Are the beaches in Karachi safe?

Published: August 1, 2014

A Pakistan Navy helicopter carries out a search operation at Clifton beach. PHOTO: REUTERS

A Pakistan Navy helicopter carries out a search operation at Clifton beach. PHOTO: REUTERS Rescue workers in red shirts carry a stretcher as they run to receive the body of a victim who had drowned on Wednesday, from a Pakistan Navy helicopter, after search rescue operation by the navy, at Karachi's Clifton beach July 31, 2014. PHOTO: REUTERS

This Eid proved to be the deadliest in terms of loss of lives when news started coming in of the recovery of more than two dozen dead bodies that were washed ashore at the Clifton beach, Paradise Point and Hubco beach strips. As of now, 36 bodies have been recovered and the death toll is rising with several still missing. Till further notice, the beach has been closed for public.

The horror started on the first day of Eid when an unusually large number of people turned up at the beach and spent entire days and nights enjoying their Eid beating the heat. A large number of such picnickers belonged to other cities, who were in Karachi for work or visiting relatives.

Most of the young men who drowned were in their teens. The entire search and rescue operation is being conducted by the divers and helicopters of the Pakistan Navy.

The main reason behind these mass deaths is still unknown.

Some call it a consequence of the ongoing dredging activity being done to expand the port area while a widely established fact is the disregard shown by the public towards warning signs setup by the Cantonment Board Clifton (CBC) regarding the ban on swimming in the open sea, under Section 144 with red flags installed at prominent locations throughout the Karachi shore line. Families scuffled with the law enforcers while our men in uniform, albeit low in numbers, tried their level best to keep them away from the beaches. A couple of lifeguards who were posted by the CBC pushed their limits in carrying out the search and rescue operation with limited equipment at their disposal but to no avail.

This entire episode points towards sheer negligence by beach goers and is a lesson learnt the hard way. This has, in fact, become synonymous with the negligence shown by the general public when, in the event of an imminent danger, our people run towards it rather than from it. Be it a cyclone or an oil spill at the sea, Karachiites make it a point to rush to the danger zone in order to witness the danger ‘first hand’. Besides the ignorance of our masses, the under strength law enforcement agencies and poorly equipped rescue services failed to respond to SOS calls in a timely and efficient manner.

The water and safety aspect is getting more and more relevant with each passing day. The estimated figure of 360,000 drowning deaths annually worldwide is an alarming figure and thus, developed countries have been working towards improving their rescuing protocols.

Here are some of the standards that are followed worldwide:

Measures necessary to minimise frequent drowning cases

  • Educating the public
  • Denial of access and/or provision of warnings
  • Acquisition of rescue and survival skills
  • Provision of rescue equipment and its maintenance

Together, these measures constitute a drowning prevention strategy to help control risk. Operators, CBC in this case, must adopt a proactive approach rather than a reactive one. No beaches are safe and each beach has its own dynamics and needs to be dealt with separately as an individual case.

Identifying beach hazards

There are two main types of sea currents that are caused by tides-wave action or a combination of both.

A rip current is a body of water moving out to sea and is often fast moving with a potential to drag swimmers in to the open sea and cause drowning. Such currents can be identified by the following characteristics:

  • Discoloured water, generally brown due to sand stirred off the bottom
  • Foam on the surface extending beyond the beach
  • Waves breaking larger and further out on both sides of the rip, often on banks
  • Debris floating seawards
  • A rippled appearance when the water around is generally calm

A lateral current is a body of water moving parallel to the shore and is caused by either the tidal flow along the coastline or the action of waves hitting the beach at an oblique angle. In most situations, for an average swimmer, there is no danger as the current takes them along a beach rather than away from it. However, in some locations, these currents can wash into a rip current or off the end of a spit.

The water safety code

  • Hitting the Karachi beach, an open sea, may look safe but even in the summer it is extremely cold and will be much harder to swim in than a warm indoor pool. Beware of deep water, slippery banks and strong currents.
  • Look out for signs and notices which tell you of the dangers and where it is safe. A red flag or a skull and bones sign means that there is danger ahead and that portion of the beach should be avoided at all costs.
  • Go in a group rather than going alone. Children should always be accompanied by adults and water sports enthusiasts should ensure someone else is near.
  • By learning rescue and survival skills, you may be able to help someone else and yourself if there is an accident. Instead of jumping into the water to save someone, immediately call for help rather than putting your life in danger.
  • Stick your hand up and shout for help if you feel you can’t swim back to the shore.

