Sunny
High: 31°C
Low: 26°C

Power marred by tragedy: Kennedys, Gandhis and Bhuttos

October 23, 2011

These ill-fated families had everything in abundance including loss, yet continued to become much-loved legacies.

Fairy tales will always be just that, fairy tales! Happily ever after can never reach the extraordinary heights reached by its antagonist, tragedy. And when tragedy strikes real people, it hits where it affects the most and becomes history.

Perhaps the biggest ambassadors of misfortune are the three cursed, first families that we loved, believed in and mourned over the years. The Kennedys, Gandhis and Bhuttos sow a similar fate and carved the same destiny for themselves.

The intertwined dynasties of these families were given the same screen play, with different settings and dialogues.

John F Kennedy the 35th president of the United States enjoyed the stature of a glamorous movie star instead of a customary, dry politician. He gave rise to the media and was a god-like figure, globally plastered as an enigmatic, revolutionary leader. A glamorous couple, he and Jacqueline were the epitome of allure, power and immense fascination.  His trademark revolutionary dialogue – Ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country, was matched by Indira Gandhi’s Gharibi Hatao and ZA Bhutto’s, roti, kapra, makaan.

Indira Gandhi rewrote history by becoming the first woman Prime Minister in India’s male dominated society. For rural India, she was their mother and to date her devotees show unprecedented support for the congress.

The pioneer of Pakistani democracy was the open buttoned, sleeves folded, not adorning a khaki uniform, the revolutionary — ZA Bhutto. A country starving for a voice that could free them from military rule welcomed ZA Bhutto with open arms. He gave Pakistan an identity through the Islamic Summit in 1974, gave it security by founding the nuclear programme and initiated peace dialogues with India. To date, ZA Bhutto arguably remains the most popular leader of the nation.

The power legacy set by these leaders was embellished later by their next of kin.

Robert Kennedy who worked with his brother as Attorney General, became the forerunner for the Presidency.

Rajiv Gandhi a professional pilot, became the youngest Prime Minister of India in 1984. His widow, Sonia Gandhi leads the ruling party in India today.

ZA Bhutto’s daughter, Benazir Bhutto, became the first woman Prime Minister of a Muslim state in 1988 and in 1993. Her widower, Asif Ali Zardari is the current President of Pakistan.

However, it wasn’t all fame and power for these ill fated families.

The Kennedys have had a tragic end to their dynasty with unnatural deaths haunting all male members of the family. The most shocking assassination, perhaps more so than Ceaser and Lincoln was that of John Kennedy. In 1963, the president was shot dead in his motorcade. Captivating scenes of JFK Junior saluting at his father’s funeral, Jackie’s blood-stained pink dress and America’s public grief were etched into memory. Younger brother Robert was later shot dead while campaigning and another brother, sister and son died in plane crashes.

The Gandhi legacy was blood stained in 1984, when Indira’s own guards opened fire on her. She succumbed to 19 bullets an hour later. Grief was overshadowed by anger at the death of the nation’s mother when thousands died in an anti-sikh massacre. In 1991 her son and  then Prime Minister Rajiv Gandhi was killed when a woman bowed down to touch his feet and detonated explosives on him. The bomb was so powerful that he could only be identified by his tennis shoes. Younger brother Sanjay had already died in a plane crash in 1980.

The Bhutto’s maintained a similar sordid tale, as the family saw a death almost every decade.

ZA Bhutto was hanged after a murder trial in 1979. With him died the visionary and commanding leadership of a man becoming too popular in the region. In 1985, younger son, Shahnawaz Bhutto, 27 was poisoned while surviving son, Murtaza Bhutto was assassinated in front of his house in 1996 when his sister was the Prime Minister. She too met a similar violent end a decade later when she was shot in 2007. Benazir Bhutto had survived several assassination attempts before she finally lost the battle and her blood flowed in the same spot where Pakistan’s first Prime Minister was assassinated.

The images of a convertible cruising with the first couple of America and gun shots being heard; Benazir Bhutto waving to the crowd and then going down with the explosion; the assassin bowing down to touch Rajeev Gandhi’s feet — all images that will perhaps always remind us of life’s unpredictability. These families have seen power, money, success, tragedy and sorrow like no other. They had everything in abundance including loss, yet continued their ill-fated tradition becoming much-loved legacies shortly after they dramatically came, saw, conquered and surrendered to the will of God.

