Here’s to hoping PPP rises again

Published: October 18, 2014

The party has made mistakes, some small, some massive – they must not be repeated again. PHOTO: AFP

PPP Patron-in-chief seen praying over the venue where his mother's rally was attacked in 2007. PHOTO: @BBhuttoZardari The party has made mistakes, some small, some massive – they must not be repeated again. PHOTO: AFP

In the midst of a tussle between Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaf (PTI) and Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N), Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) has been cast aside. However, after the party’s rally today, this might not be the case anymore. For Pakistan’s political web, this is an extremely positive development.

PPP was outmuscled, outwitted and completely blown away in the 2013 general elections. Statistically, PPP’s seat count in the National Assembly went down to 45 seats from the 118 it won in the 2008 elections. This was, in no small part, due to PPP’s poor performance from 2008 to 2013. As things unfolded following the elections, the general feeling was that PPP was redundant and dead as a political entity, with the 2013 elections being one of the last nails in its coffin. The old guard had been put to shame, and the new one went unnoticed.

While it is fair to say that the rise of PTI created a massive chunk in PPP’s electoral potency, likewise it is also fair to believe that Pakistani politics needs a vibrant PPP back.

Historically, PPP has been the most potent left-wing political force in Pakistan at the federal level. While it has been guilty of making a disappointing shift to the right wing’s capitalist end at various points in time, Bilawal has injected some much needed left-blood into the party again.

Starting from the current civilian ruling class to the military, capitalist blood runs through the country’s veins.

A country where an industrialist, drowned in blood of the proletariat, serves his third term as prime minister. A country where the ruling elite showcases consumerism in all its sick glory and the average man struggles to feed himself even once a day. A country where the phenomenon of religion and hyper-nationalism is poisoning minds every passing day. A country where, out of the two political entities brawling it out for federal power, one feeds off private industries and the other feeds off misguided anarchy, fuelled by hyper-nationalism – the choice of ideologies is limited, and it doesn’t make for pretty reading.

With a potent PPP, a third ideological narrative is offered; an ideology that – if executed properly – can reap benefits on both social and economic levels. This is of utmost importance in order to avoid pushing Pakistan in a position where the only available option is either hyper-nationalism or the socioeconomic horrors of privatisation. A third option, one that speaks for the working class, one that empowers the proletariat, one that addresses the issue of class conflict, is pivotal for Pakistan.

PPP’s recent history has been a massive disappointment. No one realises this better than the PPP leadership themselves, even if they don’t admit this publicly. But after the dust from the 2013 general elections settled, there have been a few bright spots for the party.

The Sindh Festival was brilliant, and Bilawal’s bold stance on terrorism has been commendable. But all this needs to translate into something more.

It is obvious that the party has become more active off late, showcased by the recent movement in Southern Punjab. It is still, however, playing third fiddle to PTI and PML-N despite being the official opposition in the Parliament. This has not necessarily been a bad thing, since it has allowed them to avoid the media spotlight and regroup as a political entity again.

Critics of PPP will bring up arguments such as Bilawal House occupying public property, cell-phones being shut down in Karachi due to the rally, the treatment dished out to Rehman Malik and the likes – all things effectively going against the PPP’s ‘for the people, with the people’ roots. These are all valid arguments, and ones that need to be addressed by PPP urgently. There has to be a better way to offer Bilawal security than by causing inconvenience to people. Tightening security for a one-off rally is understandable but doing that perpetually is not.

However, what needs to be remembered is the fact that, due to Bilawal and PPP’s very vocal anti-terrorism stance, the threat to them is very real. It was there when they were campaigning for the 2013 elections and it is still here today.

There is also the regular argument of what makes Bilawal stand out. How is he better than any other politician?

The answer is simple: Bilawal doesn’t stand out right now. He has a while to go before he is able to do that. What he does bring to the table, however, is a massive political legacy – first built by his charismatic grandfather and further honed by his mother. He also brings with him an incredible amount of baggage amid accusations of corruption and inefficiency, the lessons of which PPP learned in the 2013 general elections. The point is to take everything in your stride and learn. Awami National Party (ANP) and Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM) will never rise as federal political entities; therefore it is down to PPP to keep the left-wing active at the federal level.

An active left-wing in Pakistan is imperative. The roots of PPP are imbedded in Marxist theory and Socialism. The same roots that have given Pakistan brilliant statesmen like Aitzaz Ahsan, Raza Rabbani, and Malik Meraj Khalid. It is essential that those roots are not abandoned again the way they have been in various moments during the party’s rollercoaster history. The party has made mistakes, some small, some massive – and they must not be repeated again.

