Can Moin Khan help Umar Akmal become a complete wicketkeeper?

Published: July 27, 2013

Umar Akmal is good, but he isn't even close to Rashid Latif or Moin Khan. PHOTO: REUTERS

Rashid Latif and Moin Khan are easily the finest wicketkeepers Pakistan has ever produced. Which of the two was a better choice is debatable but both had the ability to represent the national team on any and every platform.

Be it Shoaib Akhtar’s deadly pace or the reverse swing of Waqar Younis and Wasim Akram or the doosras of Saqlain Mushtaq, wicket-keeping wasn’t a problem for Pakistan as long as these two men played for the country. During their tenure, the captains even enjoyed the special leverage to use one wicketkeeper as a replacement for the other for a good many years.

Unfortunately, the Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) couldn’t find even a single wicketkeeper that could match Latif’s or Khan’s competence since their departure from the Pakistani cricket team. Instead, the PCB has been relying upon half wicketkeeper and half batsman, Kamran Akmal, for nearly a decade now. Akmal has been in and out of the national squad, mainly due to his poor performance, but he keeps coming back because either the team doesn’t have any replacement options or the Board doesn’t want to replace him.

I recently came across two news stories: “Kamran Akmal is hoping for another comeback and “Moin Khan appointed as Chief Selector, PCB”.

Given that the new selector himself was a star wicketkeeper back in his days, the least this nation can expect from him is to give the national team a complete wicketkeeper — one who can bat as well.

Khan doesn’t have to rush for now as because the younger Akmal — Umar Akmal — has performed well against the West Indies. He was impressive behind the wickets with his stumping, catches and run-outs — he even scored a half century. Khan could continue with Umar Akmal for the time being and start hunting for a permanent wicketkeeper batsman.

Khan should get inspiration from India that has MS Dhoni, a complete wicketkeeper batsman who has won his country many world titles in all formats of the game. And they also have Dinesh Karthik — another fine wicketkeeper batsman — who can replace Dhoni if ever required.


Farooq Baloch

A reporter for the business desk at The Express Tribune

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Muhammad Ishfaq

    Well, well, I don’t think Umar Akmal was impressive behind wickets in the first place, but yes, given that Moin Khan is our chief selector now we can hope to have a decent wicketkeeper.Recommend

  • ali

    Umar Akmal needs to turn into a complete batsman first.Recommend

  • Musadiq Khan

    Article is about Umar Akmal and we have Kamran Akmal’s pictre. Ironic is its Express tribune.Recommend

  • Usama Bin Ahmed

    @Muhammad Ishfaq:

    Believe me friend, still he is way better than his elder brother :)Recommend

  • Muhammad Ishfaq

    @Usama Bin Ahmed:
    yup, I must agree with you on this…. way better than Kamran Akmal :)
    But still would love to see a wicketkeeper who is not Akmal :D Recommend

  • Usman

    Future wicketkeepers are considering changing their last name to Akmal so that they may play for pak.Recommend

  • Hassan

    Rashid Latif was the finest wicket keeper ever. Not talking about batting, just keeping. Ask any player, they will point to Rashid LatifRecommend

  • Omar

    I think Umar Akmal is the best batsman in the current Pakistani team. He should only concentrate on his batting. I rate him even better than Misbah. In the last series against WI he had and average of above 50 and strike rate of over 100 in both ODIs and T20s. No other player was even close to him. He should be allowed to bat at #4.Recommend

  • Hassan

    Akmal is a way ahead of his elder brother in terms of wicket-keeping. And a bit of training and grooming can develop him as a complete wicketkeeper-batsman, though it is early to say, yet it is desirable. Recommend

  • Hassan

    @Musadiq Khan:
    Nice pointing out! Recommend