‘Jinnah’s Pakistan’ has no room for Hindus
Hindus and Muslims may have similar wedding celebrations, but there is no registration system for Hindu marriages in Pakistan.
The Indian parliament passed the Hindu Marriage Act in 1955 which made it mandatory for Hindu marriages to be registered in India. In Pakistan, the Hindu community has been demanding the same rights for decades, but to no avail.
Members of the Hindu community gave a two-month deadline to the government and threatened to hold a sit-in in front of the Parliament House in June if these demands were not met. They urged the media and concerned citizens to participate in a petition campaign as a token of support for the cause of poor Hindu women. But all to no avail.
Despite the Supreme Court’s suo motu ruling of November 23, 2010, no measure has been taken to introduce legal provisions for Hindu marriage rights by the Parliament. The assurances made by the Prime Minister have also not produced any results.
The assassination of minority affairs minister Shahbaz Bhatti further worsened the situation, especially for Hindus. Anita Vadhani, an O-Level student from Rahim Yar Khan says:
“Shahbaz was our last hope but his tragic end forced us to think seriously. We should either leave or migrate to another country.”
Shami Mai, a poor Hindu woman said:
“In case of separation or domestic violence, a Hindu woman cannot register a complaint in the government departments because she has no legal document to establish that the perpetrator was her husband.”
The shocking news about a Hindu MPA from Sindh migrating to India is another sign that the situation is worsening. PPP MNA Palwasha Behram blasted her own government in the National Assembly for the deafening silence of her fellow parliamentarians over the unfortunate fleeing of minorities from Pakistan.
But the injustice persists.
Sadly, many followers of the Hindu faith have left the country as a result of the injustices perpetrated towards them by those in power.
An Islamabad based journalist hailing from Sindh, Kapil Dev, says:
“Our community members are migrating to other countries because they think that no one accepts them in Pakistani society.”
The persecution of Hindus has become a regular feature in Pakistan, especially in Sindh. The Sikh community in Khyber Pukhtoonkhwa (KP) is also suffering from insecurity despite the power the progressive Awami National Party in that region.
Minorities’ rights are being denied and our parliamentarians and citizens are not concerned about their demands even though they have the power to change things.
Was this Jinnah’s dream for Pakistan?
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.
Misleading title.
This would never have been the case in Jinnah’s Pakistan. But who says this is Jinnah’s Pakistan? Mullah’s Pakistan fits the bill. I, as a moderate Muslim feel sidelined and threatened for voicing my opinion despite living in an urban area, but I’ll get out of here in one piece; I can’t begin to imagine what the minorities are going through just by existing.Recommend
First I have heard of this ever. So probably the minorities representatives and the media is not doing their jobs. I can not think of anyone who would oppose legislation on this.
@Ducky, don’t mask your weakness mate.Recommend
@Ducky Misleading Title exacty but you swam as far away as Siberia.
Come back Come back.
Now its incompetence of ministers and government to be seen, not biasness of general public as portrayed. Spicing the blog by Murder of Shabaz Bhatti which is Outragous. Jinnah’s Pakistan as enough room for hindus sikhs and so we accept hindus and chirstian they all the right to live and practice religion and get married live agood life in generall.
As for the bill mate they are excavating Bhutto’s grave right now what do you expect from them they will reincarnate Bhutto and God knows what next
In all seriousness we cant overlook out minorities if we do what will be the differnce between us and Israel where minorities are called “leeches”.Recommend
I seriously feel that minorities should migrate to other countries, bad days are ahead. People dont care when bombs go off in mosques, shrines or Imam bargahs and people get slaughtered due to sectarian differences. Nobody will come to the rescue if minorities are attacked. Here in lahore, most of the educated people i meet everyday, believe that Shahbaz Bhatti and Salman Taseer were rightly killed, and that minorities are enjoying sufficient rights! Infact, mostly people use the word Kaffirs for non-muslims, those who are eternal enemies of islam and who are destined to go to hell! If thats how our educated middle class thinks, then one may conclude that incidents of extreme voilence against minorities will surely rise in the near future.Recommend
That’s a very legitimmate demand (Hindu Marriage Act).
