Why do Pakistanis think Asad Umar’s claim of 10 million jobs is impossible and impractical?

Published: May 31, 2018

Opposition claims that it is impossible for PTI to accomplish the task, and that this too is simply another election slogan. PHOTO: INP

While outlining the 100-day agenda shared by the Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) recently, Asad Umar spoke about the possibility of creating 10 million jobs in five years. 

He mentioned promoting tourism and announcing new destinations in an attempt to produce thousands of employment opportunities for the youth. He also mentioned making an extra effort to attract investors in Pakistan and creating an economic link with China through China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC). Ultimately, enhanced investments and exports would create a bulk of jobs for the unemployed youth of Pakistan.

Hue and cry, sarcasm and ridicule poured in over his statement, with the consensus being that the promise of 10 million jobs is simply not possible, and is impractical. His political opponents ridiculed him by dividing the 10 million jobs to the number of total months in five years, and further splitting it into days, hours, minutes and seconds, to create an impression that it is simply not possible for PTI to accomplish the task, and that this too is simply another election slogan. They compared this idea to the billion tree tsunami project, suggesting the billion tree tsunami does not exist, and neither will these 10 million jobs.

Just as any criticism of the billion tree project is baseless, for it has become an internationally recognised project, similarly, their criticism against the employment project is groundless too. It is very childish to reject a positive project without knowing its feasibility and practical possibility, simply because it is proposed by someone whose political affiliations you disagree with.

After all, one has to wonder, how it can be impractical to produce 10 million jobs in a country with a population of 220 million, which mostly comprises of youth, who have the will and the energy to contribute to the job market.

From 2015 to 2017, the unemployment rate in Pakistan was 5.9%, and it has not declined thus far in the current year. Pakistan’s record low unemployment rate of 3.10% was last reached in 1987. In the decades since, our unemployment rate has only risen, despite a surge of youth in the country. Hence, the most urgent need in Pakistan is to create jobs and increase employment for its youth, all in an attempt to bring down unemployment.

There are two possible means to employ the lower middle class youth of Pakistan in creative work: either support small businesses, or offer jobs. Encouraging small businesses is of course important for it creates a multitude of jobs, but given the high rate of poverty in Pakistan, not many have the funds for a start-up. Thus, the other option is to hire individuals for salaried jobs, which is in many ways easier for the government to offer and manage, since supporting a business is a gamble that may not necessarily pay off.

The critics of this 10 million jobs initiative have their eye only on one side of the picture, where producing so many jobs is impossible in the government sector, and thus are terming this as an election slogan to be forgotten after achieving electoral victory. But have they forgotten about Pakistan’s corporate sector?

If PTI were to legislate proper organisation of the corporate sector (possible with Umar’s professional experience) with a law creating stricter rules to ensure a greater sense of job security to the employees, a majority of individuals would be better able to secure a future in this sector.

Taking another aspect into consideration, if PTI forms the next government, and focuses on establishing new universities in Pakistan at a rapid pace, millions of jobs will automatically be produced. We need thousands of universities to manage a population of 220 million, and it is no secret the government is struggling to provide, while the private sector is simply not enough to cater to our growing population. However, it is possible for the government to concentrate on establishing more universities in more areas of Pakistan, which would produce thousands of jobs as well as reduce illiteracy, again creating more potential in our unemployed youth.

Establishing schools and universities is thus the need of the hour, for if the existing number of schools is multiplied even by two at the end of five years, hundreds of thousands of jobs will have been produced. Similarly, tourism, as well as the billion tree project itself, will create more jobs, as the billion trees won’t take care of themselves.

At the moment, the textile industry is lagging behind due to electricity shortages and the reduction of cotton crop in cotton growing areas. However, provided some facilitation by the government, this industry can offer thousands of jobs as well. Even the simple act of providing canal water to facilitate farmers in cotton growing areas, as well as assisting them in the purchase of pesticides and fertilisers, will end up creating more jobs in an industry likely to flourish.

These are only a few of the possible means to achieve the target of 10 million jobs in the upcoming five years. There is nothing impossible about this initiative, for this project only needs dedicated people on the required posts. Every Pakistani should be optimistic about any attempts to reduce poverty and create jobs. This project is beyond political affiliations, and we all need to put partisanship aside and think on it as Pakistanis, not as members of any political party. After all, if the mission of 10 million jobs is achieved, it will be Pakistan that will have improved its position, and no matter who you support, we all benefit from this.

