If Pakistan follows Saudi Arabia’s footsteps, why not take a leaf from its sexual harassment law also?

Published: June 6, 2018

We need only touch the tip of the iceberg to gauge the predicament of both men and women in Pakistan’s ugly avenue of sexual harassment.

One would think that the loose cannon that is the rising monarch of Saudi Arabia, long since the world’s Muslim hegemony, would not have thought all its radical initiatives through. And with good reason too. But recent endeavours are making us think otherwise.

From where we stood, the lifting of the decades-long driving ban for women, only weeks from being set into motion, was nothing if not far flung. But it’s now being tailed by an impressive pre-emptive measure. Put short, Prince Mohammed bin Salman’s (MBS) Vision 2030 might just be a concrete plan, and not just a ludicrous emancipation campaign.

Setting lose their women after clipping their wings for as far as salvageable memory goes, will foster some inexorable concerns from within. And this is not in reference solely to their rusty driving skills. The Shura Council foresaw the colossal wave of sexual harassment that MBS cleared the way for, and approved of an impressive draft law that has left quite a stir.

Like any other penalty in the country, the price for sexual harassment is unrelenting. Marked at as high as a five-year prison sentence and an $80,000 fine, the very sound of it is enough of a deterrent on its own. Women’s rights activist, Dr Najat ElSaeed, termed the law a timely introduction, in an interview with AlHurra;

“If the law had not been passed, there would have been a lot of issues for women who drive.”

MBS may have made Saudi women content by giving them a taste of freedom, and also security, once this law receives royal approval, but this will inevitably invite demands from other parts hoping to bear fruit. For instance, he frivolously opened doors for Saudi cinema, concerts and mixed-gender celebrations – for which his ancestors must be turning in their graves– but there is a gaping legislative vacuum in areas such as intellectual property rights in the film industry.

And if the circumstances weren’t already ironic enough, the defacto King and his social reform agenda are receiving serious backlash for the arrests of 11 activists. Most of these are women arrested only days from the passing of the law. But then again, the royals have forever wallowed around in impunity.

Saudi Arabia may be a rookie in the field of sexual harassment, on a comparative level if nothing else, but many of its Muslim satellites in the developing world aren’t. Pakistan, for one, has amassed quite a record of its own. Some incidents stuck, others went in one ear and came out the other, either way substantiating the fact that we’re a perfectly desensitised lot. We need only touch the tip of the iceberg to gauge the predicament of both men and women in Pakistan’s ugly avenue of sexual harassment.

In Pakistan, making sexual harassment a criminal offence is still a welcome development. Meanwhile Saudi Arabia criminalised it without a second thought, and despite how liberal they make themselves out to be, they are still the most conservative theocratic monarchy on the map. So what’s holding us back, especially after our evident failure to grapple with our insurmountable number of cases in this year alone?

The two legal provisions that govern sexual harassment in Pakistan are the Protection against Harassment of Women at the Workplace Act of 2010 and Section 509 of the Pakistan Criminal Penal Code. Looking at the first of these alone is enough to ascertain the flaws. The title of the section, ‘Insulting modesty and causing sexual harassment’, proves lawmakers have barely understood underlying issues around harassment and are not trained to a high enough degree on ethical standards. The word modesty itself is subjective and thus interpreted at the discretion of the presiding judge.

An absence of state-funded legal advice and a police force incapable of handling survivors of violence is only scratching the surface. Deeply entrenched patriarchy makes the efforts of the handful with the courage to ‘come out’ futile, by mounting a dangerously low glass ceiling over their heads.

For one, in order to solve a problem you need to recognise that there is one. And the only palpable recognition we see in these parts is the outrage channelled online. Broadly speaking, no one here is looking to emulate the Prince’s Vision 2030. In fact, emulation is too distasteful a prospect in this regard, while Pakistan fails to merely recognise the newfound freedoms Saudi women are being adorned in.

On the contrary, we watch all other Saudi developments unfold with admiration, and follow suit without a second thought. It’s almost like regimes in these parts cherry pick the laws they find appealing to plant them on home soil, and conveniently brush others under the rug. Women’s concerns are unfortunately still synonymous to profane talk.