A separate marriage act for Hindus is even better
for two nations theory (ideology).
We should at once accept this demand!!!Recommend
@Raqib Ali
“…A separate marriage act for Hindus is even better for two nations theory (ideology).”
In India, Muslim have their own personal law and we never believed in two nations theory!!!Recommend
pakistan is an islamic nation and we better tell them to move to india or other country!!
we dont want to be blamed for any crimes which happen against them due to amount of intolerance in our middle class!!
We should legally deport all hindus to which ever country takes them,christians could easily get some asylum in western countryRecommend
People from minority community should stop complaining now. Enough is enough. Why are they still living in Islamic republic of pakistan?Recommend
Jinnah.s Pakistan never had room for Hindus let alone for other minority faiths. Had it been there, Pakistan would have never happened to start with.
Having said that, Jinnah was gone for 60 years. What did Pakistan people do until now?
Minority rights are always determined by majority, and it is incumbent upon the majority as a sacred obligation to protect the rights of minorities-ethnic, religious, or linguistic. Nations prospered once they realized this code of conduct.
Did Pakistan live up to that code? Sadly, the answer is no, and that is root of all the problems of Pakistan. It was the very fear Jinnah had in mind for the muslims with ” Hindu” India and Pakistan people made his fear a reality for others.
Union of man and woman is the basic, primordial, and natural right of humans, and when PAK interferes on this principle right, it cease to be a nation.
Correct this NOW.
Right to wear Burqa is the least of the problems.
Shame on Pakistan muslim women who tolerate this injustice.Recommend
this ain’t jinnah’s pakistan,this is zardari’s pakistan where hindu girls are kidnapped,raped & then forced to convert to islam in interior sindh.
one would have thought that getting converts to a religion would happen by impressing people with your good deeds but no, becoming muslim through rape is the new way of increasing the numbers of the believers while the infidels’ numbers are reduced.Recommend
Well,atleast the Hindus have political representatives but the athiests,agostics,ex-muslims have no voice or rights in pakistan.The mualvis instruct the hordes of jihadi terrorists to cut off the head of any one who leaves the fold of islam.
how can you force through the threat of death to keep people in your religion? if someone born a muslim chooses to become an athiest later on his life,that’s his right,you can’t take that away by threats of beheadings.Recommend
sad commentry. Hinduism was born in Pakistan 3,000 years back.Recommend
This is pretty messed, we Muslims, when we are living abroad as a minority, we leave no stone unturned to try and demand our equal rights, demanding and complaining about a lot of things from our respective host countries, yet at the same time, we fail to provide for our minorities. How unfortunate.Recommend
why doesn’t CNN or BBC cover these problems?? why must the non-muslims of pakistan suffer in painful silence?? we scream,take out massive rallies & don’t waste a second to scream ” islamophobia” to put the non-muslims on the backfoot but then keep on making life hell for the non-muslims in our own land.
lakhs of hindus,christians,parsis & Ahmadis have been forced to flee pakistan but no one covers their stories,no one takes their interviews of what religious persecution they have had to face in paksitan.
why isn’t this article shared more on facebook,twitter,email etc.?????????Recommend
@shahid imtiaz:
yes,this practice of making girls muslims through rape has been going on unchecked in interior sindh for many decades now.No media house dare cover it or it knows that it will meet the fate of shaheed salman taseer & shahbaz bhatti.Recommend
This Govt. is good for nothing. Literally.Recommend
This is sad all minorities should have equal rights after all they all belongs to Pakistani soil.Recommend
A sickening and misleading title. This is not Jinnah’s Pakistan, not even in his worst dreams.
This is the Military/Bhutto/Nawaz PakistanRecommend
Piece of CrapRecommend
Dear writer,
the title is completely misleading, what do you mean by jinnah’s pakistan has no room for Hindus? What Quaid-e-Azam’s fault. Quaid gave equal rights to minority, and he himself said that the constitution must be completely based on Islam. Islam gives all basic rights to minorities, if the constitution is not implemented , do we start blaming Jinnah? Do you think that putting the blame of government negligence on jinnah is justified? If Zardari is not performing well, would you put the blame on ZA bhutto?
