#KarachivsLahore: Three reasons why Karachi is not ready to host international cricket

Published: September 21, 2017
SHARES
Email

Passions run high on the field, with big hits and big wickets causing a flurry of excitement. PHOTO: AFP

To an ordinary person, September 12, 2017, may seem like yet another date, but for us Pakistanis, it was reliving the past, contemplating the present and gearing up for the future all in one.

Pakistani cricketers pose for a photograph with trophy after winning the third and final Twenty20 International match against World XI. Photo AFP

History will remember this date because 15 of the most skillful and courageous men stepped onto the ‘barren land’ with the aim of not only ousting the Pakistan cricket team, but also to eradicate the looming threat of terrorism from the land of the pure, once and for all.

A fleet of brightly decorated autorickhaws ferried the World XI players inside the Gaddafi Stadium, PPakistan v World XI, 1st T20I, Independence Cup 2017, Lahore, September 12, 2017. Photo: AFP

The realisation of such a dream not only meant that international cricket was finally returning as a feast for the eyes of the cricket-hungry fans, it also meant that Lahore was buzzing again.

A Pakistani fan holds a placard aloft to welcome international cricket in the country, Pakistan v World XI, 1st T20I, Independence Cup 2017, Lahore, September 12, 2017. Photo: AFP

Approximately a fortnight prior to the World XI’s arrival to the Gaddafi Stadium Lahore, whilst the Lahoris were gearing up for the intense tussle by lining themselves into queues with the aim of finally getting their hands on the tickets, some of the outsiders were unhappy and quite angered to say the least.

Fans residing approximately 1,271 kilometres from the centre of attention, in Karachi to be more precise, had a bittersweet response to the long-awaited return of international cricket. Whilst they were ecstatic about the matches, they were discontent with the fact that none of them could experience the action live in their own city.

There is still a genuine cry being heard from the city of Karachi, but here are three reasons why Karachi is still not yet ‘completely ready’ to host international cricket.

1)Legitimate security concerns

The first and most obvious reason for not hosting international cricket matches in Karachi is the political instability surrounding the city of lights that brings with it real security concerns. Even though the die-hard cricket fans residing in Karachi are most likely to disagree with this, but if word within Pakistan is that Karachi is not yet ‘as safe as Lahore’, how can we expect rumours circulating internationally not be taken seriously?

Just like the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) has given special emphasis to Lahore, it needs to concentrate on Karachi by hosting more local and national tournaments. What the PCB can and should do is plan and work towards organising a few play-offs for next year’s Pakistan Super League (PSL) at the National Stadium in Karachi.

Mar 5, 2017 Peshawar Zalmi celebrate their victory over Quetta Gladiators in the 2017 PSL Final. Photo: AFP

These matches would serve as a litmus test for Karachi and provide everyone concerned with a clearer snapshot of Karachi’s security situation and readiness to host international games in the future. Gradually, as things start to go smoothly from there on, Karachiites will finally get to see their heroes perform right in front of their eyes.

2)Administrative inefficiency

Instead of creating dispute between fans from two major cities, rationality must prevail over everything else. One must realise that Lahore is the hub of PCB and therefore, facilitation of administrative tasks is much more efficient in and around the Gaddafi Stadium as compared to the National Stadium.

In order to host an event of such magnitudes, the PCB and the local government must be on the same page. Whilst many may disagree with the style and stature of Shehbaz Sharif as a politician and Punjab’s chief minister, he is very experienced in handling such international events and knows how to instruct his men to ensure foolproof security for such a high profile tournament.

Army soldiers stand guard at the entrance of the venue as spectators queue up to make their way in, Pakistan v World XI, 1st T20I, Independence Cup 2017, Lahore, September 12, 2017. Photo: AFP

The Lahoris witnessed, in its true essence, the extremely proactive participation of the local government, which eventually led to a successful tournament.

3)Crucial distance factor

Whilst hosting such a huge event, every intricate detail must be taken into consideration since the pride of our entire country is at stake. A certain distance factor comes into play whilst analysing the situation. We know that guest players are always invited to stay at the most highly secured hotels. The foolproof hotel in Lahore is approximately six kilometres from the stadium, whereas the hotel in Karachi is 11 kilometres away from the stadium. Thus, the risk of a potential attack is higher in Karachi as compared to Lahore.

Pakistani security personnel also made a visit to Gaddafi stadium, regarding the security arrangements for the upcoming Independence Cup. Photo: AP

In addition to the distance factor, roads surrounding the Gaddafi Stadium can be and are easily blocked without disrupting traffic, whereas National Stadium is adjacent to a major thoroughfare that cannot be blocked for multiple days, unlike Gaddafi’s security plan.

Whilst my words may hurt and anger a quite a few people, I am only genuinely trying to put the Pakistani interest of international cricket above everything else. Even when everything is done and dusted, at the end of the day, I am a Pakistani first and a Lahori after. For me, and like many others out there, cities don’t matter as long as radiant smiles on the faces of the fans are here to stay, hopefully forever.

Raacikh Asghar

Raacikh Asghar

The author is a student of Political Science and has a keen interest in cricket. He also worked for The Nation's Sports Web Desk.

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Mubashir Mahmood

    For 1st reason please see this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terrorist_incidents_in_Pakistan_in_2017

    For 3rd reason:
    If any security expert read this reason he will laugh all day. (Lahore is approximately six kilometres from the stadium, whereas the hotel in Karachi is 11 kilometres away from the stadium.) It is 6 KM from Lahore not 60 meters.Recommend

  • irfan shamim farooqui

    Quite kiddish and unrealistic column.Recommend

  • Ahmed

    Karachi is precisely 1250 km away from Lahore not 12000 km as it is mentioned in your article.Recommend

  • peter pan

    We need to remember also that the attack on the SriLankan team was In Lahore- or am I mistaken; The hub of the Punjabi Taliban is Lahore- or am I mistaken, Lahore has the unfortunate distinction of hosting all the major attacks by religious fanatics and TTP against the Pakistan Army and police- Need I say more.Recommend

  • peter pan

    Please note also that the security of Karachi is handled by the rangers and monitored by the Corps Commander Karachi- not the corrupt PPP GovernmentRecommend

  • Haris (Canada)

    Spoken like a true Lahori. I wonder where The Srilankan International
    Cricket Team was attached in Pakistan, for the life of me I cannot recall the
    name of the city :S

    Three reason only my friend, you Lahoris can do way better
    than this, come on stop short changing yourself and come up with at least 10
    next time.Recommend

  • Asad Zaidi

    Yet wasnt it in Lahore where the Sri Lankan team came under attack and the militants were able to disappear into thin air after which international sporting events stopped taking place in Pakistan?Recommend

  • Waqas

    Do some reasearch before writing any blog, compare the security situation of Karachi & Lahore for the last 3 years, you will know the facts.Recommend

  • Junaid Ahmed

    Dear Mr. Writer Please note every year in Karachi here are ammunition exhibition in Expo center which is just behind the National stadium, and the security risk are more high then the cricket match but its happen yearly and without of any incident. Please noted and stop writing this nonsense columns…Recommend

  • Tribune’s regular ready.

    Tribune Editor,
    Just because someone can write a column doesn’t mean it has to be published without much thought, even with the disclaimer that this is entirely author’s opinion – you do bear some responsibility. Else, some of the comments below should be published as articles going by your standard.

    Most Sincerely,
    Tribune’s regular ready.Recommend

  • Salim Alvi

    What can you expect from people who are willing to give up their own mother tongue, mother’s culture and festivals!Recommend