Why I will not celebrate Mumtaz Qadri’s execution

Published: March 2, 2016


Supporters and family members of Mumtaz Qadri sit near his body after his execution in Rawalpindi, Pakistan February 29, 2016 PHOTO: REUTERS PHOTO: REUTERS

The rumours had been floating around since the beginning of the year, but not many outside a close-knit group really knew when it would happen, if at all. Then, before his crusaders could get a whiff of what was on the cards, his family was called in one last time, and at some ungodly hour before dawn on Monday, the patron saint of religious violence – Mumtaz Qadri  was hung at Adiala Jail in Rawalpindi.

As a recap for those of you who don’t know (and I suspect there will not be many): the man in question killed Salmaan Taseer – the Governor of Punjab whom he had sworn to protect as a bodyguard – over five years ago because of his stance on reviewing Pakistan’s oft-misused blasphemy laws. Mumtaz Qadri gloatingly stood around to be put behind bars, but support for him poured in from every corner of the country as he sat around with that signature smug look. His case took several controversial turns in this time — not least when the Islamabad High Court dropped charges of terrorism against him. Ultimately, though, his sentence was upheld by the apex court, much to the outrage of those venerating him as a ghazi.

Mumtaz Qadri was, by every definition, a cold-blooded killer. So why, then, will I not celebrate his execution? In the straightest words: because an execution is not something to be celebrated. Whether Baloch youths dumped off helicopters, beheaded army officers in Waziristan or guillotined terrorists in Rawalpindi — there is no heart-warming festivity to be found in death.

Bear in mind that this is not a debate about whether the moratorium on the death penalty should be restored or not (which I am personally in favour of, but let’s save that for another time). This is about the abhorrent bloodlust that has taken root in our society.

Hanging bodies – to whomever they may have once belonged – are not a medieval spectacle for frolicking. They should not be a source of pleasure; they are definitely not a sign of progress, but could be indicative of us suffering from a collective ailment. And it is not something that Pakistan, well into the 21st century, should aspire to, either. If we visualise a just, humane, progressive society, we are going to have to start believing that violence will always, and only, beget more violence. A desensitised and bloodthirsty population is not the hallmark of a civilised nation (I’m looking at you, Saudi).

Now, while I understand the need to give in to passionate emotions at a time like this – especially for those who have personally suffered from such atrocities – how about instead of wanting to rip more people limb from limb and parade them in gory victory, we observe a moment of silence. Not for respect, but for introspection.

While there was one man who put 28 bullets in Salman Taseer’s body, there were tens of thousands gushing to the streets in their zealous mania yesterday. Don’t jump for joy, Pakistan. Deliberate over why monsters like Mumtaz Qadri are allowed to germinate in your country at an alarming rate in the first place. Ask yourself why the bar association in our capital led the charge in calling for the protests, or why our information minister was assailed by angry “clerics” at an airport, or why – and this one is my favourite – the head of the largest Islamic party in Pakistan, Jamaat-e-Islami, personally led Mumtaz Qadri’s funeral prayers in absentia.

We must ask tough questions of our representatives in the government, armed forces, bureaucracy, judiciary, and perhaps most importantly, ourselves. Why do we consistently receive impressive, yet unverifiable, statistics from the battlefront in the tribal areas, while the man who openly lends allegiance to our opponents, Abdul Aziz, is allowed to thrive in Islamabad? Why have we promoted Mumtaz Qadri from “ghazi” to “shaheed” while his mentor and inspiration, Hanif Qureshi, roams scot-free? Why do we condemn the terrorists’ means but can’t bring ourselves to publicly denounce their ends?

For all those concerned (you know who you are), it has been said time and time again, and I will repeat it for good measure: Outwardly battling terrorism while inwardly nurturing extremism will only make things worse — also known as the curious case of fighting the symptoms while ignoring (at best) the disease.

Perhaps we could exert more pressure on our representatives in Parliament to retake control of the narrative of religion that has been so carelessly handed over to any cleric with a red mosque. Maybe they could cut short their nap to make some advances on the National Action Plan (NAP) by, say, actually regulating madrassahs as planned, or not allowing banned outfits to resurface under different names. Stricter and swifter action could be taken against individuals like Mumtaz Qadri who take the law in their hands under the cloak of religiosity, while somebody could once and for all earnestly tackle the dismal state of our school curriculum.

Fortunately or otherwise, being citizens of Pakistan, it falls on us to remind our representatives of their duties when they forget them and push them to completion. Otherwise, at least as individual members of civil society, promoting a culture of tolerance, human dignity and plurality might be a better use of our time than drawing sadistic pleasure out of frenzied calls for blood. That’s what the Taliban do.

Do you think Mumtaz Qadri should have been executed?