Nusrat Bhutto, in her struggle and her sorrow continued this Bhutto legacy, departing from this world today. May her soul rest in peace.

on Twitter, become a fan on Facebook

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

 Posted by Parkha Zeb
 

Readers Comments (33)

  • Reply Rubab A. Zaidi Oct 23, 2011 - 8:30PM

    Brilliantly written!! What a fine tribute. :-)Recommend

  • Reply Tanzeel Oct 23, 2011 - 9:11PM

    Unlike Kennedys and Gandhis “Kal bhi Bhutto Zinda tha aaj bhi Bhutto Zinda hai”Recommend

  • Reply zafar Oct 23, 2011 - 9:29PM

    RIP nusrat bhutto !! great article!Recommend

  • Reply Mishka Oct 23, 2011 - 11:18PM

    How True. .. All that fame and power came with a heavy price, that cost their entire families’Recommend

  • Reply Sana Oct 23, 2011 - 11:38PM

    //The pioneer of Pakistani democracy was the open buttoned, sleeves folded, not adorning a khaki uniform, the revolutionary — ZA Bhutto. A country starving for a voice that could free them from military rule welcomed ZA Bhutto with open arms. He gave Pakistan an identity through the Islamic Summit in 1974, gave it security by founding the nuclear programme and initiated peace dialogues with India.//
    what utter crap, Parkha Zeb.. seems like you need to brush up on your history and learn what a fascist ZAB was. Always felt sorry for his poor wife, battling so many crises brought on by the hubby. RIP dear lady.Recommend

  • Reply Zia Wali Oct 24, 2011 - 12:47AM

    @Sana: At the time he was a welcoming change from the disctatorship of Zia. Poeple were bhind him hundred percentand to date no leader enjoys the kind of support he did back then. Recommend

  • Reply Ali Tanoli, Oct 24, 2011 - 1:28AM

    He gave us sense of security he gave us faghr e pakistan he gave us identity he was one
    brave son of soil he never beg for his life in front of munafiq dictator he secrificed his whole
    family for islamic pakistan. Jaye Bhutto.Recommend

  • Reply Imran Oct 24, 2011 - 1:47AM

    @Sana: What do you not agree with in the above copied statement~That the Islamic Summit wasn’t a great contributor in putting Pakistan on the world map, he shouldn’t have initiated the nuclear programme or after the 65 war he shouldn’t have had peace dialogues with India?
    The ‘poor’ wife had a mind of her own and was perfectly capable of making her own decisions/choices!
    Nobody is dwelling on their political characters in this article. Recommend

  • Reply Anonymous Oct 24, 2011 - 2:48AM

    Respect for these power dynasties are markers of a slave mindset. They should all die out and their supporters come to senses.Recommend

  • Reply Mustafa Moiz Oct 24, 2011 - 5:50AM

    Zulfikar Ali Bhutto was deposed as mass protests and the prime minister’s own thugs threatened to bring the country to civil war. It was only the Armed Forces saved Pakistan at that stage.Recommend

  • Reply Baba ji Oct 24, 2011 - 10:23AM

    Power is like Heroin/coke !!!! once you get addicted to it you will die one day of over dose ….

    “With great power comes great responsibility” – Uncle Ben , Spiderman 2 Recommend

  • Reply Ahsan Iqbal Oct 24, 2011 - 11:06AM

    never ever commented on any blog in my life….. but this article deserves to be appreciated!!Recommend

  • Reply Tipu Oct 24, 2011 - 12:11PM

    It must be remembered that these power ful people always bring their down fall through their own hands Who appointed Zia Ul Haq from ranked 7th to Chief of Army Staff When such violation of merit is done and hand picked people are appointed in key positions this will continue to happen As they say “Greed is a curse”Recommend

  • Reply Anoop Oct 24, 2011 - 12:19PM

    The Bhutto legacy is much stronger in Pakistan, than the Indira legacy in India. And, that is not a compliment.

    The term ‘Islamic’ prefixed to the name of Pakistan by Bhutto continues to haunt Pakistan. The negative fallouts of Indira’s governance and the events after her death can be comparable but they are fixable. They are scars which can be healed. But, Pakistan can never let go the word ‘Islamic’ attached to it. Recommend

  • Reply NJ Oct 24, 2011 - 1:00PM

    Zinda hy Butto Zinda hy!! Recommend

  • Reply Noman Oct 24, 2011 - 2:08PM

    What a brilliantly constructed piece. All these comments are making it political which it clearly isn’t. Its a factual narration written in a very effective way. Recommend

  • Reply Shakir Lakhani Oct 24, 2011 - 2:25PM

    Most Pakistanis don’t know that it was Iskandar Mirza (not ZAB) who started the nuclear program in Pakistan (he set up the Pakistan Atomic Energy Commission in 1956, when Bhutto was an Indian citizen trying to get his father’s property back from the government). Like Gaddafi, ZAB was also a fool, not realizing how much the people hated him. No one shed any tears when he was hanged, and even some of his supporters celebrated his death.Recommend

  • Reply Parvez Oct 24, 2011 - 2:25PM

    Enjoyed reading this. Liked the way you drew the similarities between the three. The difference is the impact each has on their respective countries. Recommend

  • Reply narayana murthy Oct 24, 2011 - 2:42PM

    Z A Bhutto was hardly a visionary.

