#NoFeesTillLowFees: ‘Quality education’ at private schools is a myth!

Published: September 12, 2015

Under the guise of quality education, the private institutions have implemented a high fee structure with yearly increments. PHOTO: TWITTER

In 2002, when private schools initiated their long, drawn out process of bleeding the parents of this country dry, many predicted that a day would come when the middle class and the upper middle class would have to leave their air-conditioned offices to hold angry placards on the street and furiously pound their fists in the air.

That day has come.

Recently, parents and students in Karachi accumulated at the KDA roundabout and in North Nazimabad and marched up to Ziauddin Hospital in protest to the harrowing rise in the private school fees. Parents in Islamabad have also organised demonstrations in staunch opposition to the ungoverned surge in tuition charges.

Parents protesting outside Generations school.
PHOTO: Twitter (@Sohaib107)

Their placards read:

“Stop making profit in the name of education”

“No fees till low fees”

And their enraged voices reverberated through the city:

Taleem ke naam pe dukandaari nahin chalay gi!”

“Yeh kaisa insaaf hai?”

Their anger is not unwarranted. The future of any country rests on the shoulders of the education system. Pakistan’s educational system is plagued with disparities on every level. The dual nature of the system has produced many gaping rifts in society based on language and class. The section of the population that can afford private schools, which have become synonymous with the term ‘quality education’, possesses the capacity to acquire success. The other section which has been shunned into the dismal sphere of public schools can only expect to find discrimination in the professional arena. Now, with the rise in private school tuition fees, the middle class has been hit with a reality check: everything comes at a cost. It has been shaken awake from slumber. It is lobbying for reform in the private education sector; parents are talking about approaching MNA’s and the President.

Under the guise of quality education, the private institutions have implemented a crushingly high fee structure with yearly increments that are introduced without any prior notice. This has put the future of many students in jeopardy. The prospective doctors, engineers and leaders have to deal with this massive blow; they might not be able to afford their dreams anymore. In fact, very few children will.

The argument that the private education institution is presenting to disgruntled parents is that quality education is expensive and the schools have to endure high costs to keep up the standards. It is time we question such assertions. This myth of ‘quality education’ at private schools needs to be dispelled once and for all. The awful truth is that the standard of education at both public and private schools is dreadful.

A study called the Education Debate in Pakistan: Barking up the Wrong Tree conducted in 2010 by Irfan Mufazzar and Faisal Bari asserted that learning at both types of institutions, public and private, is of very poor quality. The study cites that if the education system in the country is reviewed as a whole, there is very little difference between public and private institutions in terms of the quality of education.

The parents of this country clearly share that sentiment. One parent at the protest in Islamabad asserted that the schools are just erecting more buildings and the focus on education is markedly shallow.

The question, thus, is that if the claims of ‘quality education’ are essentially false, then what are these private schools charging us for? What are the yearly increments achieving if the standard of education is still elementary?

We shell out half our salaries and sometimes more than that to be able to send our children to schools that boast of ‘higher standards’ and ‘international quality’. What parent doesn’t want to provide the best for his/her child? But the fact is that we have been fooled. We have been blinded by those big, shiny words which tell us that our children will have the brightest futures.

In 2012, the Annual Status of Education Report released a publication which featured research on the public and private education in Pakistan. Here are the depressing facts of how our children are really doing in private schools:

Irfan Muzaffar has made the shocking discovery that “a whopping 43% of the private school students were unable to read a story in Urdu”.

43 per cent. Let that sink in.

Moreover, he notes that children who attend private schools are more likely to attend private tuition as compared to public school children. So the parents are not only bearing the burden of private school fees, they are also going bankrupt while keeping up with private tuition.

In addition to this, in a study called the Effectiveness of Private, Public and Private-Public Partnership Schools in Pakistan, when academic prowess of the children in private schools was compared to the standards delineated in Pakistan’s national curriculum, Ravish Amjad and Gordon MacLeod from the Idara-e-Taleem-o-Aagahi noted that children in grade three were not able to perform the tasks which were expected of them after the completion of grade one.

49% were not able to read simple words in English.

32% were not able to do simple subtraction sums.

45% were not able to read simple sentences in Urdu.

These are not merely numbers on a page. They are our children. Is this the “quality education” we are paying for? Where is the “academic excellence” which the private schools promised us?

One out of three children going to school attends private institutions. This means that one out of three of the parents whose children go to school pay ridiculously large sums of money for education that is barely better than what public schools have to offer, and is significantly inferior to what Pakistan’s national curriculum dictates.

