While a new day yields a new molester, our girls are still told it’s their fault

Published: June 15, 2017

A customer was inappropriately touched by one of the fashion outlet's staff members.

“It was my first day at work. I covered my head like a good Muslim, didn’t speak to the opposite gender unnecessarily, still somehow by the time I returned home, I had a few extremely vulgar text messages from unidentified numbers on my mobile.

It shocked me because only a few family members had my new mobile number and I was 100% certain that it wasn’t a coincidence to receive such messages on my first day at work. I was frightened at the thought of someone at this new workplace having such a perception of me. That someone must have assumed I am open to the idea of having sexual relationships at workplace. I was frightened and filled with self-doubt. I traced back all of my steps during that day to figure out what exactly had I done to ‘encourage’ this kind of behaviour.”

This story was narrated to me by a friend a few years ago and it still makes me incredibly sad and angry.

Angry because we live in a world where survivors of sexual abuse and harassment are often led to believe that somehow they themselves are responsible for what happened to them. Children as young as seven or eight are told that the aggressive actions of monsters and vultures could be due to their clothing or behaviour. Want to avoid getting raped? Wear ‘decent’ clothes or don’t stay out late at night. Don’t like getting harassed? Don’t laugh a lot or loudly or don’t mix with the opposite gender.

That anecdote makes me sad because unfortunately, it isn’t the only story that comes to my mind when I think about sexual harassment. From streets to places which should have been considered safe havens like colleges, universities and workplaces, people, especially women, have to endure such unwanted and aggressive acts of intimidation on a daily basis.

Sexual harassment and catcalling are no alien concepts to women around the world. Hollaback, a global movement to end harassment, and Cornell University published results of the largest survey on street harassment in 2015. Out of the 16,600 respondents, the majority reported experiencing street harassment for the first time during puberty. According to the survey, over 50% women in 22 countries reported being groped or fondled in public. And this data doesn’t even include countries like Pakistan or Bangladesh.

If you are a woman and if you have been out shopping in Pakistan, chances are you must have experienced harassment first hand. From being leered at to ‘accidental’ touching, women in Pakistan are well aware of the dangers that lurk in our hustling bustling malls and shopping centres. There used to be a time when women walked in confidence on streets thinking that if someone bothered them, they will create a ruckus and inevitably hundreds of men will come to rescue them. But now, the society has degenerated so much that after each incident, every survivor is reminded that their outfit could have been the reason behind this ‘reaction’.

Recently, a similar incident happened at one of the fashion outlets where a customer was inappropriately touched by one of the store’s staff members. The incident sparked furious debates on social media and obviously, suggestions came pouring in from fellow ‘concerned’ citizens that she should have covered herself up ‘properly’ or that she shouldn’t be out in a mall at all. Admirably, the management took swift action and fired the staff member in question. It is one of those rare examples or outcomes in today’s world which gives me the courage to even write on this subject.

9th June 2017, around 4:00 pmI was inside Zeen at Dolmen Mall, Tariq Road in Karachi. For those who don't know, Zeen…

‎Posted by Girls at Dhabas on‎ שבת 10 יוני 2017

When I was first asked to write a blog on this incident, I thought to myself that perhaps it wasn’t a good idea because people are going to launch personal attacks online. They might harass me on Twitter. They will use religion to somehow prove the survivors are at fault, no matter what. They will say things which will make me furious but then I told myself that these inculpations haven’t stopped me in the past and they won’t stop me in the future.

I can quote a few personal examples as well, of times when misogynists told me how women were responsible for everything bad happening in this world. Believe it or not, I was told in a professional setting that it was mentioned in the Holy Quran that women were created to test men and they were evil creatures. Yes, I am not making this up, I wish I was exaggerating or joking, but sadly I am not.

