Barfi!: A sweet cine-treat for all

Published: September 21, 2012

Carefully understanding the lives and needs of autistic and differently-abled people, Basu has pulled his lead characters out of their traditional roles in a cry-fest. PHOTO: PUBLICITY

For someone who had not seen the rushes, Barfi! was a pleasant surprise. When I walked into the theatre I was unaware that I was about to watch a film where the lead actor had a speech and hearing impairment, and that the lead actress was autistic.

About ten minutes into the film, when the audience is told that Barfi, Ranbir Kapoor’s character in the film, had severe impairments, I braced myself to watch another emotive movie that would leave me crying profusely and feeling sorry for the differently-abled.

Until the end, I kept waiting for that moment.

The film manages to constantly put a smile on your face and gently sprinkles bouts of laughter in several scenes.

Director Anurag Basu had proven that he understands the myriad complexity of human emotions when he made Life In A Metro in 2007; with Barfi!, he has gone a step further.

Barfi had all the reasons to be a traditional Bollywood tragic hero – his mother died at birth, he’s poor and penniless through his youthful days and is left brokenhearted by a rich girl. However, Barfi is different and so is Jhilmil, Priyanka Chopra’s character, an autistic child who is loveless and companion-less for most of her screen life.

Attempting to carefully understand the lives and needs of autistic and differently-abled people, Basu has pulled his lead characters out of their traditional roles in a cry-fest.

Ranbir Kapoor is not only the current hot-favourite among the girls, but has also been consistent in getting critics’ accolades. This is another such performance which can bag a huge chunk of the awards next year.

At the start of the movie, where Ranbir Kapoor is being chased by a policeman, played by Saurabh Shukla, Ranbir’s expression of youthful carelessness and joy comes alive on the screen. The scene is also shot wonderfully well with interesting camera angles, and contributes a great deal in building up the pace of the movie.

I felt, however, that Priyanka Chopra has overdone her bit. The worst criticism for an actor is when the audience can see the actor as being separate from the character, and that is exactly what Priyanka does in several scenes. Jhilmil is lost (or overdone) reminding the audience constantly that they are watching Priyanka Chopra’s pretence. The scene when Jhilmil is brought back home from ‘Muskaan’, a foster home for differently-abled people, exemplifies my point.

South Indian actress Illeana D’Cruz surely gets into the skin of her character named Shruti, who is also the narrator of the story. She is crafty, both at the romantic scenes and at the emotional ones.

More than once during the 180 minutes, the audience is caught sitting intently on the edge of their seats, predicting the character’s next move. Some of those moments are when Shruti holds the train ticket in her hand and is deciding whether to leave her life as a wife of a rich man behind; when Shurti hears Jhilmil scream out Barfi’s name and is in the dilemma of whether to convey that to Barfi, and the scene in which Jhilmil runs behind Barfi’s moving bus.

The music is exceptional and keeps in tone with the changing mood of the film. Music director Pritam does the trick again in getting the music just enough attention that is required. The songs do not take away attention from the scenes, neither are they too insignificant that they go unnoticed.

Barfi! is an enjoyable watch, mostly because it springs a surprise on the audience and let’s them carry a sweet, happy feeling back to their homes.


Read more by Raksha here or follow her on Twitter @Raksha_Kumar

Join us on Facebook for blog updates and more!

Raksha Kumar

Raksha Kumar

The author is a Bangalore based video journalist freelancing for the New York Times and the BBC. She graduated from the Graduate School of Journalism, Columbia University in May 2011 where she majored in TV news. She is a Fulbright Scholar and has worked in various media outlets in India. She tweets @Raksha_Kumar.

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • GrimmJow

    Cr*ppy Movie! :PRecommend

  • ayesha

    Loved every bit of the movie. Barfi and Jhilmil stay with you long after the film ends! Recommend

  • Saad Aziz

    Barfi is magic,i was in a trance throughout the movie,is one of the best movie ever made,the only movie i saw two times in a theatreis a treat for all,don’t miss it,will surely make you a better personRecommend

  • Phatty

    Priyanka Chopra was actually really good. I found her to be extremely adorable, in fact.Recommend

  • TheBlueEyedson
  • Umair

    Very lengthy movie. I enjoyed first 30 mins only after that movie becomes very difficult to understand & I lost my interest completely. I don’t understand why such confusing movies get so much appreciation. The director tried to make Oscar winner THE ARTIST with desi story. I couldn’t find any difference between ranbir kapoor with voice (ajab prem ki gazab kahani) & without voice (barfi). I hate music as well. The only good thing about this movie is the debutant girl. She is beautiful & was the only reason to keep my interest for first 30 mins. Don’t watch & don’t waste time. Media always supports such idiotic movies.Recommend

  • hiraz

    Barfi had the exactly same scene from the Note book.Recommend

  • Rashid Nazir

    Agree with your opinion. Its again a copy of hollywood film with a desi touch, thats the norm of indian film industry though they had also made many good films. But many a times they also copy hollywood flicks with desi touch. I have only watch the tailor of this movie, and it looks like an overrated movie. Actually indian film industry now do dare to make films on different topics, but the somehow over do and dont do justice to these topics like hollywood movies did. The acting and overall treatment is pathetic. But our media do our level best in praising for such movies as these are the best things in world. I would rather prefer throwing my money in gutter than seeing these over acting films. Recommend

  • BlueEyed

    And here’s a reason why you may not like Barfi:

    link textRecommend

  • Zahra Haroon

    I enjoyed watching Barfi. Loved it!!!Recommend

  • Insaan

    Why is it some people’s comments show they liked the movie Burfi a lot, others just could not stand it and some others think Pakistani media does not know what they are doing. Same movie but extreme reactions.

    A movie is for entertainment and when some one starts analyzing everything they are not going to enjoy anything. Recommend

  • manoj

    it is very amazing movie …i lov it…Recommend