#PakVsIre or the #LahoreChurchBlast – which caught your attention?

Published: March 16, 2015
SHARES
Email

A Pakistani Christian family mourn over the lifeless body of a boy who was killed from the suicide bombing in Lahore on Sunday. PHOTO: AP

Pakistani Christian women mourn as they gather at a church damaged from a suicide bombing attack in Lahore, Pakistan, Sunday. PHOTO: AP A Pakistani Christian family mourn over the lifeless body of a boy who was killed from the suicide bombing in Lahore on Sunday. PHOTO: AP

One wonders if the National Action Plan (NAP) was actually implemented beyond the Punjab police’s wide arrests of clerics who tried using loudspeakers. After all, Maulana Abdul Aziz and his devotedly-radical wife Umm-e-Hassan still use a state-recognised mosque to propagate a narrative that insists the actions of groups like ISIS or the Afghan Taliban are all justified – commendable even.

Add this to the fact that the most high-profile raid to happen in mainstream news recently was not a madrassah sending jihadists to Kashmir or a mosque being operated by the rabidly anti-Shia Ahle Sunnat Wal Jamaat (ASWJ) (which still holds protests without the fear of being rebuked as violently as farmers in Okara), but the office of a popular, secular-rooted political party notorious for not being exactly law-abiding. Meanwhile, all the hate speech and weapons proliferation can continue on in centres where religion is the guiding force rather than just ethnicity.

The culmination of all that doubt in our government’s (and our military’s) enthusiasm to tackle terrorism were the church blasts in Lahore yesterday which, as non-Sunni places of worship, were supposed to have been given extra police-attention. Alas, like every other regular guy, the security guards in charge were too preoccupied cheering for Pakistan in its match-up against Ireland in a nearby teashop.

They didn’t think of the fact that they weren’t like every regular guy in Lahore. They didn’t think of the fact that as a Sunday, the churches were more likely to be attacked. They didn’t think of the fact that there was a bombing in Lahore barely a month ago, or the fact that one of Taliban’s allied factions, Jundullah, bombed Peshawar’s biggest church in 2013 during Sunday Mass. They simply shrugged off their responsibility and put the lives of over a thousand people on stake.

If that isn’t plain revolting, the reaction certainly makes it far worse.

While cricket enthusiasts continued on watching their match, just glad that it wasn’t in the Cantonment, the media proved which side it was on. By reminding television viewers that Christian protestors were carrying a nationwide protest and associating it with images of carts burning, the media ensured that the public would start equating the Christian community’s response to a terrorist bombing to the bombers themselves.

And then there’s Imran Khan and his bandwagon of followers chiming in, accusing the Punjab government of a security lapse and coming out with a statement that, as usual, condemns the incident but never names the perpetrators. Anyone who has a reasonable ability to recollect can remember the great and consistent security lapses made by the Khyber-Pakhtunkhwa (K-P) government, with the Peshawar school attack, the imambargah attack and last year’s church bombing acting as plain indicators of the hypocrisy political personalities like Imran Khan have always embodied.

For all the NAP’s effectiveness in coming out with statements to appease the international world with claims of banning terrorist organisations, Pakistan’s government hasn’t moved an inch towards recognising the threat of militancy.

The only figure who has, Jibran Nasir, isn’t even part of the political framework; he can’t make decisions that count. The ones who do count, like the interior minister who claimed that Aziz had apologised for his insensitive remarks after the Peshawar attack – a claim that Aziz immediately refuted – are too busy trying to explain to the world that “Islam is a peaceful religion and terrorist groups do not represent Islam”, as if all it takes to beat radical Islam is that essential clarification by Chaudhry Nisar.

All these claims and all these deliberations that insist on representing terrorism as a war being ‘imposed’ on Pakistan’s people and refusing to deal with the root problems have had a cost. It has detached everyone from the reality of radical Islam posing a significant threat to Jinnah’s Pakistan. It has killed thousands of Pakistanis, even before American involvement in the region.

Above all, it has made us indifferent to incidents like yesterday’s church blasts, where 14 murdered human beings simply became a numerical addition to a much bigger death toll.

Rana Saadullah Khan

Rana Saadullah Khan

A film fanatic who can't stand nationalism over liberalism, or conspiracy theories or secular facism or religious fantacism. He is an A Levels student at Learning Alliance. He tweets as @RSaadullah (twitter.com/RSaadullah)

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Maximus Decimus Meridius

    I created the article about the church blasts on Wikipedia. And just as I was combing through the news I came across a video claiming to be of “christian” mob burning down shops.I was appalled but did not link it in my article.However this later proved to be an unrelated incident of three years ago which was being used to portray the christians as an angry mob . This is the level to which some people are willing to stoop to when it comes to audience attention.Recommend

  • Gulchand Mehta

    What an excellent article ! It laid bare the ugly soul of sectarianism,
    provincialism, ethnicism, religious strife and simple hate mongering.
    With no end in sight. What a terrible terrible horrifying situation for a
    country to be in. If you argue with this, pull your head out of the sand.Recommend

  • bigsaf

    You can bet a great deal of folks will fixate on and condemn more the violent aftermath by the enraged minority protesters rather than the initial terrorist attack by majority extremists.Recommend

  • SAM-CXVII

    Comparison of a cricket match and a terrorist attack is irrelevant unless you can prove causality between the two.
    Additionally your intended message seems to have been lost. Was it our apathy to the death? criticism of the NAP? Negligence of the guards? politicking around terrorism? media bias?

    Perhaps a more focused would work better and maybe try to avoid such a seemingly desperate heading that panders to the lowest common denominator for such a grave topic as this.Recommend

  • Maximus Decimus Meridius

    Quite right. I have seen that many supporters of extremist mullahisttic religio political parties such as the ones who support JI, JUI etc etc have been constantly vomiting the mob scenes onto social media.
    This shows the mindset of the typical Pakistani extremist and makes the other residents of the country bow their heads in shame. I am quite sure that some media houses will soon be broadcasting interviews with our corrupt politicians who will focus entirely on the mob violence. What infuriates me even more is the utterly ridiculous and shameless patronizing. “OF course terrorism is bad, but anyone who takes the law in their hands will be dealt with severely”. “Everyone has been hit by terrorist attacks, but they did not retaliate, so now we will make an example of these christians”. etc etc.Recommend

  • Maximus Decimus Meridius

    Quite right. I have seen that many supporters of extremist mullahisttic religio political parties such as the ones who support JI, JUI etc etc have been constantly vomiting the mob scenes onto social media.
    This shows the mindset of the typical Pakistani extremist and makes the other residents of the country bow their heads in shame. I am quite sure that some media houses will soon be broadcasting interviews with our corrupt politicians who will focus entirely on the mob violence. What infuriates me even more is the utterly ridiculous and shameless patronizing. “OF course terrorism is bad, but anyone who takes the law in their hands will be dealt with severely”. “Everyone has been hit by terrorist attacks, but they did not retaliate, so now we will make an example of these christians”. etc etc.Recommend

  • islooboy

    Ireland match kheheRecommend