Lesvos: From a tourist heaven to the ‘refugee island’ of drowned boats and lifejackets

Published: June 4, 2018

I found the place to be perfect for killing one’s hopes and dreams. PHOTO: IBRAHIM TARIQ

I recently had the chance to visit Lesvos, a tiny Greek island located a few kilometres from the Turkish Riviera. This picturesque island, which was once a tourist heaven, is now commonly referred to as the refugee island, given the high influx of refugees since 2014 following the wars in Syria, Iraq and Afghanistan.

Whilst there as a volunteer, much of my time was spent realising how borders can sometimes prove fatal

As I visited the shores of Skala, I could see Turkey through my binoculars. While many refugee boats arrive weekly from Turkey, at one point in 2015, an average total of 350 refugees journeyed here every day. These individuals did not only include those from war-torn countries, but also from states like Pakistan, Bangladesh and many West African countries. These are people who flee social and economic marginalisation, and aspire to settle in Western-European countries like Germany, Netherlands and France, in hopes for a better living.

A view through the binoculars. This journey, despite being only 45-minutes long, has proved fatal for thousands

Skala, where smuggler boats with refugees arrive from South-Western Turkey

The journey they attempt, however, is full of dangers; the first one being at the hands of smugglers, thanks to the lack of a humane and orderly way for the refugees to enter the European Union (EU). For this route, the smugglers are not quite interested in delivering the refugees alive, as it is the last stage of their trip. While they charge exorbitant prices, the provided boats are of extremely low quality, with little shade and minimum amount of fuel, eventually making them end up here in significantly worse conditions.

Mytilini is now a retreat for humanitarian workers

The Mytilini city centre

As I conversed with Adil, the founder of the NGO ‘Movement on the Ground’, he explained that while it was illegal to push the refugee boats to Turkey, Greek officials often did not indulge in rescuing activities until boats reached the shore. Officials often argue that if the migrants know the EU will rescue their ships, it would lead to many more making the trip. While I failed to find any relation between the two, I only saw this as something adding to the chances of fatality through drowning.

At the Lifejacket Graveyard, I saw drowned boats and lifejackets filled with non-sailable materials like Styrofoam, which only served to remind me of the many Aylan Kurdi’s we have lost thus far.

The lifejacket graveyard

My next stop was the Moria camp, a refugee camp controlled by the Greek Central Government. Here, the refugees are made to stay for an uncertain time period, until they have received a decision for their asylum application.

As I met Kamran, a Hazara from Quetta who has lived here for the past two years, he described the process as painfully slow, especially after the EU-Turkey deal limited the number of refugees the EU was to take annually. While all the refugees have to go through this process, it gives special preference to Syrian nationals given the concurrency of the crisis, while delaying most others for a period of up to four years.

A Pakistani refugee from Lahore working as a cook says unemployment for several years pushed him to take this journey

While their asylum process is still underway, refugees are barred from exiting the island. As Kamran brisk walked with me across the camp to give me a quick glimpse of the living conditions, I found the place to be perfect for killing one’s hopes and dreams. This former military detention centre, with a capacity of around 1,500, was now being used to cramp over 7,000 refugees.

Omer, a refugee from Syria, said,

“If this camp was full of 7,000 animals, there would be an outcry around the world, because you cannot keep animals like that.”

While I saw piles of waste spread all over the camp, the cell where refugees waited in line for food smelled only of urine and sweat. Residents complained of electricity shortages, which were common and often continued for over a week, killing many during the winters due to the absence of heating systems.

As correctional psychologists may argue, such distressful environments lead even those who haven’t had prior negative experiences to develop mental health problems, which seemed visible at Moria. Here, group fights, fires, and rapes are reported almost daily. The state of this camp articulates how when passive expression fails, states resort to physical violence as the only means to deter the undesired movement of people.

“Borders Kill” seen at the lifejacket graveyard

Graffiti in Mytilene

While the Greek Central Government and the EU may be blamed for having a policy of hostility towards these refugees, my understanding of the work of several NGOs and the local municipality made me believe that the inhospitable policies of states do not necessarily reflect the voice of the majority.