Do these capitalist educationalists feel no shame? They’re exploiting the love that we have for our children, they’re demanding more and more money from parents in an economic climate that is hopeless and bleak, and what are they giving us parents and our children in return? Nothing, except lies wrapped in pretty words.

We will not be fooled, any longer.

I urge all the parents to join the #NoFeeTillLowFee campaign to stop the rampant exploitation of our children at the hands of these remorseless private institutions. We need to hold them accountable to all the promises that they have made. This is a wakeup call to all the parents in the country: the facts are in front of you. You have been scammed. Stand up and fight for the rights of your children.

Salman Anwer Habib

Salman Anwer Habib

The author is a social justice activist and a journalist. He tweets as @salmananwer3

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Brain Think

    There shouldn’t be anything hard to understand about the word “private business.”

    A private business is a personal commercial property. They are free to charge $1 or $1 million for their products or services.

    If you don’t like it. Leave.

    No child is kept as a hostage in a school.Recommend

  • Imran Haider

    ok then K-Electric is a private organization doing private business. Should they be allowed to charge $1 or $1 million. If you don’t like it, use your generator. Some generic rules are not always applied every where.Recommend

  • Brain Think

    Legally they can. Whether someone should is another discussion. Yes, legally K-electric can charge whatever they like.Recommend

  • Brain Think

    Second its a free market principle. If the fees goes to high, alternatives appear in the form of new competition.

    High fees would attract more investors, but then in order to compete, they will lower the fees, eventually over saturating the market.

    That is how the free economy works. If you give it time to work, ultimately the consumer DOES benefit.Recommend

  • A Citizen

    So, the next should be against doctors and hospitals. Followed by governments (federal and local), who have recently increased toll prices much higher than the inflation. Then the next movement should be against the parliament, which has started to tax people arbitrarily and even those who have paid income taxes. Then the car manufacturers, who regularly increase prices of their vehicles. This will be followed by airline tickets (PIA included), which provide pathetic service and increase ticket prices several percentage points in one day. Then the government again, which has started to increase tax rates. If one teaches at a university/school as visiting teacher the tax rate used to be 5% during Musharraf era, then increased to 6%, then to 7% by PML-N and now it stands at 10% since last years. Since, July 1, 2015 this tax stands at 15% (deducted at source) for those who had not filed (but paid) the last year’s taxes. What about McDonald and Burger King. Hardeez anyone? The cost way more than the ‘dal-chawal’ of khokha.

    If you don’t like the fees of private school, don’t patronize them. If they get hurt, they will automatically reduce the price of their products and services. Very simple.Recommend

  • Muhammad Khan

    @ Brain Think.

    Really? Maybe ‘Think’ again.
    These schools made education a commodity. Parents have all the right to ask for ROI or demand to reduce the cost if quality of the product ain’t worth it. Not to mention that schools are bound by law as well not to increase the cost more than 5% every year.
    And why would I leave If I don’t like it? Why should I pay the high cost of switching?
    Private businesses can not do all they want. Even M$, AT&T etc were not able to do it, a little exaggerated analogy but just to get my point through…Recommend

  • Sane

    How many schools you own.Recommend

  • Faisal

    The private schools aren’t the problem here. They arent for the masses and they should not be. Pakistan should get its priorities straight and invest in its public schools, with a well educated population the economy will grow and the investment will surely pay off. The private schools will have to become cheaper to compete or they may become even more expensive and cater to a niche but either way, what pakistan needs is a good public school system.Recommend

  • Student

    “If you don’t like it. Leave.

    No child is kept as a hostage in a school.”

    Really?? No offence but you’re INCREDIBLY naive
    What do you think will happen if the parent’s can’t afford the school fees? They’ll have to take their kids out, which means that they won’t get the “refundable security deposit fee” back. Which also means that they will have to pay the admission fee, security deposit fees and the three-months advance monthly fees for the new school.(which is a considerable sum, I might add). Also some of these schools are refusing to provide Leaving Certificate to parents unless they pay two-month advance fees.

    Now the school administration knows all of this. They know the parents are helpless. They know the parents took the bait; hook, line and sinker the minute their children’s got admitted into their esteemed school. So they keep increasing the fees under various pretences without any fear of reprimand. This is blatant entrapment.

    So Yes my dear, the child IS being kept as a hostage by the school and only those parents who can afford to pay the hefty ransom can get their child out.Recommend