My patient refuses to undergo treatment for cancer

Published: January 22, 2016

Pakistan is a 68-year-old patient, well known to our oncology service, here to see me in clinic again for an acute flare of the above-mentioned symptoms. PHOTO: SPL

Patient’s Name: Pakistan

Chief Complaint: Pains, high fevers, insecurity, depression and weight loss.

History:  Pakistan is a 68-year-old patient, well known to our oncology service, here to see me in clinic again for an acute flare of the above-mentioned symptoms. Briefly, the patient has been plagued with cancer for the last many years. It has lost over 50,000 of its cells to tumour growths all over its outside body, mostly concentrated in the head and neck area. Over a year ago, the patient visited one of my colleagues with a huge tumour that had revealed itself in its Peshawar territory.

The tumour engulfed 144 healthy, vibrant cells.

And now, the patient is here to see me again for another growth that clinically seems to be of a similar nature, and is associated with an acute worsening of his cancer symptoms.

Once again, the target of this tumour was harmless young cells in the patient’s Charsadda territory. Twenty-one cells have died and many in the vicinity have been left injured.

Photo: AFP

All body parts seem to be in severe pain at this time. The patient also complains of headaches, high fevers and a sense of insecurity and depression. Before coming to see me, the patient indulged in self-medication with 2mg of morphine, which barely seems to be effective in alleviating the pain.

As usual, the patient showed up late for the appointment, and so I had the chance to investigate the case in-depth. As per the documents that were scanned into the electronic medical record, the patient had been feeding on carcinogenic substances for the last many decades. Many doctors tried to instil some sense, but the patient consistently ignored medical advice.

Unfortunately, the patient was formally diagnosed with cancer a few years back, but continued to remain in denial about the diagnosis for a long time. In fact, until recently, it ironically wore the cancer as a badge of honour. The patient underwent screening of the whole body and its disease was found to be metastatic, spreading to all its internal body organs without exception. The patient consistently refused life-saving chemotherapy.

After years of constant pressure from friends and medical professionals alike, the patient finally admitted in December 2014 that it had a medical problem. It agreed to embark on surgical removal of the tumours on its surface. A seemingly powerful surgeon by the name of Zarb-e-Azb was employed to this end. And it seems as if the tumour growths have slowed since then. But three recent growths, including a big one in its Charsadda region, seem to have – as expected – put this treatment strategy into question.

Photo: AFP

Important as it may seem, excising an external tumour in a body ridden with metastatic disease only provides temporary cosmetic relief. Without a serious look at the cancer cells that produce these tumours and continue to eat the body from within, cancer can never be defeated in the long-term.

And it is not as if the patient does not know this. After decades of repeated medical advice to initiate a long-term and definitive treatment plan with chemotherapy, the patient finally willingly agreed to undergo chemotherapy last year. Many doctors had said it was already too late and this would be a futile attempt, but some were still optimistic.

A seemingly powerful chemotherapy regimen – National Action Plan (NAP) – was chosen for Pakistan. It looked wonderful on paper. And doctors were glad that the patient had finally recognised it had severe metastatic disease within, which was feeding its frequent tumour growths outside. NAP was meant to attack and disarm all cancer cells inside the body, and empower the patient’s natural immune system. I was one of the optimistic physicians who believed the plan, if properly implemented, would put the patient’s end-stage disease on the path to cure.

But after going through the patient’s blood tests and imaging results from last year, I am utterly shocked. Frustratingly, the cancer continues to spread.

What went wrong?

Is NAP not working?

A careful study of Pakistan’s treatment records revealed that although it was reportedly taking the recommended NAP regimen as prescribed; it had not gotten any meaningful dose. The patient was found to be non-compliant and unreliable. Cancer cells were growing just as fast and continuing to eat its tissues from within. While these cells were successfully identified, a conscious choice was made to leave them alone. In some cases, the cancer cells were nourished and protected from NAP. Ironically, and to the great dismay of my clinic staff, the patient had recently used the powerful chemotherapy regimen to kill its own immune system. This was a unique case in medical history. On December 2, 2015, for instance, records show that the patient used NAP to paralyse an experienced fighter cell that had dedicated its life to fighting the cancer from within.