I would advise you to stop using misleading titles in future!Recommend
There isn’t any advantage of being legally registered as married in pakistan anyway…for example for tax purposes, etc.
Anyway, i think it should be an option regardless of everything. A religious document of marriage might not mean anything to somebody of another religion, whereas an official government document would.Recommend
I feel that the title is just apt … because it brings the reader to the right conclustion.. a very good articleRecommend
Who in the world knew the land where magnificent eternal Hindu civilization born,and follower of this ancient religion have to face such a hardship and the day will come when not a single follower would exist.Recommend
if ever there was a title so misleading – this is itRecommend
@sana:
Great idea Sana…and in the same breath, take the 20 crore Muslims from India too…Recommend
Fellow Muslims in India should see how their Pakistani muslim brothers treat Hindus. Still we have Indian muslims crying every day inspite of the best freedom enjoyed everywhere.
this article is an eye opener.Recommend
This leads to grey area in Jinnah’s Character. Should he be called a visionary? Should a man of his stature be oblivious of consequences of his actions? Why did he, a man not even knowing Kalema used religion for political gains? Was he so stupid to reckon that he could not neither send every hindu across the border or import muslim into his country?
Whenever one reads partition, one arrives at the same conclusion that post WWII, the Raj could not hold to India and the danger of advancing Communists was haunting them. Hence they created Pakistan to use it against the Reds. United India they could not have exploited. Jinnah was neither a leader nor visionary but an implant. Read his Aug11, speech the much heralded policy making guideline, there is nothing of leadership in it. One speech cannot annul his 15 years of preaching division on religion.Recommend
They r welcome in india along with shia and ahmadi . .minority future in pakistan is bleakRecommend
@sana:
pakistan is an islamic nation and we better tell them to move to india or other country!!
We should legally deport all hindus to which ever country takes them,christians could easily get some asylum in western country
Such a great idea, take few crores of your muslim brethren from india in exchange we will be totally greatfull because our life will be far better !!!!!!!!!!!!
Why not start from exchange of few crore muslim kashmiris in exchange of pakistani hindus…Recommend
@Ron(Indian):
minorities cant move to india or some other countries because they dnt have enough resources to move.. you cant blame minorities , there were areas in pakistan region where our grand father didnt feel any lawlessness at time of partition , even they dnt knw which regions were included in pakistan and which were part of india,
personally i think that there shoud be treaty between both countries so that minorities of both sides must be a given a final chance to change their country, both borders should be opened , army must provide safety to refugees ,
i have lot to say .. but this nort the right place to say more :(Recommend
It’s great Azam, the surge of intolerance in our society towards communities having beliefs, whether religious, social or cultural, other than us really disappoints me, but the irrelevance of govt is totally disheartening. Keep raising voice, at least!Recommend
@Ravi:
i agree with you..Recommend
@Ducky:
How can it be mullah’s Pakistan?? I don’t remember them being in power ever and never seen any mulla even in bureaucracy. On the other hand, in my opinion we have been ruined by our so called secular leadership.
May be u r talking about “some” Islamic laws we have in our constitution or the name “Islamic Republic of Pakistan”, if u r, then you should know that these laws & name are there because of the people of Pakistan. Don’t believe me? Then go ahead and try to amend any of these laws.
Yes, on issues people stand with mullahs because (accept it or not) majority of people of Pakistan are religious. Luckily they don’t vote for mullas in the elections because of their affiliations & some unknown reason but they also don’t want to be known as secular or modest/moderate, instead they are proud to called Muslims. Beauty of democracy is that people get what they want, so we should respect it.
It is a fact that people who support secular ideology are very few.Recommend
Good job Azam,
I love how blogs like this bring out all the bigots..telling people to leave their own country, a land where their ancestors have been from time immemorial (newsflash: you live in a country that is historically named Hindustan) and claiming to be Muslim in the same breath?
