For better or worse, Janaan is a step in the right direction

Published: September 15, 2016
SHARES
Email

The insouciant use of pederasty in Pakhtun culture as a device to create movement in plot is ignorant and hollow. Such salient matters must either be succinctly covered when mentioned, or else become the cause of triviality. PHOTO: FACEBOOK

The Macmillan Dictionary defines a romantic-comedy as,

“A funny movie, play or television program about a love story that ends happily.”

 Janaan is just that, but it’s not funny in the ordinary sense of the word.

The film, directed by Azfar Jafri and co-produced by Reham Khan, is a latter-day ode to Pakhtun identity and heritage. It is a story about Meena, played by Armeena Khan, who returns from Canada to attend her cousin’s wedding in Swat, but falls in love with her adopted cousin.

On paper, it sounds appreciable to the Pakistani viewer, and for the most part, the outcome on the screen is adequately gratifying. The stunning introductory shots of the beautiful Swat Valley juxtaposed by the protagonist’s contemporary lifestyle in Vancouver, effectively illustrates the modern Pakistani expatriate.

We follow her journey as she lands in Islamabad and mistakes the male lead – played by Bilal Ashraf – for airport staff (apparently, he used to be fat and social media doesn’t exist in Canada). What follows next is a tedious set of dialogue about Meena’s homecoming by her extended family, distinguished by traditional sweets, small talk, and familial updates.

Regardless of these characters’ relatability, a casual lack of depth and sustained emotion are the cause of their diminishing memorability – we like watching them, but we know we won’t be recalling them any time soon.

Armeena Rana Khan
Photo: Facebook

The target audience for this movie are middle-class, educated and enlightened viewers who enjoy jokes about power outages and security issues in Pakistan – along with light-hearted love triangles between cousins.

The producers take the aforementioned for granted, as proved by respective deficiency of Urdu subtitles and an addition of English translations for Pashto conversations. This is quite potent since the jam-packed theatre where I watched the movie, was indeed a reflection of this creative decision. In fact, recurring humour with Meena’s Canadian roommates about terror in Pakistan, albeit an obvious cliché, was well-received by the crowd with whom I shared my viewing experience.

Bilal Ashraf, Armeena Rana Khan and Ali Rehman Khan
Photo: Facebook

For better or worse, Janaan is a step in the right direction for the Pakistani film industry, but two steps back in terms of the sheer profundity of filmmaking. We still seem to be glued to the plot-writing and camera techniques associated with serialised TV shows.

The screenplay, penned by Osman Khalid Butt, drags on for the most part, especially in the second half which arbitrarily relies on flashbacks as filler for soundtrack. The writing fails the lead cast, who are sketched out as superficial, funny – but not too funny personalities. Even the stand-out performance of the supportive lead by Ali Rehman Khan is hindered by the lack of gravitas in penmanship, yet his performance arguably remained the most memorable facet of this film.

The cinematography is grandiose and striking in the first half, yet reverts to the close-up, non-flattering camera visuals commonly fettered with an Urdu drama post-intermission.

Bilal Ashraf and Armeena Rana Khan
Photo: Facebook

Shallow writing and undignified camera-work aside, perhaps the greatest fault in Janaan lies in the handling of the cardinal issues it raises for the sake of plot progression and comic relief. The insouciant use of pederasty in Pakhtun culture as a device to create movement in plot is ignorant and hollow. Such salient matters must either be succinctly covered when mentioned, or else become the cause of triviality.

Bilal Ashraf, Armeena Rana Khan and Ali Rehman Khan
Photo: Facebook

Despite my critique, however, as an Eid release, Janaan is a profitable venture worth watching with family. I believe it is a successful demonstration to put Pakhtun culture and moreover, Pakistani films on the map for the long haul.

Agha Temur Durrani

Agha Temur Durrani

The author is a prospective undergraduate student and currently works at the Herald. He is a motivated researcher, debater, writer and film enthusiast. He tweets @AgTemurDurrani twitter.com/AgTemurDurrani

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Roona Meer

    Wonderful read! A great critical review since everybody seems to only be talking about how great it is. Recommend

  • Zak Khan

    A very detailed and in depth analysis of the movie coming from a young and talented individual.Recommend

  • Temur Durrani

    Thank you, Roona!Recommend

  • Temur Durrani

    Thank you!Recommend

  • Temur Durrani

    Thanks, Zak!Recommend

  • Emaad Siddiqui

    Very well written review Temur! You have a wonderful expression and reviewed the film from interesting angles ! Keep writing and sharing with us ! Great job once again ! Best wishes for the future !
    Recommend

  • Temur Durrani

    Thank you!Recommend