Flag system

Internationally, a standard flagging system is adopted for beach safety purpose. A red rectangular flag depicts danger ahead (no swimming zone). Red over yellow sign shows the position of life guards on duty.

What needs to be done?

In order to prevent such accidents from happening, the government of Sindh and CBC will have to come up with a dedicated rescue service which shall have a team of trained and competent rescue personnel with a decent salary structure and perks. Services of international search and rescue consultants can be obtained in this regard in order to train our men and women on contemporary lines. General public awareness programs should be held in all local languages and on all major TV channels with maximum outreach. Rescue services should be provided in terms of speed boats and a couple of helicopters for timely rescue and relief. A proper monitoring mechanism of the provided equipment should be formulated to discourage political figures from utilising such services for their own personal objectives.

While many of these steps may seem very obvious and even rhetorical to some of you, with the recent deaths that have taken place, I have realised that common sense may not be that common after all.

Arsalan Faruqi

Arsalan Faruqi

An entrepreneur with a degree in computer engineering and an MBA from IBA Karachi. He tweets as @arsalanfaruqi (

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • SamSal

    While what happened is sad and unfortunate, blaming the ‘shehri intezamiya’ is unfair. You cannot blame the city administration for people’s own stupidity. And then demanding them to compensate the bereaved families is another stupidity. People should be more careful.

    It’s sea! Everyone knows that it can be dangerous if you go deep.Recommend

  • Supriya Arcot

    My thoughts are with the mothers of those who left us . May the gods grAnt them strength at this time .Recommend

  • Fawad

    Author, kindly change your statement to “Do we know about beaches”. Beaches are never been a safe place, if you go all over the world beaches are dangerous during monsoon season. It’s the people who needs to take cautions. If you are silly then you’re responsible for your action.Recommend

  • Syeda KAzmi

    Very right… If you talk about international standards, in any country if the Government declare any beach as “unsafe” people refrain themselves from visiting in the first place… they cooperate with officials and are sane enough to deem the danger… I don’t see much of Government’s negligence here…the coastal areas are widespread, its not possible for police to check everywhere.. If the CBC has setup warning signs about the ban, people should have been responsible too..Recommend

  • Adnan Moosa

    Good article Arsalan with very valuable suggestions. Would suggest send the same through separate letter to all concern authorities with a Hope that atleast one person will pick one suggestion to implement.
    Further as I got to know some one took Jeep in sea so put some suggestions to stop taking vehicles on beach at all. Put some net around half kilometer to protect people as well control garbages. Keep it up to speak your mind & heart :)Recommend

  • Kamran

    How about individuals taking some personal responsibility? The ocean was clearly dangerous. I saw it myself, the waves were high and it was windy. Very few pakistanis even know how to swim and then these geniuses go into the water wearing their street clothes. There is a reason for swimsuits as the materiel they are made of does not hold water and get heavy like street cloths do. The combination of wind, heavy waves, street clothes in the water and lack of swimming capability along with a great amount of stupidity lead to these deaths. Not only was the order not to go in the water broadcast repatedly, the authorities on site were also telling people not to go in. Ahh, but this is Pakistan where the ignorant are so sure of themsleves and the wise so full of doubt.Recommend

  • Aysha M

    Government must admit its criminal negligence. Even in western cultures where people follow law and are able to exercise restrain, there is visible and active governmental presence to regulate public behaviour. There are always individuals among masses who need to be guided by the government to make wise and safe choices. Sindh inevitableRecommend

  • Sane

    Nothing is safe in Karachi or Sindh as we have a dozed Chief Minister.Recommend

  • Jazib

    There is no negligence on part of government. The government did not pick up and throw the people in sea water. These people willingly went in the water themselves.

    The ‘victim’ mindset is so prevalent. Pakistan, please stop being a country of victims and take responsibility for own actions!Recommend