I have a better suggestion. Keeping in mind that many Muslims in South Asia trace their ancestry to people who invaded this part of the world, instead of asking the Hindus and Christians to leave, why don’t all these people move to the “pure” Islamic state of Saudi Arabia? Or to the Taliban controlled parts of Afghanistan? Enjoy Wahabbi style women’s rights and denial of nationality, Muslim or not.Recommend
very well written.. What do you accept from bunch of culprits who are ruling us since the beginning.. They don’t have time to do anything for majority and they don’t have guts to stand for the minority.Recommend
@Ron(Indian):
Hello Indian,
Do any Indian law allow accepting Pakistani Hindus in their nation? It is even more difficult to get Indian visit visa than American visa. Indian consulate in Pakistan is highly insulting to hindus of Pakistan. And many Pakistani Hindus who migrated to India failed get Indian passport even after 10 years of living there. Indian hindus (especially congress party) is so afraid of Indian Muslims that they fill their dhoti with shit if someone voices for Pakistani Hindus in their parliament. I think Pakistani mullah’s are 100 times better than Indian.
So, you Indian hindus, first get some legislation passed for easy visa and settlement of Hindus in your country and then as Pakistani Hindus to leave Pakistan.Recommend
completely misleading title…. What Jinnah’s fault in it… corruption and violation of laws is everywhere ……. its the fault of the government who is not doing anything…..!Recommend
Our great leader messed up our lives.There should have been complete transfer of minority population at any cost.Such a pity we cant do anything for Hindus of Pakistan.At least for Humanity sake govt of both side should allow minority to move their choice of country.Recommend
Victim and others: The time for migration of Hindus and Muslims from/to pakistan and India are over long long ago. The decision was taken by your elders/ancestors and you are enjoying it or paying for it. I am from deep down south and we have lots of Sindhis from karachi and larkhana etc and settled in S India for a long time. They all are thanking god for their luck. We can only feel sorry for Pakistani Hindus. Will be difficult to take them now.Recommend
@ Ravi
You always come with hatred against Muslims.
I don’t agree with your point of view but lets say that we will give you 3% of our land (for 3% minorities). Will you give us your land (proportionate to Crores of Muslims)?????
Also, give Kashmir area with Kashmiri Muslims.
After all, they have to live somewhere!!!Recommend
@ sana, Ravi, Walter Gonslaves, minority of Pakistan and others
We would not be even discussing this subject but for one of the many ideological foolishnesses of Nehru. In this case, his Muslim appeasement made him put his foot down when exchange of populations was discussed at the time of separation. Of course, his party has since reaped gold from that policy without benefiting Muslims in any way. They have always been aloof and strangers in their own country. Incidentally, even Pakistan closed its window on any Muslim immigration soon after Partition unlike Israel which is open for any Jewish migration, being the state established for Jews as Pakistan was for Muslims.Recommend
Agreed. But i believe we can increase that space for ourselves (muslims), hindus and all religious and sexual minorities in Pakistan. Need is to act: NonviolentlyRecommend
@ G. Din
@ Rohit
@Ravi
Jews are small in number and Isreal is only one Jewish state.
Pakistan is not for ALL the Muslims. It is for those who wanted to come from India. Borders were opened for nearly 5 years but even my hair dresser in Pakistan came in 1972 with his mother as a child when his father died.
I am in favour of equal rights to all minorities. But if someone wants to make them move (or ‘choice’ as Rohit puts it), we need to negotiate territory as well. We should be willing to give up 3% of our territory too.
I know many will get upset, but let me ask you:
Who is more important for you:
People or Land????Recommend
@Raqib Ali:
Who is more important for you:
People or Land????
Both
Because pakistani hindus are our people and what you call today pakistan is also our land simple.
Why dont you vacate my land and go to arabia, turkey , iran, afghanistan from where your fathers came as told by your history text book.Recommend
Thank you Very Much all friends………….espacaily Azem Khan and Kapil Dev for High Light this issue ….. we Stragling from last three years…………………Recommend
@ Ravi
Stop this illogical argument. We are a reality. In the same way, it is not your land, you’ll have to leave everything to the aboriginals (south Indians) and all North Indians will have to go to wherever they come from (who knows where!!!).
If my father, grandfather came within last 100 years or so (when the concept of visas etc was introduced), then I’ll gladly go back!
Stop hiding behind illogical arguments.
