IDEAS 2016: For the elite, by the elite

Published: November 23, 2016

A view of the traffic jam at the Baloch Colony Bridge on Tuesday. Traffic jams were witnessed in most parts of the city due to the ninth IDEAS exhibition being held at Expo Centre. PHOTO: FILE

Like every year, a proud tradition has come about again; one where government officials and army generals hold highly sophisticated weapons in their hands and pretend to target invisible enemies – so the foreign dignitaries they are trying to entertain are impressed enough to purchase the firearm in question for big bucks – because, well, these steel toys do not come cheap.

The place is flocked by bureaucrats, generals and a whole lot of politicians in one place having a good time and appreciating the deadliest weapons produced by a third world country.

Although this is seen every year under the name of International Defence Exhibition and Seminar (IDEAS) – it is not why I am writing this piece.

Three days before the event was to commence, I was leaving a nearby sports complex when I came across a massive banquet type of tent located in the parking lot – the tent occupied more than half the place reserved for members’ parking. Upon inquiring I came to know that the army is storing their equipment for IDEAS inside the parking area.

I thought to myself, where were people supposed to park their cars then? Would they designate an alternate space to them? Why couldn’t the tent have been put somewhere else? People can’t visit the expo if they have no place to park.

And these kinds of ridiculous decisions take place everywhere in Pakistan and the civilians are meant to be accommodating about it.

Of course. It’s a matter of national security. Why don’t we understand? It’s only for our protection.

And we have no choice but to abide by those calling the shots in this cursed poverty stricken country with an inept political system.

Anyway, not long after, I saw huge containers arriving in front of the Expo Centre,  the Rangers personnel shouting on the shuddering car drivers to stop and give way, while instructing the container driver in an awkward Punjabi-Urdu accent ‘aan deyyo’ (let it come). These containers were then stored inside, beside the fence of Expo Centre. My worst fear had come true. One of the bystanders commented, “it has begun” as if indicating the happening of a natural calamity or disaster.

And that is exactly what happened, just as suspected. Yesterday, the first day of the Expo, brought with it a plethora of problems. Not only was the event a nuisance for the people wishing to attend, it was problematic for those who were just trying to navigate through their daily routine. Broken roads inundated with knee-deep sewage water were used as diversions, which were not controlled by traffic policemen. Public buses and rickshaws were also stopped from using certain streets in the city. Despite the promise made that University Road would not be closed, it was closed for about two hours, resulting in even more traffic clogging the streets. The extra traffic police force, which was assured by the traffic police, was also nowhere to be found on the alternative routes.

Such promises are made every year. But, hey, when have any of our government departments ever been keepers of their word?

It’s pretty evident that no amended traffic route will be our resolve and these issues will keep plaguing the public till the event comes to a close. In other words, the entire population of the city should just brace itself and continue going through absolute mental torture and frustration for the next few days!

Every year when IDEAS arrives, we witness a repeat of confused citizens running out of ideas regarding which route to take. While the influential people, including the military leadership, present our proud productions to the representatives of the more civilised countries, normal citizens outside lose hours of productivity. Children can’t go to school, patients don’t reach hospitals, and office workers don’t reach their jobs on time. This is caused by the gridlocks made in order to ensure the safety of all those attending the great IDEAS.

Inadequate traffic management on the traffic police’s part, blocked roads, and the insensitive/unconcerned attitude of those involved, are all factors that contribute towards making IDEAS a terribly bad idea, while also forcing the civilians to boil with anger and blame the ambitious Expo endeavour. Hardly anyone I know from last year had anything positive to say about this exhibit and, why would they? The geniuses from the military and the government have robbed them of any reason to think otherwise.

I wonder if those involved in IDEAS management ever ask their customers if they conduct such exhibitions in their country. And if so, do they block all modes of travel in the name of security?

I do realise that we live in times that require extreme security measures to be taken, but please don’t tell me that security cannot be made possible without adding misery to the lives of thousands of already drained, depressed, and exhausted citizens. Because, while our rulers and men in boots enjoy after parties, dinners, and drinks in air conditioned halls, thousands of civilians outside are stuck in traffic in the heat. And such feelings of helplessness fuelled by such humiliating circumstances transform into resentment towards this endeavour.