‘Good’ Muslims often forget that they should be very cautious when quoting sacred texts or when using religion to justify their own actions. The main problem with that is that since none of us are perfect, we will make mistakes, and when our flawed personalities become ambassadors of our religion, people will criticise the religion and not the followers; case in point – terrorism. Secondly, not every person in this world has to believe in what you believe in. So by saying things like, “Oh but women are asked to cover up in Islam”, you are essentially condoning acts of violence against those who don’t cover themselves up which is extremely disturbing and just plain wrong.

Having said that, I do acknowledge that the problem isn’t confined to Pakistan or other developing countries only, catcalling is fairly common in developed societies as well and the only explanation that makes sense to me is that for centuries we have been asked to blame the survivors of sexual violence. After all, we like easier options and what’s more convenient than tarnishing a person’s reputation once they are already hurt. When we blame the ones being affected after such incidents, we often forget a few important aspects.

Clothing doesn’t have anything to do with someone else’s behaviour. Women who wear the burqa or abaya are harassed as well. Have you seen the video where a woman with a young child is being harassed by a man at an exhibition at Expo Centre Karachi? Do you think that children as young as two-years-old are raped because they were wearing provocative clothes?

Blaming the survivor is not only damaging to them, it damages the moral fabric of the society by normalising acts of aggression. When you say a man must react to his impulse if a woman provokes him, it discredits a man’s ability to control his urges. It derogates a man into some sort of beast that lacks the capability to think and do the right thing.

Expecting a survivor to ignore harassment because the problem is so widespread is basically giving a green signal to aggressors. Every time you tell a survivor of sexual harassment to stay quiet, you are also telling the abuser to continue pushing boundaries further and further.

I won’t end this blog by begging men to have empathy for women and by saying things like ‘but what if it happened to the women in your family’. No, women don’t need to shoulder the burden of men’s actions anymore. But believe me, when morality is lost in a society, everyone gets affected. There comes a point when these beasts stop caring about their target’s age, marital status, and even gender. We hear about cases of young men and boys being abused all the time. Think about it, what sort of world are we planning to leave behind for our future generations?

Dureen Anwer

Dureen Anwer

Dureen is a communications professional from Pakistan, now living in the UK. Having worked for a local government and now for the healthcare sector in England, she often wonders why Pakistan can't be developed like these Western countries. She tweets @ConfusciousDee (twitter.com/ConfusciousDee)

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Fizza Malik

    Rather than educating our women how to save themselves from opposite gender, firstly we should make our boys learn how to respect a women. Secondly, give confidence to girls to raise voice against such harasser just like the girl did and her mother supported rather than asking her to keep quiet or blaming her.Recommend

  • Duniya Hasan

    Isn’t this government’s job? They are the main reason women suffer in Pakistan because they are in favor of mullah type people. Recommend

  • Zafar Iqbal

    PLease allow me to share another type of experience. I am a 65 year old male with a grey beard. To commemorate the United Nations’ International Mother Language Day, the second Pakistan Mother Languages Literature Festival 2017 was held to celebrate the diversity of languages in Pakistan at Lok Virsa, Islamabad on the 18th and 19th of February. I was very interested and went to the mela. While exiting the “REd Hall” I found a big 6 foot about 35 years old male standing in the centre of the door with his one hand across the door. If I had to go out, I had to bend and walk under his arm. I asked him to move aside. He smiled and read a romantic verse. Meanwhile a staffer Ms Nusrat came and conveniently passed under his arm. I again asked him to move away. He didn’t, smiled and another romantic verse. Now I am an ex Air Force Pilot…have dealt with all kind of situations,, but never this kind. Ultimately I decided to chance going under his arm. He almost grabbed me. I was horrified and all this while there were people all around. It was indeed horrifying. Soon I found out that he was the cameraman deputed to cover the events in the Red Hall. I went around looking for the Executive Director Lok Virsa Dr. Fouzia Saeed ( reputed to be a very tough Lady). Not finding her I wrote a detailed account and left it with her PSO a Mr Sherani. Later in the afternoon I came across the Executive Director Lok Virsa Dr. Fouzia Saeed and told her what happened. She said that she will find the culprit and do the needful. And that was that. I went to see her after 2 weeks. She was too busy. I called her, she was busy. I called her PA. She said that they could not FIND the cameraman. I wrote to her on her web,No response. Is she a party to the whole thing? Is he her brother, nephew etc? And I told her that if this crook can harass a 65 year old male, how females he must have harrassed? But the Great Dr. Fouzia Saeed has been kept on shielding him. Today 4 months have passed and the writer of two books on sexual harassment , Taboo and Living Among Sharks is protecting this Shark. If I can’t forget that creepy shameless scenario, I can imagine how the girls being harassed must be feeling. Shame on all such monsters, and Shame on all those who protect them, including Executive Director Lok Virsa Dr. Fouzia Saeed.Recommend