If you are relying on Pakistani history books,
then I claim over whole of India!!!Recommend
The suggestion of sending Indian Muslims to Pakistan is nauseating to say the least. Our country is India, it is not a Hindu Pakistan. There are millions of Indian Muslims who has contributed to the growth of India. I do not know how people can contemplate the migration of Aamir Khan or Yousuf Hamied to any other country. The major problem with the Indian Muslims is that they are under the influence of Maulavis. They lack modern education, especially those in north India.The Muslims of south India are successfully integrating into the mainstream. The north Indian, Urdu speaking Muslims should learn from the Christians and the Parsis and their southern counterparts. On the other hand, the governments of India and Pakistan should facilitate the migration of Pakistani Hindus and Sikhs to India. As the Pakistani society is increasingly becoming Wahabized, I do not think there is any hope for the minorities in that country. When the minority minister himself is murdered, no prizes for guessing the state of Pakistani society.Recommend
WRONG TITLE!!
Jinnah should not be blamed in this whatsoever
this is the fault of the Pakistani authorities that they haven’t made legal arrangements for hindu marriagesRecommend
Insan kisi Haal main khush nahi rehta A human can never be happy if he gets a valley full of gold he will cry for the 2nd one but to some extent we must care for our people. India must worry about their minorities. Khan sahib this is relatively easy subject which you have chosen. Frankly speaking I am tired of this subject Great Expectations!Recommend
@Victim:
I am not a hindu. I am a christian. But my forefathers were Hindus. What I said is for entire pakistani minorty and not just for pakistani hindus. Minorities in India are better placed. Remember India has the biggest minority population on planet earth. Always think about future generations. No hopes from pakistani government so pakistani Minority affairs institutes should talk to Indian government to find out the solution. I can assure that Indian minorities will support you in this regard. thanks.Recommend
This subject does not get the attention of our parliament simply because there is no money in it.
Morals, religious teachings, the visions of our founding fathers, the humane need to do the right thing, do not and never really did matter and this will only get worse.Recommend
How ironic! You Pakistanis debate Burqua Ban in France. Look at your own country first. How it treats its minorities!Recommend
@Cherish Raj:
I do not know how people can contemplate the migration of Aamir Khan or Yousuf Hamied to any other country.
Both of them would not have been able to make such a huge mark of their own if they would have migrated to pakistan or any other muslim dominated country………Recommend
“‘Jinnah’s Pakistan’ has no room for Hindus ”
–> Because it is truly Jinnah’s Pakistan.
Jinnah was the one who advocated the divisive 2 nation theory, a truly divisive and intolerant theory. And, Pakistan has become just that. What is there to be surprised?
Pakistan is the greatest mistake of Jinnah’s life. Those who talk about his speeches he made AFTER the partition, let me remind you actions speak louder than words. Once the virus of intolerance takes hold it consumes the body. That exactly is what has happened to Pakistan. It has just followed the path of Jinnah.Recommend
messed upRecommend
Why we forget that we once were minorities in greater India as well?Recommend
My previous attempt to post comment did not get through (The moderators did not like the truth?)…Anyway, I pointed out that formation of pakistan is based on an exclusive idea, namely two nation theory (Hindus and muslims are different ppl and cant live together etc)…how then can non mulisms in pakistan live without fear?Recommend
@muhammad sadiq:
Well said.
We are living in an intolerant society guided by delusional believes indoctrinated from childhood. No one can announce apostasy without risking his/her life to say the least. There is no freedom of choice once you are born in a Muslim familyRecommend
First they came for the communists,
and I didn’t speak out because I wasn’t a communist.
Then they came for the trade unionists,
and I didn’t speak out because I wasn’t a trade unionist.
Then they came for the Jews,
and I didn’t speak out because I wasn’t a Jew.
Then they came for me
and there was no one left to speak out for me.
