Kashmir’s undying love for Pakistan is an unpalatable truth for India

Published: August 22, 2017

Masked Kashmiri protestors shout pro-Pakistan and pro-freedom slogans during a protest in downtown Srinagar on July 31, 2016. PHOTO: AFP

We have seen numerous images of young Kashmiri lifeless bodies, wrapped in Pakistani flags, being lowered into graves by their old and fragile fathers.

Such images are enough to give us an idea of how deep-rooted pro-Pakistan sentiment is in Indian-held Kashmir.

Kashmiri civilians, mostly teenage boys, are hounded, tortured, arrested or even killed by government forces during anti-India protests and pro-azadi (freedom) rallies. This is a result of them raising passionate slogans in favour of Pakistan. Kashmiri boys and girls are seen chanting “jeeve jeeve, Pakistan” (long live, Pakistan) or “Pakistan Zindabad” slogans. A few have even set the Pakistani national anthem as a ringtone on their mobile phones.

This unconditional love for Pakistan emanating from a few sections of the Kashmiri society is not something new or surprising. It is, as they say, a matter of fact.

In the past, Kashmiris would draw up wills with the request that once the region merges with Pakistan, their children and grandchildren should hoist the Pakistani flag on their graves. For some, a visit to Pakistan is no less than an emotional pilgrimage.

Kashmiri children from the 90s, also described by some as ‘children of conflict’, have heard countless bedtime stories from their grandparents about how older Kashmiris loved Pakistan. They also loved Pakistan’s cricket and hockey teams, radio commentary in Urdu, thought-provoking television serials, as well as Pakistan’s sahar angez mouseeqi (magical music) in dil gudaaz aawaz (heart-breaking voice).

As a school boy, I grew up listening to exciting Urdu cricket commentary on Radio Pakistan. I immediately fell in love with this language of elegance and grace.

The very first Urdu sentences my ears heard, understood and then remembered were,

“Aasman par halke halke badal chaye huwe hain, aur maidan par iss waqt Pakistan ki team chayi huwi hai.”

(The sky has been taken over by light clouds, just like how the cricket ground has been taken over by the Pakistani team.)

“Bharat ki wicktein aisi girti gayien jaise khizaan ke mousam main paidoun se patte gira karte hain!”

(India’s wickets have been falling the same way trees shed leaves in autumn.)

Love for Pakistan is not just limited to its language and its cricket team, it goes beyond that. Iconic Pakistani tele-serials Ankahi (1982), Tanhaiyaan (1985), Dhoop Kinarey (1987) and recent ones such as Zindagi Gulzar Hai and Humsafar are household names in Kashmir.

In Kashmir, one comes across people whose love for Pakistan will surpass the proudest and most patriotic Pakistanis. Pakistanis may even end up doubting their quom parasti (nationalism) and hubul watni (patriotism) on encountering such Kashmiris.

Key observers state that in a suppressed environment, such as the one in Indian-controlled Kashmir, wherein democratic spaces for expression and dissent are suppressed, it is difficult to assess how deep the pro-Pakistan sentiment actually is.

February 5th symbolises Pakistan’s deep-rooted relationship with Kashmir. Every year, this day witnesses the revival of cultural, religious and the geographical proximity the Kashmir valley enjoys with Pakistan. Observers claim that the pro-Pakistan sentiment in Kashmir is neither dead nor diminished, rather it’s suppressed. The reasons for this are rooted in how Kashmiris have been treated since the 90s.

Interestingly, there is also a section of Kashmiri youth which does not entertain any discussion or debate that aims to equate Pakistan with India. For most Kashmiris, India is an aggressor while Pakistan is the sympathiser.

India’s Independence Day is observed as a ‘Black Day’ while Pakistan’s Independence Day is celebrated with immense joy. In some parts of south and north Kashmir, some people organise small rallies in which Pakistan’s national anthem is played out loud.

Given the fear of being kept under strict surveillance by government forces and intelligence agencies, some Kashmiris consciously choose to pay a cost for this expensive expression. That is how much they love Pakistan.

However, their love for Pakistan does not necessarily mean that they favour merging with Pakistan. In my view, the most dominant ideology prevalent in today’s Kashmir is the ‘anti-India’ and pro-freedom ideology. Many Kashmiris question the role of Pakistan in Kashmir, especially after the outbreak of anti-India armed rebellion.

Some Kashmiris also question Pakistan’s official policy regarding Kashmir, which they feel keeps wavering from time to time. They feel frustrated over what they describe as ‘Islamabad’s inconsistent Kashmir policy’.

