#GoneNawazGone: Today could be the darkest day in Pakistan’s judicial history or the day a new Pakistan was born

Published: July 28, 2017

Nawaz Sharif looks on during a lecture on Sri Lanka-Pakistan Relations in Colombo, Sri Lanka, January 5, 2016. PHOTO: REUTERS

The nail-biting suspense leading up to the verdict is now over. The unthinkable has finally happened. Nawaz Sharif, who managed to win three elections and serve as Pakistan’s prime minister, has been disqualified and faces political extinction.

This is the mother of all Supreme Court (SC) verdicts and whether it will change the country’s fate for better or worse will be decided in the next few days.

It could be the darkest day in Pakistan’s judicial history or it may be remembered as the day a new Pakistan was born, depending on whether or not the SC disqualifies others who are equally corrupt (which includes most of our present lawmakers).

Legal experts have different opinions on the verdict:

Pakistan now has the dubious distinction of having had almost all of its prime ministers sacked before they completed their full five-year terms. Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, the first prime minister under the 1973 Constitution, served for almost four years, but since elections were due in 1977, he too did not complete five years.

Of course Nawaz and his men will claim that he has been removed by a judicial coup, that it is an international conspiracy to remove him, so on and so forth.

But Nawaz has only himself to blame for his troubles.

He could have resigned two months ago when two judges had held him to be unfit to be a member of Parliament. Resigning would have at least saved him the humiliation of being disqualified and being labelled as dishonest and corrupt.

Nawaz and his children cannot hold public offices for the next five years at least. Furthermore, Nawaz will undergo more humiliation when the National Accountability Bureau (NAB) finds him guilty of corruption and he could also be sentenced to serve time in jail.

The credit for Nawaz’s downfall undoubtedly goes to Imran Khan, although it was the Panama Leaks which accelerated the process. So it would not be out of place to mention here that Umer Cheema also deserves to be praised for exposing the Panama scandal, for which he has earned international recognition. And we now know that the decisive factor in the disqualification was Nawaz’s iqama (permission to work in the UAE, for which he received a regular salary but failed to declare it).

At present, after his disqualification, the country is without a prime minister. It is up to Nawaz to decide who will be the interim prime minister until Shehbaz Sharif is elected to the National Assembly and becomes eligible.

Knowing how suspicious and insecure Nawaz is, I doubt he will select a strong man to serve as an interim prime minister, although the country desperately needs such a man now.

In my opinion, the man who would be acceptable to all political parties as the next prime minister is of course Chaudhry Nisar Ali Khan, the now former interior minister. But unfortunately, he has differences with those who are very close to Nawaz, so it is doubtful that he will be the next one in line.

Shahid Khaqan Abbasi and Ayaz Sadiq are definitely suitable, but again as I said, Nawaz would not like to have someone more powerful or more popular than him to be in the driving seat.

Who should be the next prime minister of Pakistan?

     View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

In fact, it is very difficult for the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) to survive now. It is very likely that some, if not most, of its parliamentarians will defect to other parties, leaving the 2018 elections to be contested mainly between Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaaf (PTI) and Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP).

However, we must not forget that it is very difficult to find an upright and honest politician in Pakistan. Almost all our parliamentarians have wealth which is much more than their declared incomes. So it is impossible that the 2018 elections will give the country a prime minister who is sadiq (honest) and ameen (upright).

The SC should now proceed against corrupt politicians like Asif Ali Zardari and others to eliminate corruption in the country. It should do so with the same speed with which the Panama accused were tried. If that is not possible, perhaps elections could be postponed for six months to a year to ensure that only honest and God fearing people are elected to our assemblies.

The SC should try the others according to the same standard that was set for Nawaz. All known corrupt politicians and holders of public offices should explain within a few weeks how they have managed to accumulate so much wealth. Those who cannot do so should be disqualified immediately. This is the only way people will believe that Nawaz has not been disqualified due to a conspiracy.

Let’s hope the SC does so without fear or favour.

Shakir Lakhani

Shakir Lakhani

Engineer, former visiting lecturer at NED Engineering College, industrialist, associated with petroleum/chemical industries for many years. Loves writing, and (in the opinion of most of those who know him), mentally unbalanced. He tweets @shakirlakhani (twitter.com/shakirlakhani)

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • http://zdnexus.blogspot.com Malik Bux

    Ideally an interim government must be set up anf elections announcedRecommend

  • John Malletman

    Most of the politicians in the US are corrupt too.

