Is Pakistan doing enough to protect its Hindu minority?

Published: August 25, 2017

Members of Hindu community pray inside a temple in Rahim Yar Khan March 27, 2014. PHOTO: REUTERS

According to the Pakistan Bureau of Statistics, Hindus constitute around 1.6% of Pakistan’s population. During the time of independence, there was a sizeable Hindu population in the areas that eventually became a part of Pakistan, but a majority of Hindus opted for India.

However, thousands of Hindus were still living in the eastern wing of the country, but after the dismemberment of East Pakistan, Sindh became the largest province to house Hindus; it constitutes 6.51% of Sindh’s total population. But over the years, numerous Hindu families have migrated from Sindh to India which is the natural destination for Pakistani Hindus as they share religious, cultural and familial ties with the people settled across the border.

The majority of Pakistani-Hindus end up settling in the Indian states of Gujarat and Rajasthan since both these states share a border with the Pakistani province of Sindh. It is not just one blatant factor that has led to this mass exodus, but rather various reasons have contributed to this phenomenon.

The rising religious extremism in interior Sindh is one major factor. Forced conversions of minor Hindu girls have become a norm in these areas. In fact, forced conversions have become the face of cultural and religious persecution in Sindh. The list of atrocities does not stop there. Abductions for ransom of Hindu traders and hate speech are also rampant.

Moreover, Hindus are treated as second class citizens and face discrimination when it comes to gaining admission in educational institutions, getting jobs and availing health facilities.

There are also various economic reasons behind this migration. Most of the Hindus who migrated are poverty stricken individuals/families and don’t see any chance of upward mobility in their social strata standing in Pakistan. Thus, they migrate to India in search of better opportunities.

Hindus that are well-off leave for India to protect their business interests as Pakistan does not provide an even playing field in terms of protection and promotion of their businesses. However, the current situation in India has not provided much relief to the migrants either. Since India is not a signatory of United Nations Refugee Convention, the migrants have to live in makeshift camps without any basic necessities such as electricity and water. On top of that, they are suspected for being Pakistani spies with the Indian agencies closely monitoring their each and every movement. Moreover, obtaining Indian citizenship is not as easy since it requires a strict and lengthy procedure.

The migrants have to live a life that is, in short, miserable and difficult. Although the Indian government has taken steps to speed up the process of acquiring Indian citizenship, it is still far from producing the desired results.

The questions that should be put forth here are why this is happening and what the state and citizens of Pakistan should do about it?

Pakistan repeatedly reiterates that Hindus are safe in Pakistan and enjoy religious freedom. They feel the entire situation is mere Indian propaganda adopted to malign Pakistan’s image and to divert the world’s attention from the atrocities faced by the Indian minorities at the hands of Hindu extremists. But the situation in Pakistan is closer to what India claims.

The matter of forced conversions and abductions is a serious matter and should be looked into. The Sindh Provincial Assembly did pass the Protection of Minorities’ Bill earlier this year which sets an age limit for marriage and conversions, and prescribes a harsh punishment for those who do not adhere to it. But due to pressure from religious parties and political compulsions, the bill has been swept under the carpet under the guise of a review. The government should take a stand and the aforementioned bill should be implemented in its letter and spirit.

Moreover, the Federal government should take actions to facilitate the return of willing Hindu migrants from India. Pakistan’s High Commission in India can act as a liaison in this regard. The government should take all necessary actions to rehabilitate them upon their return and take steps to ensure their security and well-being.

Furthermore, special task forces should be established with members from the Hindu community and the local civil authorities in order to address the grievances of Hindus. Plans to improve the condition of Pakistani-Hindus should be chalked out as well.

Places in Pakistan that are sacred to Hinduism should be preserved, renovated and open for carrying out religious activities. This will not only strengthen Pakistan’s Hindu connection but the national exchequer will also benefit from religious tourism.

It all comes down to the government and us. We have to realise that we are responsible for our minorities, irrespective of their creed and race. The law provides safeguards to our minorities and the government should make it their priority to implement these safeguards.

Pakistanis should realise they are responsible for their minorities and this is the only way through which they can achieve Jinnah’s true vision of Pakistan.

Aizzan Malik

Aizzan Malik

The author is a political science graduate from Government College University. He tweets as @AizzanKehtaHay (

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • amrik

    Short answer is no, karma is everything, what goes around will come back around Recommend

  • Memona

    No!!! Pakistan is Not doing anything to protect any of its minority, it is a joke to even talk about condition of Hindus/Christians/sikhs in Pakistan, I pity them I cry for them. Hindus regret not moving to India whereas sikhs are somehow neutral due to their holy sites located in pakistan. Recommend

  • Hosur

    The fact that Hindu numbers have shrunk is proof enough of how much the state had done for its minority populationRecommend

  • rationalist

    Good sentiments. The author must be commended for his honest and sincere concern about the Hindu minorities.

    Unfortunately, it is too late to protect Hindu, Christian and other religious minorities in Pakistan. Hindu population has dwindled to 2% from the figure of 22+% in the early years of Pakistan. The only hope for the remaining Hindus is to migrate to India.Recommend

  • Sane

    Shed some tears for Indian Muslims also. Shed some tears for those innocent children and adults. Shed some tears for those Masjids and houses burnt or destroyed.Recommend

  • Memona

    We have to think about citizens of pakistan first (if your referring to kashmiris in IOK that’s a separate issue and I do shed tears for them). Indian Muslims have more rights than pakistani hindus do. Recommend

  • Sane

    I am surprised the kind of heart and knowledge you have specially about Indian Muslims…..really surprised. (Some of the sentences of my comments could not comply with policy of ET and removed.) We cannot reply to a derogatory or otherwise comments in a rightful way.Recommend

  • Sane

    Among 22% migrated to India and left 2% as Muslims migrated to Pakistan, making Muslim population thin in India.Recommend

  • Patch

    Muslims in India are only ‘persecuted’ because they are deliberately inflating their numbers to try and take over the country, same as they are doing in Europe, the Hindus see this threat and are acting appropriately.

    Wherever Islam is the majority, the minority suffer horribly.Recommend

  • Shiva

    India doesn’t need Muslims..
    We have other peaceful and contributing and patriotic model minorities other than them
    U are free to take them into Pakistan as envisaged by ur Jinnah..
    Dnt forget to say Thanks Jinnah at the end of this discussion..Recommend

  • vinsin

    They can move now. Christians also fought for Pakistan along with half dalits, so not sure about them.Recommend

  • vinsin

    Pakistani Hindus can move to India., Pakistan was created for Muslims.Recommend