Seen in Mytilene

At the lifejacket graveyard

Among the many inspirational stories I heard was Kara Teppe, another refugee camp run by the local municipality and NGOs. As I was volunteering to add heat-screens to each camp, I found this place to be the polar opposite of Moria. Here, the roughly 1,250 residents have access to a typing centre, dance theatre and a modern community kitchen. Smiles were more visible, while some even expressed the idea of settling here for good if they had the choice. This shocking contrast displayed the varying attitudes of the central government and the majority of locals.

Typing Learning Centre in Kara Teppe

This trip made me realise that states, which are currently all built around the idea of protecting their wealth and the privilege of their populations at the cost of marginalising others, strongly need to readdress their policies towards refugees. It is against any notion of humanity to restrict those who have either fled political persecution, or life as a sweatshop worker dreaming of a better wage. At the end of the day, the inhospitable nature of borders which limits the unconditional movement of people speaks of nothing but the hypocrisy of state governments who wrongly boast of globalisation and diversity.

Ibrahim Tariq

Ibrahim Tariq

The author is currently pursuing a degree in International Politics at the Georgetown University School of Foreign Service in Qatar, and likes writing on issues of historical and social interest. He tweets @ibrahimtariq_ (twitter.com/ibrahimtariq_)

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Patwari

    Great article. Great photographs. Excellent piece regarding the worldwide refugee crisis.
    Which, to a great extent, was created by Western nations. Starting with ‘Dubya’ Bush.
    Then there are dictators, absolute monarchs, fanatics, thugs, in power in the Third World Countries, who also perpetuate this tragedy, and perpetuated it, in the past.
    Mugabe, Modi, Zia, Qadafi, Saddam, el Sisi plus the current thug in Yemen, come to mind.
    Kudos to the author for bringing out the awareness. Please keep up the good work.
    However, must digress on one small [maybe?] point.
    “…the inhospitable nature of borders that limit the unconditional movement of people…”
    If there are no border restrictions, then half of Hindustan and Pakistan would be sitting
    in “Vilayat” [England]. At least those who can afford the airlines tickets.
    Also, nearly all of Afghanis would be camped in Karachi, instead of just half of the population, currently. Then all of Egypt would be cramped inside, the richest country in the world,…Qatar.
    [see, they speak the same language too,…Egypt-Qatar]
    All of Somalia would be inside Cape Town, South Africa. That would include el Shabab. and
    AbouBakr Shekau, straight from Nigeria.
    Not to mention that all of Philippines would be lined up to get in Australia.
    By the way, was in Doha, just last month. Wow! It looks futuristic. All those buildings!Recommend

  • 19640909rk .

    Which refugee crisis came because of modi?Recommend

  • Patwari

    Hmm, well, see, we can start with Hindustani Occupied Kashmir.
    People would try to slide out, edgewise, if they could. Some
    do, ending up in Pak Kashmir, Ladakh, Nepal, Jalandar, Himachal
    We can move to Mizoram, Meghalaya, Assam. Kerala. And the elephant
    in the glass house, known as “Arunachal Prasesh”. The whole state wants
    to grow legs and walk out of Hindustan.The Hindutva Mothership.
    And join China. With which it has all kinds of connections.
    Fact is, people can be “REFUGEES” in their own country!
    Like Indian West Bengalis, Kashmiris, wants to escape the oppressive
    Modi Sarkar’s rule and near genocidal conditions; to other parts of
    Hinduland. Because their current living conditions are worse than a Greek
    refugee camp. More like living in a Nazi concentration camp. With guards.
    After all, they are just minorities. And can be shot and killed anytime.
    Why all this? Because Modi Sarkar wants a Hindu rashtra.Recommend

  • TheMeckMan

    Sadly poor Greece has its own economic crisis so the Western European approach is that much more abhorrent and truly indifferent In that regard Merkel is no better than Trump – filtering out the refugees to only take those that expand the economy of Germany…Recommend