Battle of the Khans: Wajahat vs Imran – but why?

Published: February 20, 2018
SHARES
Email

Wajahat S Khan started, what I can easily rank as one of the most hilarious, and yet saddening, public meltdowns.

A few days ago, I had the “privilege” to see a video sent to me by one of my friends who happens to be a diehard Imran Khan fan. He forwarded me the video on WhatsApp while stating that it was one of the most “sincere” videos he had seen in recent times, as it indulged in what he called “constructive” criticism of Imran.

Intrigued, I started to watch the video which began by focusing on garbage cans for a few seconds. After the obviously bewildering and frankly senseless focus on garbage cans, the camera lens moved to show our most “sophisticated” anchor, Mr Wajahat S Khan. He started with what I can easily rank as one of the most hilarious and yet saddening public meltdowns.

If Wajahat’s intention was to sound serious, his humorous video was definitely an unintended and unfortunate outcome. He started by introducing himself and declaring that this message was for Imran. It was followed by his grievance – undoubtedly the real reason behind this “sincere” video – that Imran was not accessible and therefore he had no option but to talk to him via this medium.

Wajahat then started a rant about the Lodhran debacle and why the result had been expected. He followed his argument by blaming Imran’s daily routine of physical fitness and how it was contributing to his party’s non-presence in the political arena. According to Wajahat, Imran’s weekly strategy of holding one jalsa and giving an interview to one of his favourite handpicked anchors was not going to work in 2018 elections. I could feel his deep and personal pain here, as I am sure this video would not have been made if that “favourite handpicked” anchor was Wajahat himself.

Moreover, he also asserted how Nawaz Sharif had fooled people and successfully sold the narrative of “mujhe kyun nikala” (why was I disqualified). He went on to criticise Imran for not coming to Karachi to fill in the vacuum created by the withering of Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM).

The most hilarious part was when he removed his sunglasses and said, “be like a Khan”. That was overacting at its “best” and I seriously thought that he would breakdown and start crying.

After watching the video, I was initially left dumbfounded and confused as I did not know what to make of it. Here was an anchor, trying to teach politics to Imran and also making assertions that Nawaz had “fooled” supposedly simpleminded people.

But then it dawned on me that the entire video was nothing but an attention-gaining gimmick, made worse by the fact that the presenter apparently thinks that he is intellectually superior to the rest and therefore Imran should listen to him. It became clear to me when rumours were abound, suggesting that the real reason behind this video was that Imran had perhaps not invited him to a meeting which took place with several media personnel at Bani Gala a few days ago. This apparently infuriated Wajahat and led him to make this emotional video.

Imran Khan meeting with media anchor persons in Bani Gala.

Posted by Imran Khan (official) on Saturday, February 10, 2018

Furthermore, the video contained insulting remarks about Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N), its leader and Pakistani voters, which frankly were in poor taste.

But Wajahat’s antics and dubious objectives aside, did he really offer “constructive” criticism? Is he correct in his assertion that Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) was in decline and in fact below than what they had been prior to the 2013 general election? Was there something really wrong with PTI which also led to the debacle in Lodhran?

I am afraid Wajahat is quite off the mark when he made the claim that PTI had been stronger prior to the 2013 election. There is, in fact, no comparison here, as PTI has actually improved its electoral prowess quite a lot since 2013. Back then, just prior to elections, most of the surveys (such as Gallup) had given PTI substantially less than 20% of the expected vote share. Now, however, recent surveys place PTI comfortably above 20%, which by all means is a sizeable improvement. Yes, it is true that PML-N remains the most favourite party but PTI is expected to give it a much tougher fight in the forthcoming election.

Secondly, Wajahat also implied that despite the Panama verdict, PML-N was strong due to the failure of Imran to capitalise enough on the situation. One of the major problems with Wajahat, and for that matter most of these urban-based anchors, is that they think that the Panama verdict is an issue which resonates with the entire Pakistan. Frankly, this is not the case as Panama leaks or for that matter “corruption of politicians” are issues which only Pakistan’s urban white-collar class deem important. Imran’s failure is not that he did not capitalise enough on the verdict but rather that he has overemphasised on it. In fact, after the verdict, all PTI has done is to keep on obsessively discussing it instead of trying to expand its message beyond it. Even today, it is relying more on favourable National Accountability Bureau (NAB) judgments rather than talking about other issues.

Ironically, Wajahat himself had been making tall claims that how PML-N was on its way out just a few months ago, in a very derogatory way, on Twitter. The fact that he is now babbling about PTI’s supposed failure, shows how he himself is off the mark and, to be honest, clueless.

His assessment of the Lodhran by-poll election was also way off the mark. If anything, Imran and PTI had campaigned harder than PML-N in the constituency. The defeat did not occur because Imran’s party was “nowhere to be seen” but mainly because of local factors and also because PML-N, despite ousting of Nawaz, remains firmly entrenched at the grassroot level.

Yes, it is true that PML-N’s narrative of “mujhe kyun nikala” is also resonating with people, but that is taking place in the urban areas. Rural areas, in general, work differently and politics is often highly localised.

Third, Wajahat’s suggestion that after MQM’s fracturing, PTI should take over and handle issues like garbage collection, was extremely senseless. PTI cannot “takeover” in the sense Wajahat was suggesting without winning through local elections. I don’t really understand what the purpose of that suggestion was.

