apa ( originally from South India) . Zubeida Apa was a TV personality from South Indian family and she would also promote the creams to lighten skin just like they did back in India but in parts of Pakistan where people already have lighter skin, no one cares. People in Pakistan need to accept that all skin types are beautiful and not buy into Indian stereotypes.Recommend

  • Leonard Harrison

    Sure, well putRecommend