Zohaib Zahid

Zohaib Zahid

The author is a PhD scholar in English Linguistics at The Islamia University of Bahawalpur. He has also authored the book "Let's Revisit our English Language Policy". He tweets @ChaudaryZohaib (twitter.com/ChaudaryZohaib)

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Hashmi

    Lol first short
    100 days turned into 5 years
    Nothing much to sayRecommend

  • Israr Khan

    excellent :) health education LG and environment sectors saw massive increase in jobs and pay scale so we can safely say 10-15% of these jobs will come from here … asad umar did mention building houses massive amount of jobs in labour in skilled labour in paint those jobs as well. however we will see other sectors like cpec and petroleum industry booming in Pakistan as fata is now merged with kp u will see massive increase in jobsRecommend

  • Ali Arya

    I’m a Comp-Sci and Economics major, so I will add my technical experience. When 100 direct jobs are created, those 100 employed individuals now have money to spend on motorcycles. What happens is that increased demand creates more jobs for motorcycle salesmen, clerks in motorcycle showrooms, motorcycle assembly workers. Motorcycles need parts from tires to mufflers to headlights so the manufacturers of those parts will need to hire more people. How does the motorcycle get transported? through rail and truck, so more jobs in transportation, all those people hired to make more motorcycles will also become consumers, buying clothes, cars, healthcare, food, consumer goods, thus creating even more jobs. On top of that more taxes will be collected, savings will grow which will allow for increased investment. This is called the multiplier effectRecommend

  • Pakistani

    Why do Pakistanis think Asad Umar’s claim of 10 million jobs is impossible and impractical?
    Because Pakistani Politicians never mean what they say. But it is different now . You shall see this happen InshaAllah.Recommend

  • sterry

    Have you seen the sorry state of Peshawar’s copy cat Metrobus which is nothing short of a disaster ? Ask people in KPK whether PTI has planted a billion trees or done anything they set out to do. Tell me what is different with PTI except that they have done less in KPK than the provincial government in Punjab. Everyone travels within Pakistan and can make the comparisons of who is doing what. By the way when Pervez Khattak’s wife was denies entry on a plane for not carrying her US passport what does that tell you ?Recommend

  • sterry

    You can safely say anything but we know PTI is only good for dharnas and preventing others from doing real work. Do you forget how the dharnas scared away Chinese and Turkish leaders or the message it sent to investors over the world. PTI has no interest in governance but making tall claims but we can see the reality of what they really achieve in the disaster of the copy cat Metrobus in Peshawar. For years saying Punjab Metrobus is a waste or unnecessary or this or that – then suddenly u turn and Peshawar needs a Metrobus. Only that the one PTI makes is borrowed money from the Asian Development Bank, costs more, causes more inconvenience to people in Peshawar, is riddled with corruption, is behind schedule, has engineers jumping ship with claims of incompetence and with a cost that has ballooned to 50 % more than planned – so yeah I doubt the PTIs job claims !Recommend

  • Patwari

    Humza, is there anything new in your comment? It’s the same one,
    with some changes, that you keep repeating, like a broken record.
    Please, understand, the Man with the Bloated Face from Raiwind,
    has been removed, for life. For corruption. By the CJP of Pakistan.
    Munna Sharif will not cut it. No, charisma, no personality. And very
    short. You can barely see his head above the desk. A rotund nihari
    eater. No more dynastic politics.
    And investors? Huh?! From where? Andromeda Galaxy? Pluto?
    No fake news, please.Recommend

  • Patwari

    Humza, It’s not against the law to marry a US passport holder.
    Hasan Sharif, Hussain Sharif, sons of Nawaz, are British passport
    holders and are absconders too. See, otherwise they would have been
    deported back to Pakistan by London Metropolitan Police Dept. by now.
    Even the Raiwind Palace gardener and chaprassi have dual passports,
    so they can serve their owner and master Nawaz, in London, when he
    runs there, ooops! …absconds there. Because he will not like Adiala Jail.
    And First Daughter Mrayam Safdar has dual citizenship too. British.
    Papa Sharif made sure his progeny has dual nationalities and Dubai
    iqamas, so they can escape easily, when they need to.
    By the way, why does Maryam has a “blue Pak diplomatic passport?”
    She is not a govt. employee, never seen the inside of a diplomatic mission!?!Recommend

  • Mi ahmed

    u never mentioned the time spam for all that dude ….. u talking like Asad Umar here …. and how many jobs they have created in kpk ….. all kpk citizens come to khi Lahore and Islamabad for work aren’t they ??????Recommend

  • Mi ahmed

    ok what about the peace is khi , balochistan and CPEC,s projects ?????? who do u think brought them in …..Recommend

  • Israr Khan

    i do know how nawaz and his family looted our money and took them away to uk and that is still parked there at parkway also i know zard ari took our money and showbaz… tell me if Imran khan has taken a single penny of ours as nation and not spent where he promised … so if he has taken our money by saying i wil build cancer hospital i will build university and he has done it … well hello that only increases my confidence in him and i will pay more tax to him as i know he will use my money on me and my family unlike nawaz and zardari who will cheat and rob usRecommend