When all is said and done, what needs to be acknowledged is that Pakistan was not better off without its strongest ideological political party in limbo. Here’s hoping that the PPP rises again, following today’s rally, stays true to its ideological roots and moulds a positive future for itself and the country.

salman Zafar

Salman Zafar

The writer works in the Education Sector and tweets as @salmanzafar1985 (

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Maximus Decimus Meridius

    Za Bhutto brought religious extremism into the country and opened the door for Taliban and other mallahism inspired organizations.
    ZA Bhutto destroyed the industry of Pakistan by nationalizing it
    PPP destroyed half of Pakistan in 1971.
    They destroyed Karachi in 1990’s
    They Destroyed our accountability process with the NRO
    They destroyed our economy during their last tenure
    The destroyed the name of Pakistan during their last tenure.
    Sir do you have a memory of Goldfish? I am pretty sure if our countrymen are illiterate and ignorant enough to give them the reins of the country one more time, then perhaps we deserve them.Recommend

  • Asad Randawa

    The bhutto legacy is that of crooks. From Zulfikar to MR. 10% all downright, dirty, good for nothing crooks.Recommend

  • Saleha Niazi

    LMAO jiyalas are more hilarious than patwaris these days. Recommend

  • Prashant

    Some people, when they are born, the entire country knows that they have their future leader, it does not matter how dumb he might turn out to be but as long as he is not completely nuts and his father continues to own a political party until he grows up, his future is certain and the future of their subjects remains as uncertain as ever, this applies to people across the Indo-Pak border.Recommend

  • Jehad

    using terms like Marxism and socialism, how on earth socialists supposed to be ppp like feudal and peers? and how on earth socialists could declare an acclaimed Muslim sect kafir??? PPP is misusing the world liberal, socialist left wing etc…Recommend

  • Parvez

    After watching the PPP-Z tamasha , the rented crowd, the mindless speeches ( except for Aitzaz Ahsan ) the sheer rambling of Bilawal with the glaring hypocritical contradictions …… to me looked like a drowning man clutching at straws to stay alive.Recommend

  • Parvez

    After watching the PPP-Z tamasha , the rented crowd, the mindless speeches ( except for Aitzaz Ahsan ) the sheer rambling of Bilawal with the glaring hypocritical contradictions …… to me looked like a drowning man clutching at straws to stay alive.Recommend

  • Abuzar Jamil

    Mr.Author says in the last para that “what needs to be acknowledged is that Pakistan was not better off without its strongest ideological political party in limbo”. Mr.Author Pakistan was better off when there was no political party in the limbo.This country only prospered under dictatorship of General Ayub and General Musharaf.Recommend

  • Maximus Decimus Meridius

    100% correct. Sad but true.Recommend

  • Maximus Decimus Meridius

    100% correct. Sad but true.Recommend

  • nust
  • nust
  • Adnan

    Lol ! This is Pakistan not some Bhuttoland!Recommend

  • sammy

    pop pmln pmlq etc etc your time is over- stop repeating what has happened on the name of your ancestors, you cannot let this turn into your kingdom, the nation has woken up and we know about your corruption and bribery, your time is up boys.Recommend

  • syed

    To sum it all up, bilawal bhutto is to pakistan what rajheev ghandi is to India and like congress, PPP has been decimated in terms of public opinion to the point of no returnRecommend

  • Afroz

    The only way PPP can resurrected in the political arena is their performance. If PPP able to transform some city of Sindh like Karachi, Larkan, Naudero and Sukkur into a city of symbol of good governance.
    Hoping that slogan of Bhutto will help to sail through is merely a hope.Recommend

  • ishrat salim

    PPP may rise from its ashes, but at what cost. PPP has pointed out by the writer,has a number of old faces, who are asset, but their services have never been put to actual use for thr benefit of the poor people, people like Raza Rabbani, Aitazaz Hasan & Malik Meraj to name few. If these stalwarts continue to be side-lined, which AAZ is habitual in doing so, than PPP has Sindh & it has sinned….Recommend

  • footyfan

    It’s simple, they are history now and don’t see them coming in power ever. Perhaps they need a real Bhutto not Zardari. Recommend

  • Mubeen Hussain

    just two words, perform and revive!Recommend

  • marik

    I’ve said this before. Nothing is more right-wing than a dynasty. If PPP was truly left-wing it would have abolished feudalism. But PPP is nothing but the party of FEUDALISM.Recommend

  • Hameedullah

    Here’s to hoping that it never does.Recommend

  • Hameedullah

    PPP is liberal and socialist only in name.Recommend

  • Ferrero Rocher

    People in PPP love to flaunt how liberal they are while they are perhaps the most backward party in Pakistan. Go into interior Sindh and you will know this is nothing short of modern slavery. What did PPP do to rid of this system which they have had under their control for the the last 3 decades? Nothing, and the reason is that it is this system which supports them in getting votes. Furthermore, there are cases like Ms. Parveen Junejo’s whose husband put a gun to her head and told her to resign.Recommend

  • Saad

    Lol, I feel sorry for this blogger who despite being and a well educated person is hoping to see the most corrupt party come into power again to loot this poor people of Pakistan and deprive them of their basic rights by filling their accounts.Recommend