A few voices from Kashmir’s new, assertive, educated and conscious generation are also worried about how extremist jihadi elements such as Lashkar-e-Taiba (LeT) have hijacked the Kashmir solidarity movement in Pakistan. They are also concerned about why more and more voices from Pakistan’s vibrant civil society and liberal circles don’t speak up enough about Kashmir.

Furthermore, there are concerns over why the Pakistani electronic media is not holding prime time television debates on Kashmir in order to,

  1. a) Counter Indian media’s Kashmir narrativebased on propaganda, falsehoods and vitriol
  2. b) Raise global awareness about the genesis of the Kashmiri dispute and to hold Indian forces accountable for their alleged atrocitiescommitted on the people of Kashmir

It’s clear that there is anger against the Indian state when it comes to the treatment of Kashmiris. However, to assume that Pakistan’s role in Kashmir cannot be questioned is also naive. In my view, there is a stronger sentiment for azadi (freedom), but the pro-Pakistan constituency in Kashmir is also an undeniable reality. It is an unpalatable truth for the Indian state.

In the absence of any empirical study, it is very difficult to assess whether the pro-Pakistan sentiment has weakened or enhanced over the years.

Kashmir bleeds every single day. Kashmir suffers every single day. Kashmir mourns every single day. Given the love Kashmiris have for Pakistan, I hope Pakistan rethinks its Kashmir policy.

Gowhar Geelani

Gowhar Geelani

The author is a writer, journalist and political commentator from Srinagar, the South Asian Journalism Programme (SAJP) scholar 2015, the first Kashmiri to be selected as Munich Young Leader 2014. He has also served the Deutsche Welle, in Germany, as an editor. He tweets as @gowhargeelani

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Masood Uttra

    Mr. Geelani, Standing with you by heart.
    Very nice elaboration of feelings :)

  • Rohan

    Then go live there Recommend

  • peter pan

    It in the interest of both India and Pakistan to have a divided Kashmir. If an independent Kashmir was created, Pakistan would lose Azad Kashmir, the catchment areas of the Indus water way and GET NOTHING IN RETURN.
    A division along the LOC is the only practical solution that will be acceptable to both parties. Restoration of friendly relations between India and Pak would relieve the situation in Indian Kashmir for Muslims also and help in dismantling the jihadi groups by removing their “raison de etr”. Think coolly India and Pakistan instead of blowing hot air!!!Recommend

  • Humza

    Kashmiris don’t want a division along the LOC. Most people in Pakistan would support an independent Kashmir on both sides but also a referendum. In any case the land, people, culture and geography and not just religion is linked with Pakistan. This is the reality that Indians ignore. The British and Indians cheated Kashmiris of their opportunity to join Pakistan in 1947 and the world has cheated Kashmiris by allowing a UN referendum so that people can freely admit their allegiance to either state. the fact is that most Kashmiris would automatically align with Pakistan regardless of the state being merged with Pakistan or as an independent state. One day India will wake up to the reality that Indian occupied Kashmir cannot be held hostage forever and they will have to grant freedom to the people there. This will not change and the sooner Indians understand this the better for the region. Pakistan should do a better job of highlighting the atrocities carried out by Indian occupied forces as state terrorism like the author has explained.Recommend

  • Arunanshu M

    The fact that this commentator is able to rant against his nation in a foreign newspaper is proof enough about India’s secular and democratic credentials. Imagine the same happening from a Baloch in Pakistan. IRecommend

  • Arunanshu M

    I think people of your ilk should also wake up to the fact that today’s world has no appetite for another Islamic state in South Asia. If it was a genuine struggle, where are the minorities? World over independence has been sought by nations from colonisers who exploited the national wealth and took them away. In Kashmir’s context who is exploiting whom?
    Kashmir’s special status in Indian Constitution means that you don’t even pay income taxes to the Indian government. Delhi spend billions on Kashmir rather. And yet you want to align with Pakistan simply because you believe Kashmir is Islamic and needs to align with another Islamic state as it cannot live with Hindus. Partition in ’47 didn’t allow the Hindu majority people of Sylhet in Bangladesh to align with India. They don’t cry like you in the 21st century and blame India and the British for cheating them. It’s same for the erstwhile princely states of Hyderabad, Bhopal, etc who could have moved to Pakistan. They have moved on in life. Recommend

  • realist

    Yes, since Kashmiris love pakistanis so much they should move over to pak land so the rest of us can live in peace.Recommend

  • PorkSmasher

    Why they are hiding their faces if they are real freedom fighters.Recommend