Why should feudals apologize?

Published: June 30, 2011
SHARES
Email

We must try to understand people and they come from before we pass judgments and condemn them to hell.

I have grown up hearing all the stereotypes on television in newspapers.

Feudals drive big jeeps (who cares how many books they read?).

Feudals are the reason the country can’t prosper.

Feudals abuse people in the name of tradition.

But this ‘wadera’ boogeyman image is not accurate. I’m not saying that exploitation of the poor does not exist in rural Pakistan, but the facts that are often ignored are:

Exploitation is not exclusive to the agricultural community.

For every landlord who mistreats the people who depend on him for a livelihood, there are at least three who are actively working to provide services (services that every government has failed to provide) such as education, medical care, and some sense of security to their people.

I would even go as far as to argue that urbanites treat their domestic employees far worse and with much less kindness than a rural agriculturalist.

How many factory owners attend the wedding of an employee or an employee’s child?

Agriculturalists actively participate in their people’s weddings, and in many cases even pay for each and every wedding that takes place in the vicinity of their land. When someone dies in the rural area, this so called “evil feudal” is often the first person to help make arrangements for the funeral, and ensure the deceased’s family is looked after.

How many factory owners or bankers or businessmen can you name who do the same?

When was the last time you attended the wedding of your driver’s son?

Do you even know how many children your servant has?

The other aspect of the “feudal tradition,” that is criticized, is the concept of the jirga or fasila. This is when a person in the rural community, whose opinion is respected by both parties (this is not necessarily the richest man in the area) is asked to settle a dispute.  There are some cases (such as the case of Mukhtaran Mai) where these parallel judges have abused their position and have passed judgments that are inhumane to say the least. There is no justification for such horrible acts. But, just like we did not abolish the judiciary for setting Raymond Davis free, or exonerating some of the men who raped Mukhtaran Mai, we cannot do away with a system that in most cases works – especially if there is no alternative.

‘Feudals’ or rather people who are perceived to be ‘feudal,’ especially young men, are often stereotyped as nasty characters with a ‘Napoleon’ complex.  It is partially an urban legend that feudals crash parties, kidnap and rape young women, and shoot anyone who tries to stand in their way.

The stories that these people choose to ignore are the ones where a drunken young man from a prominent business family harasses a ‘feudal’ youth at a party, then follows him home and in the process of the confrontation shoots the feudal’s brother and servant.

Or, what about the young entrepreneur who kidnapped his girlfriend after she tried to breakup with him, locked her up and raped her for three days straight?

The point is that in Pakistan money leads some people to believe that they are untouchable and can behave in any way they wish, with those who are less fortunate or weaker than them. These people can be ship-owners, industrialists, farmers, stockbrokers, lawyers, doctors, or people from any other background.

What I believe the media needs to do is acknowledge that Pakistan’s problem is not evil feudals. There are people in every part of society that do evil and unthinkable things. These people should be dealt with as individual criminals and people who share similar backgrounds should not be stereotyped.

Every citizen of Pakistan must make an active effort to stop trying to find scapegoats. Blaming one group for all problems of a country leads to criminal acts.

So, let’s try and be more tolerant as a society. Let’s try and understand where people are coming from.

Instead of flying off to Thailand to go snorkeling, why not visit Astola Island?

Instead of dying to get invited to Royal Ascot why not drive up to Shandur and watch polo played, the way the people who invented the game play it?

Pakistan is a beautiful country, filled with many wonders and many different types of people.  Let’s all try to understand these people and the places they come from before we pass judgement and condemn them to hell.

This article has been revised to reflect the following correction:

Correction: June 30

An earlier version of this article stated that the author belonged to a feudal family, this was incorrect and we would like to apologize for the regrettable misrepresentation.

 

 

Basharat A Durrani

Basharat A Durrani

A businessman who enjoys fishing, riding horses, plays polo and travels as much as possible.

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Faraz Talat

    This article seems to have been conjured out of the need to controvert a fact-based concept simply for the sake of personal entertainment.
    .
    If the author thinks that the jirga system works nearly as well as the court system, then I encourage him to do more research on the matter. Clearly our court systems are far from flawless, but they’re still loads better than the jirga system where punishments rarely ever fit the crimes, and the verdicts are often based on subjective opinions than on real evidence.
    .
    Feudalism is slavery’s ugly cousin, and we must strive to get rid of it instead of advocating it. A slave owner too can be kind and compassionate towards his “property”, but that doesn’t make the system any easier for a sane, civilized human to deal with.Recommend

  • Usman

    Completely disagree with the argument & conclusion.
    And I am curious what kind of statistical claim is for every bad feudal there is a good one – Where did it come from?

    Feudal is in my opinion, amongst the primary issues that has hampered the social and economic development of this country. Watch: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xv01x27dEPURecommend

  • Kinzah

    @ anny marri…if you be kind enough to pay attention i asked how much an average fuedal paid in taxes versus the rich mean urbanite?….i am aware of the law you very kindly offered to inform me abt…and im glad you accept how pathetically its managed…but you do you know what that means? Its a crime against the state NOT to pay taxes…and to say our systems are poor….simply DOES NOT make it okay to steal from the state…Recommend

  • Riaz

    Chill out on the blame game. Tax tax tax, they do pay taxes. Anyway feudalism is one of the factors we need to get rid of for sure, but lets get rid of Zardari first. One major disaster at a time people. Recommend

  • MAHAR

    I am from a “fuedal family”. if it werent for my grandfather, there would have been NO ONE supporting these people, no one listening to their problems and no one pushing them forward. they would have been living in just another poverty stricken neglected village where people wouldnt have enough food to eat and shelter to live under, let alone education and medical services. there is an unofficial NGO running there where all sorts of help is given to the people. anyone who has the slightest doubt may come stay in the village and explore as you please without hinderence of any kind.

    as far as the fuedal system is concerned, for every square piece of land: it is owned by the wadera, but one farmer works on it, whatever the farmer sows, he takes half of that, the other half is taken by the wadera. the wadera then invests back into it, buying seed, fertilizer etc. thats done by the land owner, NOT the worker. sounds fair enough to me. there are three schools in the village (a primary mixed, one secondary for boys and one for girls) and one hospital AND girls education is encouraged. the system is such that if you do not have a fair heart, and your intentions are all wrong, then it is very easy to go all evil on it.. but then again thats is the case with almost everyother industry. however, like the article says, everyone is not evil, there actually are good peopleout there too.

    and may i add one last thing. land in the interior costs much less than land in urban areas, im sure you will all agree with that. there are many people in the cities who own lots of land too. so if i own 500 acres in the interior, and you own 500 in karachi, who has more? and if i treat the person working on mine with dignity, respect and loyalty, i fail to see where i am going wrong,Recommend

  • mahar

    @kinza, please enlighten the rest of us where you got the information that ALL feudals dont pay taxes? there are a million politicians, a million industrialists and a whole lot of other fools who tactfully dodge their taxes too. i would love to see your tax statement,Recommend