Is Donald Trump even worthy of receiving a Nobel Peace Prize?

Published: May 10, 2018
SHARES
Email

A group of Republicans have written to the Nobel Prize Committee, requesting that Trump be nominated for brokering peace between North and South Korea.

President Donald Trump is at it again. As if his life wasn’t full of excitement and ridiculousness already. What with executive firings, fraternising with porn stars, making hush payments and igniting diplomatic rows, President Trump wants to add another feather to his cap.

This time, it’s gaining the mother of all civic awards, the Nobel Prize. A group of over eager Republicans, which is Trump’s political party, have written to the Nobel Prize Committee, requesting that Trump be nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize for brokering peace between North and South Korea.

Last week, Kim Jong Un (Supreme Leader of North Korea) and Moon Jae-in (President of South Korea) met in the demilitarised zone (DMZ) that lies between North and South Korea. It was the first of a kind meeting for the two leaders whose countries have been at cold war of sorts since the Korean War in 1953. After the Korean War ended, South Korea has prospered to no end while North Korea has chosen to sequester itself from the world and has gone in reverse in all aspects of society. This meeting was historic in the sense that this was the first time North Korea acknowledged its Southern neighbour. Coming out of the meeting, both leaders began the formal process of peace between the two nations and the denuclearisation of the Korean Peninsula.

First of all, a letter to the Nobel Prize Committee does not mean an official nomination for Trump. Secondly, a meeting between the two Korean leaders does not make Trump a diplomatic genius. This meeting took several diplomatic back channels on behalf of various countries and brokers to come to fruition. Most importantly, if the Nobel Prize Committee were to actually nominate Trump, they would be giving out the award to a man with a shady character and no moral scruples.

For historical context, the Nobel Prize was set up by the Swedish inventor Alfred Nobel. Every year, five winners are picked from fields such as science, social change and literature and given prize money that is presented by the King of Sweden. This money comes from a trust established through the fortune of the Nobel family. Over the course of years, the Nobel Prize has not been without its share of controversies and lost some of the lustre it used to have.

The prize given to American Secretary of State Henry Kissinger in 1973 has been controversial. This was a Nobel Peace Prize and was given out in recognition of Kissinger’s efforts to broker peace between Vietnam and the United States. What is controversial is that both kept engaged in a bloody war even after Kissinger’s efforts and all his diplomacy seemed to have gone down the drain.

Similarly, the Peace Prize in 1994 was given out to Yasser Arafat and Shimon Peres, for their efforts in establishing peace in the Middle East. Unfortunately, peace in the Middle East is still as elusive today as it was back then. Barack Obama was given a Peace Prize when he was inaugurated as the American president the first time. The issue was that Obama didn’t really have any diplomatic credentials at that point – all he had done was run a campaign that highlighted his African roots and encouraged global peace.

The prize is anointed by the Norwegian Nobel Committee. Many a times, when members don’t agree with a selection, they resign from the committee in protest. Unfortunately, that is the most that they can do. Their resignations, while noted, are not high profile or public. The selection process is not transparent and decisions made by the committee cannot be challenged. In the case of the Peace Prize given out to Malala Yousafzai a few years ago, the prize money was split between Malala and Indian activist Kailash Satyarthi. Not taking anything away from Mr Satyarthi, but the general notion among drawing room discussions was that the award was split between a Pakistani and an Indian due to a strong Indian lobby. Another aspect Pakistanis keep questioning is why Abdul Sattar Edhi never got a Nobel Peace Prize, despite his outsized efforts in providing medical care to the common man. There is no logical answer to this.

This year, like everyone else, the Nobel jury has also been hit by the #MeToo movement. Jean-Claude Arnault, a major literary figure in Sweden and spouse to a Nobel committee member, has been accused of sexual misconduct. As the investigation has unravelled, it has come to light that he had leaked names of Nobel laureates while engaging in betting pools. As a result, the Nobel committee has cancelled, for the first time in its history, the Literature Prize for the year 2018.

Coming back to Trump, we all know Trump likes to take credit for everything that is newsworthy, and credit should be given where it is due. In the past year, his verbal sparring with the North Korean dictator Kim has left many politicians and diplomats scratching their heads. For starters, Trump pays an inordinately large amount of attention to Kim. On paper, North Korea is a failed state with no outside contact and is living under constant dictatorship. Trump has resorted to calling Kim derogatory names and constantly challenged him to duels. Kim, the crackpot that he appears to be, has been more than happy to respond with equally demeaning name-calling and dared Trump to attack North Korea.