     View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Danyal Adam Khan

Danyal Adam Khan

A freelance journalist, writer and actor, he tweets as @DanyalAdamKhan (twitter.com/DanyalAdamKhan)

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • QS

    well written piece … talks senseRecommend

  • Rohan

    Because you sympathize with terroristsRecommend

  • Hameed

    > Why I will not celebrate Mumtaz Qadri’s execution

    You want to support a convicted killer and still want to be considered a liberal. We get it. The rest is hogwash.Recommend

  • salman

    I will not celebrate his death (or any death), but I will not mourn it either.
    He was basically a criminal who committed murder, and he got his punishment. Incidentally, the penalty for murder in Islam is death (unless the deceased’s family forgives).Recommend

  • salman

    wow, did you even read the article?Recommend

  • Zahoorul Haq

    Express tribune! you seem to be allergic to Islam and constantly promoting the liberal anti Islamic agenda. Not long ago you published a XXX story about a love affair in Saudi Arabia. This shows clearly what kind of ideology are you supporting. Remember ! This country was created in the name of Islam and you will never be successful in your mission.Recommend

  • Umm e Sarah

    Yes,and when we go against the ruling of Islam,more murder and mayhem occur. Juse today on Sahiwal ,a man who had been pardoned by his family for killing his own mother killed his two sisters .
    What does the writer have to say about that?Let’s give him one more chance to kill the rest of his family.
    Mumtaz Qadri got what he truly deserved,please don’t question Islam’s ruling because no matter how literate we are,we still cannot get the wisdom behind Allah’s commands. Recommend

  • Laila

    Sir, please read the whole thing, please. And no, the rest is not hogwash because nuance is a thing and the world is not black and white.Recommend

  • Nida Ali

    Sorry Daniyal, but your attempts at exercising liberal set pieces fail to take into account the Pakistani context. Death penalty may be unnecessary in most parts of the world, but this was an ideological stand. His hanging removes the doubt on whether Pakistan thinks of Qadri as a criminal or a man of religion.Recommend

  • Eddie Khan

    1 gone and 100,000 more to go! So no point to celebrate!Recommend

  • Mahmud Majeed

    A criminal got his due punishment. Never was a Prophet lover. Prophet would never approved killing of an innocent human being.Recommend

  • siesmann

    Hardly anybody is celebrating the hanging of a self-confessed murderer.Many are satisfied with the triumph of the law,and its not succumbing to ignorant Mullahs.It is the Mullahs and their brain-washed followers who celebrated the killer’s deed,and now his death as Shahaadat.(Shaheed has hardly any meaning these days.Anybody dead is a shaheed in Pakistan.Even dead dogs are shaheeds to certain national leaders)Recommend

  • Hameed

    I have read the whole thing its hogwash. A lot of words to hide the original motive.Recommend

  • Mansoor Ali Ghanghro

    Pakistan was created “in the name of Islam”? Really? Kindly educate the ignorant. Also which school of thought (since you are of the view that Pakistan is a theo8cratic state)?Recommend

  • Naveed Ahmed

    Salam to all readers, In my opinion YES, yes we have to mourn on his death and cannot forget him, because we can not forget the cause which he did better than you and me and we can not forget also his funeral prayer congregation. I am not capable to raise my voice or do it but true love with Our Prophet P.B.U.H. can described well by him. what kind of pressure Govt. had ??? Govt. / establishment can remain him in jail as (UmerQaid) prisoner, because he had different school of thoughts and unique super cause to save the face of ISLAM. Because we are nothing without Our Prophet P.B.U.H. (like when we were child, our parents taught us how Islam did spread by Our Prophet P.B.U.H. actually we proud to be a Muslim but where is our Love with Our Prophet P.B.U.H.?).Recommend

  • salman

    To clarify, I’m not questioning the ruling or the sentence. Qadri was a criminal who got the punishment he deserved, according to Islamic and constitutional law.Recommend

  • Nishikant

    Religion should be separated from state . He was a criminal , got the punishment .
    Whats the big issue in that .Recommend

  • Nouman Ahmed

    Don’t make such sarial comments without reading.Recommend

  • Nouman Ahmed

    Why should have Government kept him in jail? If you follow Quran that much, you must also know that in Islam the punishment for murder is death. So why the fuss?Recommend

  • stevenson

    Sad that your self declared love for the Holy Prophet has blinded you to his teachings. The prophet doesn’t need you and anyone else to defend him by killing people or taking the law in your hands. I am sure the Holy Prophet would be ashamed of people like you.The Holy prophet stood for justice, rule of law and forgiveness. He suffered the worst abuse with people literally cursing him and throwing garbage at him but he forgave them all. How can you love the Holy Prophet if you can’t follow his example of tolerance?Recommend

  • Guarav Bandernaike.

    Ask the family, the near and dear ones of Governor Taseer,
    how they feel about all this. And what they went through.Recommend

  • Patwari

    Agree. A closet sympathizer. Need to come out in the open.Recommend

  • Hameedullah

    This is very unfair. The right wingers have already blamed the left for celebrating the death of Qadri. This is false. I don’t see liberals out in the streets dancing. Now this blogger has done the same (mind you i agree on all his points) and paints the situation as we are celebrating his death. This is completely untrue. This coming from a liberal writer is even more problematic. Celebrating death and hate is the specialty of religious right wing in this country.Recommend

  • salman

    My cousin is actually friends with one of Taseer’s daughters, so I know somewhat of what they went through and are indeed still going through.Recommend

  • salman

    Zahoorul Haq seems to be inspire from Zia ul HaqRecommend