    Our current President is trying to argue that the person investigating him somehow doesn’t have authority to investigate him. It’s like a repeat of Nixon…Recommend

  • Parvez

    Those who question the judgment ….should ask that when all institutions of the government have deliberately been rendered impotent then how is accountability to take place ?…..in this case the SC reluctantly stepped in because it had to. This is not a reflection on the SC but on bad governance.Recommend

  • Rahul

    If you know the history of Pakistan,the same was done to Husyn Suhrawardy, Fatima Jinnah, Mujibur Rehman, Zulfikar Bhutto, Benazir Bhutto, Altaf Husain, Asif Zardari and Nawaz Sharif twice before. There was a similar combination of Judges, Bureaucrats, Intelligence Services and military denying an elected leader their mandate, summary dismissal from office, banning from politics,imprisonment, banning from country, execution etc.etc.The establishment never lets an elected leader execute policy so why would any honest leader come up and play second fiddle to establishment.Pakistan democracy has been set back 30 years today.Recommend

  • RHR
  • Ahmar

    “PTI and PPP will contest 2018 and PML-N will not survive.”

    Hahahaha..good joke :’)

    Nawaz has survived Musharraf’s reign, Attock jail, Plane Hi-jack case, forced exile of 9 years and came back to almost win 2008, later sweeping out 2013 elections. Their support in Punjab is strong as ever, making in-roads in Sindh and KP.

    Lets have elections by the end of this year. I can’t wait to see which party survives and which party won’t even get their deposit money back.Recommend

  • Rahul

    In Pakistan, Prime Ministers have been removed by Generals, Judges, Bureaucrats and Assassins, but never by voters.Recommend

  • Abdul moiz

    I Simply love Article 62, its basically a blanket ban on all humans to be prime minister
    no one should and could be eligible/competent/clean/honest enough to hold that office and therefore the court should consistently disqualify every one who attempts to be a prime minister
    i assure you the country would do just fine without theseRecommend

  • Rex Minor

    Nawaz Sharif disqualified by the SC on Article
    62(1)(f) — not on London properties but failure in 2013 to disclose
    salary from Capital FZE pic.twitter.com/3zUheebfui.

    This is nothing new, the good always win over evil! Alcapone the mafia boss was not jailed because of his criminal activities but failure to declare the right amount for income tax payments. The Sharifs belong to the family of criminal millionares who have set up offshore companies to launder illegal income and avoid payment of tax to communities where they reside. The world requires an island for such parasites to deny them the power over regular working citizens.. Time and again these people have attempted to seek immunity by holding powerful positions in a democracy but lost it because of their own devices.

    Rex MinorRecommend

  • husain naqi

    the darkest day was when j.munir court decided the maulvi tamizuddin khan case and Bhutto’s judicial murder when anwarul presided over the bench.NAWAZ SHARIF betrayed gentleman prime minister M.K Junejo to be inducted as prime minister by usurper ziaul haq. next time it was isi chief hamid gul who spent public money on forming Islami Jamhoori Ittehad. his ouster by a civilian court not under military usurpers can not be considered as the darkest day. it is the day when civilian court could not be bullied by thugs.Recommend

  • Sane

    Accountability shall make Pakistan safe, not the corrupt democracy. A corrupt democracy full of nepotism is worst than dictatorship.Recommend

  • Memona

    Beautifully summed up. ThanksRecommend

  • Asif Paracha

    The composition of the JIT was odd. Two people were there which had no business being on a JIT investigating financial crimes. They were intentionally nominated. So in my view the planning was there from the start. Also the final reason was a strange one for disqualification.Recommend

  • Hassan Mirza

    Nothing will change in Pakistan till not finished Corruption .Dr Asim from ppp expose as front man of Zardari single penny not recovered only stories in books billions of dollars recovered but ground reality Pakistan only get Shame but Resident of Pakistan become shameless Panama drama were staged almost 15 months day night drum beating by media of Pakistan so call historic Verdict no outcome another Episode of Panama drama about to start this time 62 63 clause Since look like Supreme court of Pakistan is justice for us only .Not justice for all there is not a single case from past several years have listen in Supreme court of Pakistan from an a common man of Pakistan is that justice for all ? Also Pakistan is 13th most corrupt nation of the world if taken a survey in Pakistan on which is number 1 department of corruption I am sure it is Justice system of Pakistan .Recommend

  • Shah

    I Think You Forget 2013 Elections PPP Was Actually Removed By VotersRecommend

  • Hassan Mirza

    So innocent like the Pakistani Nation .13th world corrupt nation from top to down every body innocently pose they are Angels must be Aliens who do corruption. OR if every body in Pakistan so Angel then 13th world corrupt ranking must be international conspiracy against them.Recommend