Saying “Children die every year in Thar” doesn’t make it acceptable, Sharjeel Memon!

Published: March 15, 2014

People of Tharparkar do not have clean drinking water and it makes one wonder what has been done to improve such basic needs. Looking at the indifference of Mr Memon, it seems that we will keep wondering. PHOTO: FILE

The Information Minister of Sindh, Sharjeel Inam Memon, has been advocating a conspiracy of false hype regarding the Tharparkar draught and claiming that the media is wrong. He even expressed his views on Waseem Badami’s show 11th Hour on ARY News:

This is a classic case of the ‘feudal mindset’ – how dare the voice of the poor reach the media? A feudal never likes that. This negligence is not really an inefficiency to perform; rather it’s a policy. A feudal likes it when people come to him with issues and if all their problems were resolved, how would he make them feel indebted to him?

Imagine a king sitting on his throne and no one from his realm comes to visit him laden with issues and pleas. The so-called catering to their subjects boosts their egos and makes them feel important.

The entire Sindh government comes across as uncaring about the Thar crisis on media and it seems that people dead or dying isn’t much to be concerned about. The information minister said,

“For the past many years, children have been dying in Thar. In 2011, 140 children died in Tharparkar, in 2012 the death toll was 139, in 2013 it was 196 and in 2014, 50 children have died to date. 600 children die every day in Pakistan because of lack of good facilities.”

Apart from stating the statistics, the information minister failed to explain what efforts were being made to prevent such calamities this year and in the years to come. It almost felt as if he was shocked to be questioned on such a ‘petty’ issue. His lack of concern was apparent when he said,

“Children die every day in all of Pakistan; why aren’t their deaths reported?”

If this is not feudal mindset, I don’t know what is.

People of Tharparkar do not have clean drinking water. Animals and humans drink from the same places. And it does make one wonder what has been done to improve such basic needs of people. Looking at the indifference of the likes of Mr Memon, it seems that we will keep wondering.

It is mind boggling if you try to understand why the Pakistan People’s Party (PPP) hasn’t improved its governance after facing miserable defeat in all the provinces except Sindh. And the only explanation is their feudal mindset. It’s in the DNA of PPP – this indifference to the plight of commoners – quite contrary to their claims of fighting for ‘roti, kapra, makaan’ (food, clothing and shelter) for the common person.

Even though they did win in Sindh, it also raises the question why things haven’t changed for the people of this province for decades. After all, PPP has ruled Sindh for so many years but it seems that the condition of people is still the same, if not worse. This feudal mindset is nothing but vindictive to the people of Sindh.

However, the PPP cannot take the sole blame here.  Other parties – the Muttahida Qaumi Movement (MQM), Pakistan Tehreek-e-Insaaf (PTI), Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) and other political groups are equally responsible for this crisis since Sindh is a part of Pakistan. They must free the people of Sindh from this menace and provide an alternative. It is the responsibility of all political parties to educate the common people of their rights and provide them alternate policies.

People are dying and not only are measures not being taken to prevent this in future; it is being waved off as an everyday, acceptable occurrence. All political parties have failed the people of Sindh and it is time for them to unite and stop playing dirty politics just to maintain their ‘hold’ over people. Fighting media wars is one thing but now it is taking its toll on the future of the country.

If people continue to die the way they are, soon these feudals will have no one to rule over.

Waqas Habib Rana

Waqas Habib Rana

A freelance writer and Editor in Chief at , who has been associated with video production, theater, event management and business. He tweets @waqas464 (

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Peshawar wala

    Your wrote a very thought provoking article.
    These Memons, Bhuttos, Shahs, and other
    feudal lords of Sindh are a craven and brazen bunch.
    They are interested in one priority only. Themselves.
    Then comes their families. Then sycophants. And down
    the line.
    The Sharifs are interested in Punjab only. Their constituents.
    The Cricketer, has his agenda, and that is another story….Recommend

  • privali

    could we imagine a child of zardari or bhutto facing the same hardship as these ordinary sindhis face … it is unfortunate to see sindhis still calling them their lords (saeen)Recommend

  • ovais

    They dont care about 10,000 that died in karachi only duiring the past 5 years. do u think they care at all. Same CM thats the worst part . Indeed democracy is a revengeRecommend

  • Queen

    Well said! i just hope Twitter lord Bilawal reads this blog.Recommend

  • Kotri wala

    When the Chief Minister goes to visit famine stricken
    areas. And the people,.. his voters are starving,..then what
    does he have for lunch?
    Fried Fish, Malai Boti. Biryani. Koftas. Tikkas, and Roti.Recommend

  • Seeker-of-Truth

    Democracy has always betrayed us, this is only a system of elite and not the poor! The only viable system that looks after the interest of all is the Caliphate system in which the Caliph was even answerable if a dog dies of hunger in the outskirts of its territory and in which a citizen of a caliphate could question Caliph Umar (RA) about his personal assets. Could you dare do that in this dirty democratic system and don’t expect that you would add yourself to the list of missing persons?Recommend

  • Ali S

    What’s more worrying than these feudals is the large segment of English-speaking liberal elite who defend PPP over this fiasco. I’m no fan of PTI or PML-N (before these English-speaking liberal elite start calling me a ‘troll’ or ‘apologist’), but PPP is a major reason why liberalism failed to take off in Pakistan.Recommend

  • Parvez

    You my friend deserve FIVE STARS for this write up.
    Let’s hope Bilawal Bhutto Zardari manages to somehow read this, because its high time he does something about the likes of Sharjeel Memon………but most likely he will do nothing. The reason being that in elections within Sindh its the servile mindset of the rural lot and their economic bondage to the feudals that, disgusting though it is, ensures them victory.Recommend

  • Undhyu Patil

    What kind of comments are these from a minister? no accountability at all.Recommend

  • Sindhi

    When entrepreneur’s join Politics this happens !

    He said “This is happening in thar since 3 years”, he was MPA at that time from PS-62 Tharparkar. did he do something then? Answer remains No. People die each year who cares.

    Talking about water condition, sharjeel in his tenure as MPA spent 35 crore on water projects (Tax payers money) and still condition of thar is worse.

    Only thing he did while his tenure as MPA there is that he built his “10-acre mansion at Nagarparkar (Thar)Recommend

  • Sane

    He says children die every year in Thur. At least he has the courage to accept his and his party inhumanityRecommend

  • Sane

    Not Roti, but Roghni NanRecommend