In my humble opinion, Wajahat needs to learn some humility and stop dragging the public into his personal spats to the forefront. And frankly, Imran should also refrain from listening to someone like him!

raza.habib

Raza Habib Raja

The author is a recent Cornell graduate and currently pursuing his PhD in political science at Maxwell School, Syracuse University. He has also worked for a leading development finance institution in Pakistan. He is a freelance journalist whose works have been published at Huffington Post, Dawn (Pakistan), Express Tribune (Pakistan) and Pak Tea House. He tweets @razaraja (twitter.com/razaraja?lang=en)

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Omar

    PTI is doomed after Khan sahib’s third marriage.Recommend

  • S M

    Raza sahib, you clearly missed the point. What appears hilarious to you, resonated well with most Pakistanis including PTI supporters. You tried to appear reasonable but your article is full of personal feelings and emotions. There are several ways to interpret the video and you chose the most distant one. Your interpretation is indeed hilarious as the video was anything but hilarious. This is my opinion and is not intended to hurt anyone’s feelings. Apologies in advance if you or anyone feels that way.Recommend

  • Hamza

    This is a person who is a true supporter of change and a true supporter of what Imran khan stands for and he is simply expressing his frustration at IKs recent inaction and inability to capitalize on his recent gains. I see nothing wrong with this and as a PTI and iK supporter i feel there is a lot of truth in his tirade. the writer of this blog seems to have his own agenda and this article doesnt speak any sense.

    IK should see this! And act on it. His recent and newly adopted laid back attitude will cost him another election even after such an amazing victory in the supreme court.

    I hope pti wins for the sake of change and for the sake of a government that doesn’t serve a royal family like the bhuttos and sharifs. For that to happen IK must pull up his socks and get to work.Recommend

  • Parvez

    You Sir, have just done Wajahat a favor by writing about this.Recommend

  • https://www.cartrade.pk/ cartradepk

    hmmm Looking forward to 2018 Battle of Titans Good for Pakistan and Let the best Man / Party Win the Election !Recommend

  • MJ

    Khan has been seeking spiritual guidance for a few years now. Guidance that he uses to do anything in his personal life as well as political one. He is now using the power harnessed in mystical rocks that he wears in rings on his fingers to gain the extra edge. He is also frequenting a bunch of mazaars . He needs powerful dead saints on his side as well. How can such a comprehensive thought our strategy fail?Recommend

  • Israr Khan

    In my humble opinion, Wajahat needs to learn some humility and stop dragging the public into his personal spats to the forefront. And frankly, Imran should also refrain from listening to someone like him!……….. so should u raja gee :)
    yes wajahat when interviewed ik kept on behaving like he was his buddy or something wajahat could not handle fame and the way he was seen bending down on his knees infront of nawaz the then pm so ppl like him well they come and go but they got personal issues more to do with personality nothing to do with idiology and i do not think he is even a journalist ..Recommend

  • Raghu

    I agree 100% with the writer. I also received this video. After a few seconds i stopped the video because it did not make sense and I was wasting my time. Therefore I deleted it without any 2nd thought.Recommend

  • Isfandyar

    Thanks Raza for writing this. It was a stupid video of a disgruntled anchor. That is how it should be taken.Recommend

  • Shakir Lakhani

    IK knows he will never become prime minister. His only ambition is to disrupt the government (present as well as future), so that the country does not progress. He may not know it, but whatever he does makes our enemies very happy.Recommend

  • Adil

    with due respect ,if Author would care to focus on message given by WK. which is a bitter truth and ground reality , he could have judged it on merit but he focused on WK personal grievances –Recommend

  • Waseem Nawaz

    The author has actually totally missed the point here. Where as one can have a sense of humour about Wajahat’s desperation on the video but i think it’s not reasonable to doubt his intent based on the authors own prejudices ,opinions and assertions.
    What this guy is saying is actually is quite close to the mark and reflects the urgency IK requires. But alas we all have our failings and unfortunately the desperation has led Ik to the hands of a peerni where as he should have backed his own mettle and belief system.

    P.s Focus shot on the garbage would resonate a lot with the people living in Karachi then someone in Syracuse. Just sayinRecommend

  • gp65

    So I have noticed that even strong supporters of Imran Khan and people who actively work to expose corruption – Rauf Klasra and Amir Mateen seem to be disappointed with Khan. Could there be more to the issue than an anchor feeling sour?Recommend

  • Raza khan kpk

    By the way there is no doubt that Imran is the reason to expose, strong opposition to looters trying his best to clean the country from the corrupt mafia thuggish shameless barbaric looters such as nawaz his family and mr10% certified criminal thug corrupt zardari his family and his all his downline chamchas.Recommend

  • Ali Abbas

    Haha…sry but your analysis of the lodhran election is totally off the charts…and therefore also the article…disgruntled maybe…but WK made his point . He said it.The vote in Lodhran was against IKs policies of continuous negativity and repetition…his strongest candidate lost…why did PTI go into depression after the election ..where is the Gallup reflection on the ground …sry but no where. It seems the author of this article had a meltdownRecommend

  • Ali Abbas

    BTW is this the same Gallup survey that said Trump would lose the elections …Lol……IK is distracted, pompous, and negative. I was a PTI voter…include that in your Gallup surveyRecommend

  • Maqsood Zafar Malik

    I think Author wants to fire gun from WK’s shoulder. We can see the hatred in the writing for WK. I guess his video was sincere and this article is just a piece to get attention or in other words “nothing but an attention-gaining gimmick.”Recommend

  • Ahmad Farooq

    Please delete this ‘Khans’ word since none of these, Reema Khan, Maira Khan, Fawad Khan, Imran Khan, Wajahat Khan, are KhansRecommend

  • Parvez

    Sorry for the delayed response……yes, many are disappointed with him.Recommend