    He was power hungry and anyone who has read Pakistan’s history objectively, knows that had Bhutto parted from power, Bangladesh wouldn’t have parted from Pakistan.

    This is a reality.Recommend

  • Reply ARFAN Oct 24, 2011 - 5:22PM

    I too enjoyed reading this article the writer related to all the different events in a very nice manner!…Recommend

  • Reply Ali Tanoli, Oct 24, 2011 - 5:33PM

    @ Naryan Murthy,
    I think u should read the history of Mr Bhutto i will say if Mr Jinnah made pakistan then
    he saved pakistan he was very vissionery person but u know army junta they dont want
    some one like him mean public figure and about bangladesh i dont why they get it in first
    hand it was too far wonderland tottaly diffrent they should have made them a country in
    1947.Recommend

  • Reply G. Din Oct 24, 2011 - 5:55PM

    Please use the correct spellings. The “Gandhis” you are talking about should be referred to as G-h-a-n-d-y-s, as in Feroze Ghandy, the patriarch of that family. Leave the poor Mahatma out of all this!Recommend

  • Reply Daljeet Singh Sidhu Oct 24, 2011 - 5:57PM

    It is great article but I would like to add that the anti-Sikh massacre that followed Indira Gandhi’s assassination was not due to general public anger but a well orchestrated genocide that had the support of several government agencies in India. Unfortunately, the justice system too turned a blind eye to the plight of the Sikhs, condoned the killings, and did not convict even a single person in the past 27 years.Recommend

  • Reply Ali Tanoli Oct 24, 2011 - 6:51PM

    @ Daljeet singh Sidhu,
    It was really sad what happend in 1984 and right word should be used here is masscare
    the way sikhs got killed and dont expect any justice in rigid society of india.Recommend

  • Reply Moulvi Nawaz Shareef Oct 24, 2011 - 7:31PM

    @ Author,
    All the respect for Kennedy Family,they really shaped modern american society, but while mentioning Bhutto’s you forgot to mention the atrocities of FSF (a security force created by Bhutto to kill and suppress his rivals), and the killing of Father of Ahmed Raza Kasuri, which was the final nail to Bhutto’s coffin. Moreover you forget to mention the genocide of Sikhs was a master mind of Indra Gandhi and that’s why she was assassinated.Recommend

  • Reply Raja Islam Oct 24, 2011 - 9:20PM

    @Mustafa Moiz:
    The mass protests were engineered by the army through the right wing fundamentalist parties who till today enjoy very little public support.Recommend

  • Reply Ali Masood Oct 24, 2011 - 11:26PM

    Wow ! What an amazing read … And @SANA like it or not but Bhutto is the post popular political figure in the history of this country .. There was something in the man because of which his political party has been in the govt thrice even after his demise despite the allegations on them… And I think it is a very well researched article because there isn’t a single thing about history that is wrong in it .. Very well written Recommend

  • Reply sidra bangash Oct 25, 2011 - 2:36PM

    Great article…weldone.Recommend

  • Reply ijaz Mir Oct 25, 2011 - 6:03PM

    Bhutto started the down fall of Pakistan, by nationalizing the banks and industry. culprit of civil war in East Pakistan. His sons were criminals , hijacking PIA aeroplane to Kabul Killing a young army man. One died by over dose of drug second was gun down by police.
    no comments fro his daughter. you cannot change history.
    you live by the sword you die by the sword, No one can escape Allah’s justice.Recommend

  • Reply Tayyab Virk Oct 28, 2011 - 12:52AM

    very well written and a wonderful piece to read ! Recommend

  • Reply ABC Oct 28, 2011 - 4:04PM

    @ijaz
    Very sad to read your mind set, such people are responsible for what today Pakistan is. And, it is more unfortunate that such people still cannot understand what is right and wrong. Recommend

  • Reply Pashtun Nov 2, 2011 - 3:55PM

    I think you have forgotten another family in your nieghbour that is AFGHANISTAN’s KARZAI family. After losing his father who was the Deputy Speaker of the Parliament in 2000 by an open fire on him by Taliban in Quetta, Karzai got this post in 2001. Now, in 2011 Karzai lost his brother as he was killed by his own guard in Kandahar.Recommend

  • Reply Dr Priyanka Nov 5, 2011 - 2:50AM

    @Pashtun:
    My friend thanks for reminding. May their souls rest in peace and God bless Mr Karzai and Afghanistan and you!Recommend