It does not matter then, how many slogans they shout of an “impenetrable defence” and a strong Pakistan. While the appalling state of the public continues, they should be assured that people consider these to be nothing but shallow dialogues.

How many years or decades have to pass, before we get to have someone sensible enough to understand these basic issues and take care of them?

The negligence and carelessness displayed by both the military and the government, shown in this matter gives much credence to the notion that they don’t really care about us. All they’re really fixated on is to further their own personal agendas and the VIP protocols they receive for events such as IDEAS, where the common man does not even dare to enter. Though they accomplish all this with taxpayer money and in the name of the nation, it is ironic that the same taxpayer, belonging to the same nation, suffers as he has no idea or vested interested in regard to what’s happening inside the Expo. His focus is solely on finding an alternate way around and swearing out the VIP’s as he struggles to do so.

On one side, one-third of the total Pakistani population lives below the poverty line; they do not have sufficient food to eat or access to healthcare facilities. On the other hand, exhibits such as IDEAS seem to make fun of their deplorable condition, even though its managers promise to bring progress to the country.

The government manages to earn a significant amount through the IDEAS exhibit. But if time and time again, they’re unable to manage the (expected) traffic situation, it really means nothing. Those flashy guns, ammunition, aircraft destroyers – what good are they if they can’t bring any change in the lives of the common man? You can’t feed the poor with weapons.

It’s obvious these guns are only there for pretentious reasons. We hardly ever see the latest weaponry in the hands of the police who are meant to protect the lives of civilians every day. They are still forced to carry decades old rusted Ak-47’s that don’t seem to work. These advanced rifles are to be exclusively used by our “jawans” and specifically those SSG guys, while ordinary third-grade policemen just don’t deserve to carry weapons of such high calibre – they should simply fight terrorists relying on obsolete guns, should they work! This too, in the country that produces and presents advanced weapons systems such as air defence weapons, propellants, mortar ammunition, drone missiles, and even tanks on an annual basis.

IDEAS draws more scepticism than support from people, as you can expect when you practically shutdown the lives of a huge number of people and, that too, for one whole week, as well as affect the daily routine of the whole city. It is high time for IDEAS to either be shifted to an alternate location, where the roads do not require any blockage or it should not be conducted at all.

The whole concept behind IDEAS seems to be an expensive show that is reserved for the elite and presented by the elite. This whole drama needs to stop now; people have suffered enough for the last few years.

This exhibition brings about no change to our lives other than the agony it adds to it. People couldn’t care less about it, whether it happens or not, since they aren’t ever invited and their presence is unwanted in the premises of this so-called exhibition, quite the same as when dogs are not allowed in some places.

Although the place is swarming with the proud elites, I would like to urge them to be merciful towards the civilians and ask the men in boots to shift their party somewhere else, without bothering us.

Ahsan Zafeer

Ahsan Zafeer

The author is interested in politics, social issues and sports. He has a passion for writing and believes that issues can be resolved through discussion. He tweets @AhsanZafeer (

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Bina

    Voice of the people, amazingly written!Recommend

  • khan saab

    The same things we cry every year, sad no changeRecommend

  • Real.$hady

    Biggest joke, cant control traffic and sell expensive weaponry..Recommend

  • abdullah

    True words are right, by elite and for elite, well saidRecommend

  • mralibuksh

    Speechless, really shameful situation for armyRecommend

  • omaradnan

    Why cant we have anything peacefully and without this kind of hassle? disgustedRecommend

  • spl

    Plz stop propganda against pk army..spitting venome and our weapons…Recommend

  • princekarim

    338 Companies from 38 Countries
    10,758 SQM net exposition space
    85 delegations from 39 countries
    32,405 Trade visitors
    Top class industries speakers and attendence

    and u talk abt this? shame on uRecommend

  • abidkhan

    hahahahaha pathetic state of affairs in pathetic country! all I can sayyRecommend

  • asgharkhan

    Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif on Tuesday said Pakistan was against an arms race in the region, however would pursue the motto of ‘arms for peace’. Speaking at the inauguration of four-day ninth International Defence Exhibition and Seminar (IDEAS) here, the Prime Minister said Pakistan was committed to discouraging arms race and promoting “the motto of arms for peace, which has always been the tagline of IDEAS”. The PM said Pakistan had achieved self-reliance in defence production.

