Democracy: Whose right is it anyway?

Published: October 4, 2010
Email

It is not democracy that we are not ready for, it is a lack of choice that has continued to paralyse the entire nation for over half a century.

I would be surprised if you still have not engaged in a charismatically disingenuous conversation in which a mischievous friend let lose a blasphemous idea, revolving around the topic of whether we, Pakistanis, are ready for, or deserve democracy. Democracy, which can be simply understood as the right of people to choose their leaders.

Now some, without chivalry, argue insistently that our country lacks education, maturity, intellect and economic growth levels – typical indicators of a developed nation. Of course, I do not refute the idea that we are a developing nation with abysmally low levels of education and economic growth. But the fact that the majority of the nation cannot read or write, is involved in subsistence agriculture and lives below the poverty line, is hardly reason enough to strip them off the right to choose their own rulers.

If those who are uneducated, who do not have access to clean water and nutritious food and are scraping together a living toiling on a farm are not allowed who to vote, then who does? The military? And the hedonistic educated elite, who seem to feel that they have an inherent right to play savior to the ‘uninformed’ and uneducated public?

Democracy means the right of choice. It is the right of the people, no matter what social strata they belong to, to choose to make their own mistakes. I say that because it is not democracy that we are not ready for, it is a lack of choice that has continued to paralyse the entire nation for over half a century; most of us vote for the party that we think will do the least damage.

Former president Pervez Musharraf probably understood this; the second time he felt like sitting on the ‘hot seat’, he did not resort to a ‘coup detat’. He has a party now.

musabmemon

Musab Memon

A sub-editor on the National desk of The Express Tribune

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • parvez

    Musab you have crooked cricket and the CWG in Delhi to worry about. Why involve yourself with something that is more nerve wracking formula one car racing and a bigger sham than professional wrestling.Recommend

  • WAJID

    I AM PAKISTANI AND WORRIED OF THIS SUIATION BEAUSE LEADER S ARE ONLY LEADER OF WORD AND OTHER NOTHING.WE ARE MUSLIMS AND BELIEVE ON GOD NOT ON LEADERS .Recommend

  • http://www.LiaquatAli.com Liaquat Ali

    Democracy is mob rule where unproductive majority usually abuses productive minorities through crafty legislature until the minority throws in the towel and the country goes down the drain.

    Pakistan is supposedly a Republic and NOT a Democracy. Republic is the rule of individuals through well-defined laws. Recommend