  • Raja Hamid

    Well I was expecting these kind of comments about mullahs from people like your who blame scholars of Islam for everything, if a criminal rape women still its mullah’s fault ? actually the problem is the rule of law if the government is not enforcing the law then how could you expect things will get better, furthermore if Mullah says that the punishment for rapist should be death then liberal fascists like you will cry out in defense of that culprit which is quite ironic.Recommend

  • Fizza Malik

    Lol… Its easy to throw the ball in government’s court and we do it every time by blaming them and waiting for them to do something. I think its high time we should not look forward to them but do something ourselves to bring change. As a quotation says Be the change, you want to see.
    Islam protects women and before asking girls to cover it orders men to lower their gaze.
    We should study Islam ourselves
    And yes government should be doing something in this regard.Recommend

  • sufyan

    Amid technological, political and economic reforms in Pakistan, it is woeful to have social lacking in this country. I second the opinion of not telling girls what to do (keeping quiet or repressing themselves) ;we should certainly educate men to have rational behavior for the betterment and social improvement of society. I think, that a man’s role in the social reforms under our sort of repressed society is inevitable and crucial. No doubt in accepting the powerful role of media and technology in rotting of one’s thinking, specially teens. This state of affairs will certainly transform our society from middle ordered harassers to a morally contaminated society which apparently, is the ultimate downfall of any nation. Allah bless everyone. AmenRecommend

  • rationalist

    “Islam protects women and before asking girls to cover it orders men to lower their gaze. We should study Islam ourselves Doesn’t Islam require women to produce four Muslim male witnesses to prove rape prescribes woman’s testimony is worth half that of men, men can do a triple talaq to throw wives out with only 90 day sustenance support, and allows men to marry four wives….Recommend

  • ab

    It has become fashion to blame mullah for everything. what is a mother role? the rapist first teacher is a mother. it’s motherhood that have failedRecommend

  • Hassan Sarwar

    Bad people are every as the good ones so it’s not appropriate to name religion responsible or you may enhance the distance between religion and so called modernismRecommend

  • farhan

    women want equality only when it suits them. meaning only to their advantages, hypocrytes indeedRecommend

  • farhan

    wow, why the mullah hate, they do not promote it, sick mentalityRecommend

  • farhan

    yeah i dont know how the mullah came up here, i guess who dosent like islam says its mullah faultRecommend

  • Sohail Ahmad

    why you afraid of registering an FIR against that person . The best way to teach a lesson to these people.Recommend

  • Sohail Ahmad

    First and foremost this is duty of parents to teach their male child regarding respecting a women second if any such incident happened report to the police, register an FIR.Recommend

  • Alter Ego

    I agree.
    Castration should be the punishment .
    But the desi liberals , will cry it as too harsh a punishment.
    Then they blame Mullahs for everything.
    The electricity is not coming.Its the maulvis fault.
    I have had a fight with my wife.Its the maulvis fault.Recommend

  • Umar Suleman

    Let’s be intelligent in changing this. Change what you have full control of, that is yourself, instead of what you have no control of whatsoever, the whole world. Waiting for the ‘whole world’ to change is what does not exist.
    Women know what change they can become to avoid this ugly experience, men know what they can become to be not part of it, to become living examples of who detest it.Recommend