    Someone believe this joke?? hahahaahahRecommend

  • shiekh

    the glass is half full also This is for pak, traffic happen everyday, hope u understandRecommend

  • patriotic

    hey man, u know how much revenue we get by this? u dont then u talk rubbish, first find out then traffic dont bother u …unless u know the fact, dont say things, be gud pakistaniRecommend

  • iqbal.ali

    OMG enough negativity already please, there’s also roads blocked in karachi for other reasons also..Recommend

  • Talal Shaikh

    Once, just once I would like to see these “elites” (politicians or army officials) deny or at least properly manage such an event where foreign dignitaries and representatives are present, so that there is minimal disruptions to the routine of the common man and so people can commute to and from their workplace and/or schools/colleges/universities in peace. If not this, then at least think of the Pi$$ poor image of our country being portrayed to foreign dignitaries/reps. when the so called “elites” allow this gross event mis-management to happen. (Shows to dignitaries/representatives how much they (the elitists) care about the common man.)Recommend

  • johnny.sensation

    plz stop this propaganda, against forces of country, what u get by this?Recommend

  • KA

    wow! you guys really think the Army is busy in COAS transition phase and you can speak anything you want?Recommend

  • jiye_bhutto

    lol how much u got paid for this story?Recommend

  • captain30

    Absolutely spot on, earu hv done great job highlighting these probs. tragic is, ppl still dont understand and especially army waly, but u keep up da gud work!Recommend

  • johnny.sensation

    well dear ur right but some time ppl can get biased and not understand these thingsRecommend

  • johnny.sensation

    some ppl are too biased they get blinded !Recommend

  • Real.$hady

    its not propaganda its about the problems of ppl!Recommend

  • abidkhan

    there is no positivity here, want that u should go abroadRecommend

  • abdullah

    shame on u, u dont realize problems of ppl bcoz of this eventRecommend

  • abdullah

    when someone highlight ppl’s problems its propaganda? plz explain dearRecommend

  • jiye_bhutto

    as long as government’s selfishness continues this keep happeningRecommend

  • khan saab

    Couldnt have been said this any betterRecommend

  • khan saab

    biggest tragedy of countryRecommend

  • Gingerman78

    When I first saw a reference to an IDEAS festival, I thought that perhaps it was meeting of creative people with business people or some such thing. But this is Pakistan so of course, this was about weapons and vanquishing imagined enemies and tilting at windmills. Sigh!!!Recommend

  • Fahim

    Author and people having same mindset need to give their votes again to PPP-P so that Karachi infrastructure development will continue in same way as they are doing for last one full decadeRecommend

  • abidkhan

    why dear u dont like someone highlighting people’s problems? or are u one of those happy go lucky one’s who go to IDEAS because of their “chachu/mamu in army” and click selfies with weapons and return happy, saying everything’s fine!Recommend

  • abidkhan

    plz tell me more abt the role of ideas in developing karachi, is it not a place where only the relatives of the military and political brass can go? why cant u focus on the problems mentioned here?Recommend

  • Faraz Khan

    The author seems to be biased and uniformed. He is planted by MqM the jaga’s of the city, may be supported by a neighbor country from our east.
    Ideas is proud of Pakistan. It given millions of karachiates work, money and food. It’s an engine karachi economy. Unfortunately there is no bhatta system in ideas so the writer is looking so frustrated.