Assessment: In my assessment, the patient is either deliberately ignoring the recommended chemotherapy (i.e. is suicidal, or does not have an idea of the severity of the disease, or is ignorant). Though it tries frequent cosmetic surgeries to make itself presentable, the patient is definitely not serious in fighting its underlying cancerous disease. Its cells continue to die and be paralysed; and all the patient does is make fun of them by refusing them the chemotherapy that could potentially be life-saving.


1)     Patient is clearly misusing NAP. Assess understanding of disease process and competency. Cancer education reordered. Psychiatry evaluation requested.

2)    Re-institute chemotherapy regimen after thorough understanding, with plans for home hospice if patient still remains non-compliant. Palliative care consulted to be on board.

Prognosis:  Poor.

Follow-up: Frequent (weekly) follow-ups, to reassess proper chemotherapy institution.


Kashif Chaudhry

A graduate of King Edward Medical University, Lahore and Mt Sinai University Hospital in New York, Kashif is currently completing his Cardiology fellowship in Boston, USA. He writes for various American newspapers and Pakistani publications and blogs at the Huffington Post. His interests include medicine, human rights and interfaith dialogue. He tweets @KashifMD (

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • EducationPlease

    Awesome analogyRecommend

  • Framroze Edulji

    This physician, is not board certified. He is half hakim and half doctor.
    So no patient would go to him because he just dispenses a yellow-green
    pill for ALL ailments. It’s a placebo he makes in his garage/lab. Whether you
    have cold or a heart attack, he gives this yellow-green pill. Just take one every day.Recommend

  • Zeeshan

    This is what happen when medical degree is used to project one’s ideological view. One has to wonder what they teach at King Edward and in Amreeka when these kind half baked hypotheses being married incestuously with one’s ideological ploy.

    Doctor sahab, what cause cancer? Those metastasized cancer cells – how did they metastasize? What cause them? Do you know? why do healthy cells become cancer? What cause them?

    Ideological ploy has blinded you.

    The old dictum, correlation does not equate causation should be applied to both your real and imagined cancer patients. If not, your medical degree should be revoked lest you become another criminal oncologist prescribing chemo to inflate your bank account.

    Given that you are just a doctor and possess very limited knowledge about cancer, shouldn’t you stick to being a doctor and allow cancer researchers to find the cause?

    Finally, if Pakistan is battling “cancer” , it should not seek treatment from an oncologist like you whose prescriptions have killed many number of people. Have your heard Farid Fata?

    Stick to being a doctor and just parrot what you have been taught at King Edward and in Amreeka. Causes for real and imagine cancer are a much more complex topic that is beyond your limited knowledge as a doctor. Just my 2 cents.Recommend

  • Usman

    Great analogy!Recommend

  • Bibloo

    Coming from a Hindu that IS rich. Hindu who has been down so long
    he does’nt know what up is. They think a heel of a shoe is the roof.Recommend

  • Bhimpole

    The ‘DAKTUR’ has been singing the same mantra since Moses came down
    from the mountain. Wrapping the same old goulash in banana leaves, coconut
    leaves, grass leaves, bamboo leaves. Nothing works. Just a morbid fixation.
    Same tired old argument is dressed in different rags. Point is, nobody is buying it.
    Same old tired and pathetic responses, from the same old pseudo scholars.
    Should be channeling his energies in more constructive ways. Like joining Doctors
    Without Borders and really helping humanity.Recommend

  • siesmann

    more oncogenes are being turned on like zshn ,and there are sanctuaries all over the body .Prognosis is bad,Doctor.
    And you know Dr. you are disqualified by the patient,and others from your Almamater.The patient has special allergy for your class.Last year a Cardiologist came to check the heart of the patient(gratis),and was himself eaten up by cancer cells.Recommend

  • Miyagi Jr.

    So much BBQ smoke in the comments that its polluting, causing global warming in their heads, can’t think straight, can’t even walk straight anymore!

    What else could you expect from a 42 year old patient who is a deliberate suicidal ignorant. It is already too late for this patient, but God’s mercy is above everything, so you never know.
    Keep up Kashif.Recommend

  • Dante

    Why didn’t you take that patient to Mayo Clinic in Rochester for a consultation?Recommend