Since he was appointed president about 18 months ago, Trump has spent close to 25% of his time in office playing golf. The other 75% of his time is spent fighting legal battles against porn stars, patchy business dealings and firing people. Bringing peace to Korea is probably an afterthought for him. The Norwegian Nobel Committee should not entertain a Peace Prize for Trump in any shape or form. If people today are losing respect for the Nobel foundation, awarding a prize to Trump will cause them to completely disregard all that the foundation is and what it represents.

Muhammad Yamin

Muhammad Yamin

The author is a management consultant based in Toronto. He has a keen interest in international business, social enterprise development and application technology trends. He tweets @myamin325 twitter.com/myamin325

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • salman zahid

    If the nation of united states can elect a psycho man like trump to rule over them, they can help getting him a noble peace prize too. No wonder at all.Recommend

  • Gratgy

    Trump is shady so should not get award, he spends 25% of his time playing gold and 75% of his time fighting with porn stars. Meeting of the two Korean leaders does not make Trump a diplomatic genius (even if the leaders themselves gave credit to Trump). The Norwegian Nobel Committee should not entertain a Peace Prize for Trump in any shape or form

    Indians get awards due to lobbies according to “drawing room discussions”.

    Sattar did not get Nobel despite his efforts, so there seems to be a conspiracy against Pakistanis

    Recommend

  • Parvez

    If Trump lands up with the Nobel Peace Prize it won’t be because he deserved it …. and it won’t be the first time something as goofy as that has happened with the Peace Prize……. even Obama was a bit surprised when he won it.Recommend

  • numbersnumbers

    Please provide proof that Trump spent 4 plus months playing golf over the past 18 months as you claim!Recommend

  • vinsin

    Please provide details of when and whom submitted application for Abdul Sattar Edhi to Nobel Prize Committee. As fas I know, no one ever submitted any application for him, so how come he can be given?

    Recommend

  • Omar K Cheema

    brokering peace between is technically a huge deal…..it kinda sorta does deserve the peace prize….the only problem is whether its ethically to give such a prize to a person like Donald Trump, who ,other than brokering peace between north and south korea, has done little else to promote peace. in fact his efforts have been quite to the contraryRecommend

  • Uzi

    Why not? If Obama can win it, so can Trump. Nobel Peace Prize has to do with lobbying rather than actual ground work. Point in case, Abdul Sattar Edhi did not win it, and people like Obama and Aang Suu Kyi did.Recommend

  • Sane sid

    Trump has successfully contained the most destructive & problematic elements on this planet … be it an organisation or a nation…this is called putting things in order….I do support a Nobel prize for him.Recommend

  • Sane sid

    This is the best comment I have read so far…. no one would dare to respond…….. made my day :0Recommend

  • numbersnumbers

    Ah yes, the world conspires against Pakistanis because the world is jealous!
    OR NOT!Recommend

  • Sane sid

    You Guys even criticized When Malala won it…….Recommend

  • Patwari

    ‘…putting things in order…’ what exactly did he put in order? Hate?
    Well, Modi Sarkar and Big Yellow are two peas in a pod. Fake leaders.
    Lots of promises, but nothing delivered, except hate, bigotry, misogyny,
    racism [brown Bharatis practising caste and color discrimination, among
    themselves, meaning skin color gradations, the less chocolaty they look
    the more Raj-like Sahib/Mem Sahib behavior they spout]
    The ofay, Big Yellow, called home grown Nazis, White Supremacists, ‘good people’
    that makes one of the the largest minority in US, Hindustanis, pandering to this
    hate monger. They are Uncle Toms with bindis.
    Oh well can’t have everything.Recommend

  • Patwari

    See, besides watching Fox News, 7 to 8 hours a day, eating cheeseburgers
    in bed, flying to Mar a Lago in Florida, every weekend to play golf, [which cost
    the US tax payers $ 5.5 million for every each single flight] and not doing much
    of anything, except ridiculous infantile Tweets….you want proof of playing golf?
    The man spends his days obstructing justice, so far he has told 2000 lies, fighting
    off and paying off porn stars, and the ever looming impeachment threat…You see?
    You should be worried about the 26 consulates Bharat has near the Pak Afghan
    border.Recommend

  • Sane sid

    Donald trump has frustrated the trouble creators all over the world…….. Get a Job Man…… Of course everyone has their own views……. he has delivered on his promises…. there is more to come for trouble creators….Recommend

  • Sane sid

    Well As I mentioned earlier….. He has successfully managed to frustrate all the trouble creators on this planet…… Just pick and count who are heyRecommend