  • Bina

    plz dont push your anti pakistan propaganda here, here the point only is the problems caused by ideas, not the aspect of the weapons..indeed these weapons protect pakistan in the long run!Recommend

  • Bina

    things will change one day I.A !Recommend

  • Bina

    The point is traffic and not weaponry pleaseRecommend

  • Muaaz Abbas Saddal

    Billions of investment on stake in IDEAS 2016 and that too in the investment deprived military industry and you guys are pointing out a blocked road and portraying it as a social class issue. The peoples biggest problem is corruption, ever asked your politicians about it?Recommend

  • Babur

    What problem ppl faced due to this? you are making a mountain of a molehill. clearly you are venting your hatred against army under the guise of highlighting the “problems of ppl”. Every big event results in such temporary inconvenience just like in lahore due to metro and in karachi due to green line project? but you chose to whine against IDEAS only because you hate pak army.Recommend

  • Bina

    so now you will make baseless accusations against the writer and label him as a traitor? You are everything that’s wrong with this country.Recommend

  • Bina

    do you care to answer, those making billion rupee investment, why cant they manage the road blockage situation? Corruption is a problem and so is this, the fact that normal people can’t go there makes it even worse!Recommend

  • liberal-lubna-fromLahore

    what a nonsense blog.

    Pakistani fake liberals’ just love pointing fingers at others and love playing the victim and the blame game.

    The event was for a good cause.Not for the elite. If your concern is traffic being burden on common citizen then your rant is directed towards government in charge of managing infrastructure not the elite you feel jealous from.

    If you are so concerned about the general public, then please come back and do your charitable work and then boast about it through your blogs. But, also be prepared to face backlash with blogs that would blame you for doing things for your self interest. Let’s see how you would feel then.Recommend

  • babafOOka

    Very honest & correct views by author, laudable. Most Pakistani are hypocrite who are actually engaged in discrimination but won’t publicly share it. I hope to see similar good piece of work. Best wishes & thanksRecommend

  • babafOOka

    Oh no you are being a traitor along with the author by daring to say such things!Recommend

  • babafOOka

    billions investment is worthless if citizens have to suffer like this bt ur dumbness prevents you from seeing thatRecommend

  • babafOOka


  • babafOOka

    Tell us more abt the positive things mister iqbalRecommend

  • babafOOka

    He is actually being a good pakistani by saying these things but ur too ignorant to realizeRecommend

  • babafOOka

    hahahaha now what have these facts got to do with the problemRecommend

  • babafOOka

    yup sounds like our national habit nowRecommend

  • babafOOka

    yes and thats wat the issue really is!Recommend

  • alama.javed

    I think these probs should be solved before these powershows happen, for the convinience of public so ppl dont get chance to say bad things abt it!Recommend

  • alama.javed

    and why ppl like u dun understand that people r more imp than weapons of a country!Recommend

  • alama.javed

    true brother v true…Recommend

  • alama.javed

    sone ppl still only criticizing the author, shameful attitude of public indeedRecommend

  • alama.javed

    I agree with u on that!Recommend

  • Bill

    “Weapons for Peace” Weapons can Never bring “Peace”.Recommend

  • liberal-lubna-fromLahore

    where is my post ET?Recommend

  • Ch Shahid

    Mr. Babur has well summarized the issue. Only traffic diversion.
    It was an exhibition showcasing the country’s indigenously built military hardware, not a picnic that every one should be roaming around. To deal with Foreign delegations and professionals, u have to have equally qualified staff.
    One gains with some pain.
    I am sure if writer is asked to manage the same event next year, he would do the same and than he would find hundred of logics to do so.Recommend

  • alama.javed

    really? calling the author a fake liberal while having liberal lubna as your name? lol u dont know how to name yourself yet u criticize the author. The military was incharge of this event and not the government by the way!Recommend

  • alama.javed

    You tried to post a blog? in the comments section? Dont talk abt matters u now nothing of..Recommend

  • liberal-lubna-fromLahore

    where is my comment??Recommend

  • alama.javed

    probably ET couldnt stand so they deleted itRecommend

  • Fahim

    It is problem of district & provincial government to manage the road infrastructure and traffic management. Whether there is IDEAS 2016 or not, Karachi will continue to suffer. So author hasn’t detected the disease so how could he diagnosed well? Recommend

  • Ahmad

    1st January, Year 4017 May be :pRecommend

  • Talal Shaikh

    I am entitled to my opinion and so are you. And in this particular case, my opinion coincides with the author. In no way does it mean I am a traitor. It just means that I am simply expressing my opinion based on what i have observed. There might be disagreements in opinion, but it technically doesn’t prove either of us right without proper evidence.Recommend