More importantly still, we aren’t arranged such that command flows only from one individual unequivocally and unquestionably, which would make passing of laws quick and simple. Instead we’re a mess of a democracy, but a democracy nonetheless, complete with debate and deliberation six ways from Sunday, making any law, especially ones as sensitive as this, out of reach.

For now, it’s safe to say that the present regime is a chip off the old block; just as dormant as any other in the face of what really matters. Maybe it’ll also take an untethered revolutionary to bring this about for us.

Minahil Mahmud

Minahil Mahmud

The author has an unflagging passion for literature, women empowerment and international affairs. With a yearning for adventure she is patiently waiting for Gandalf to knock at her door.

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Xara Riaz

    “On the contrary, we watch all other Saudi developments unfold with admiration, and follow suit without a second thought.”.

    I’m curious to know what are other developments/laws of Saudi Arabia we ‘blindly follow’?Recommend

  • Syed

    Sexual harassment in saudi’s, r u joking?Recommend

  • Parvez

    Important topic …. nicely expressed.
    The political atmosphere in Pakistan thrives on ‘ political patronage ‘ and that in itself makes it difficult to pass laws for the betterment of women. The other stumbling block is our snail paced judicial system , especially the criminal one…..and speed is just one of the problems ailing it.Recommend

  • Xahid

    Where did you see Pakistan is following Saudi’s footsteps?

    I see nothing resemblance in both countries.Recommend

  • sterry

    Your are very correct. I don’t think anyone in Pakistan would want to follow Saudi developments blindly because that country is seen as less developed socially and politically than Pakistan. Pakistani women who have lived there all want to come home eventually and we all hear about how widespread sexual abuse – not only of domestic staff women (eg Philipinos) but child abuse is rampant but not widely reported. It’s a country where laws are applied only to those with no power or to poor foreigners but it does not apply to Westerners who can do whatever they want in their compounds or to the rich elite.Recommend

  • Atsuf Kalum

    BECAUSE laws are applied almost FAIRLY in KSA, For such a strong law you have to have a proper support system of other laws.

    in Pakistan such a law will become a weapon for blackmailing, exploitation for power crazy people. Just Imagine ladies like Gulalai and Reham Khan taking few curore Rs. from NS and blaming IK for harassment and that would be end of his carrier.

    BTW, just to add there is no mention in the western world of this awesome Saudi law to protect women. If this was in place there wouldn’t be any #MeToo movement.Recommend

  • Akbar
  • Patwari

    “…follow suit…” was a figure of expression. Not literally.
    The author stated some Islamic nations cherry pick.
    Pakland does not follow Saudia blindly. Saudia, where
    clerics say it’s ok to beat your wife lightly.
    Pakland does not have any gender friendly laws. Period.
    Pakland, is where women, have no rights, are considered
    chattels of their husbands. Where girls are brought back,
    under false pretenses, from abroad, from England, Italy,
    to marry men 20 years older than them. By their mothers
    to boot!.
    Where “honor killings” are rampant. Where a pregnant girl
    was stoned to death by her father and brother on the front
    steps of the Lahore High Court!. Another shot and killed
    at steps of the court because she married by her choice!
    Same place, where 5 girls were strangled to death in
    Swat. Because they sang and may have danced behind
    purdah, in the bride ceremony of mehndi! Good grief!!!
    Where a village panchayat can order a gang rape of a woman.
    That’s Mukhtaran Mai.
    So, YOU should worry about how YOU can impact womens’ lives
    in Land of the Pure. Instead of questioning the blogger’s veracity.Recommend

  • Patwari

    Humza, did you conduct a survey of Pak women in Saudia?
    No, You did not. Speak for yourself only. No made up statistics.Recommend

  • Hareem Mehar

    When A women Says ”No” that means No in any language. A real Man will never hit a woman and a Real man will not sexually harass a woman, only mentally naive men hit women and sexually impotent will rape kids and harass women.Recommend

  • Rida Haroon

    we are living in a sick society with a deficient system which doesn’t allow peaceful protest against sexual harassment of women. #metoo #sexualharassment #womenrightsRecommend

  • Sara Khan

    I’m totally against with this statement. We are not following Saudi Arabia’s footsteps. After Meesha Shafi’s brave steps i hope so we are going to a better society.Recommend