-Pastor Martin Niemoller
If the moderates of Pakistan donot speak for the minorities, nobody will be left to speak for you when the fanatics come for you.Recommend
The title is highly misleading,jinnaj’s pakistan would be the replica of Muslim Spain, had he remained with us for a longer period
Iam coming to know about this issue for the first time , never seen an article or a letter about the problem in newspapers even
was hindu minority scared to write a letter even.Recommend
@Gautam Arya:
plz tell me with the depth of your conscience if the practicing muslims in India are living in India without fears
(And plz dont give me the reference of all filmi heros, who are more Hindus than muslims in their practices)Recommend
@anoop:
iwould like to remind you something,
golden temple
muslim kashmir
christain genocide in orissa 2008
dalits
they speak volumes of hindu tolerence towards their minoritiesRecommend
All communities are welcomed in India.Join with us to make the country better and a safe place.Recommend
@seeker:
you forgot to include Sati system and the human sacrifice to Kali temples !!Recommend
@sana:
shame on you,minorities are very important for Pakistan,they contributed allot dear in the progress of Pakistan.government should need to fulfill there all legal demands because Quaid said every citizen of this country will feel free to do every thing according to their religion.Recommend
@sana:
India has about as much Muslims as in Porkistan, and you can take them any time you like!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!. Cheers!Recommend
@seeker to Gautam Arya
“plz tell me with the depth of your conscience if the practicing muslims in India are living in India without fears”
Gautam, from his name, is an Hindu. You should be asking this question of an Indian Muslim. Now go two posts down in this very blog, the one put up by M. Asad which says “All communities are welcomed in India.Join with us to make the country better and a safe place.” From the post, it looks that M. Asad is an Indian Muslim and is offering this invitation confidently on behalf of India. What do you think? Does he look like he is living in India WITH any fear?Recommend
@seeker,
In a population of 1 Billion, there are mere aberrations.
The real India is the India which voices its concern through Elections. A Sikh is the PM of India and I say this proudly in a Country which is 80% Hindu. Sikhs form about 5% of the total population.
What you talk about are the marginal elements. Just to compare tolerance levels lets look at last year. Not a single Incident occurred in India which compares to the number of Bomb Blasts in Pakistan, which must have killed thousands(3000+ were killed in 2009, probably more in 2010). Why? Since India is intolerant and has 7 times more population, shouldn’t be the number of incidents 7 times higher?
Only Indians can have enough tolerance to vote for a guy who is not from the same Religion. In Pakistan that is unthinkable. Even in the oldest of Democracies like in the USA, which is considered to be a plural society. Shows how advanced Indian Civilization is.Recommend
@seeker:
You are right, muslims in India (especially in northern states) do feel uncomfortable. But on the whole minorities in India are much more comfortable than the minorities living in Pakistan. India and pakistan are both works in progress. I just pointed out that India is based on inclusive philosophy (poorly implemented at times) and pakistan is based on exclusive ideology (poorly implemented at times as well :)). The intolerant fringe in India is a result of poor implementation of an inclusive philosophy. And the tolerant fringe in Pakistan is result of poor implementation of an exclusive ideology.
Life exists in shades my friend. Just because a few muslims feel uncomfortable in India you cannot claim that it is same as pakistan (and hence refuse to take responsibility). This is like a murderer claiming equality with a pickpocket (both are criminals but the degree is vastly different).Recommend
@Saurav:
What are you talking about? Pakistani Muslims mistreating their minorities is no reason why Indian Muslims should feel grateful towards Indian Hindus. What is happening to minorities in Pakistan is sad and should be condemned, but we should strive as the majority to bring our minorities to the mainstream.Recommend
@ Ravi
shame on you and people who think like you…..we are not a Hindu country…..We are a secular countryRecommend
@sana:
You seem to have lost it. The intolerance is not in our middle class its everywhere. Over my dead body is anybody sending them anywhere.Recommend
@minority of Pakistan to Ron
There have been cases of groups of Hindus coming over and staying on with full knowledge and connivance of authorities. So, the future is not quite bleak though it may take a while to sort itself out. Both Hindus and Christians are self-reliant people. So, keep trying!Recommend
I think there should be a proper system for registration of Hindu marriages in Pakistan, as per their belief. Islam is the gurantior of the basic rights of minorities.Recommend
By reading the Pakistani newspapers about what is happening in Pakistan, one would come to the conclusion that Islam is not the guarantor of anything for anyone being a majority muslim or non majority non muslims. Everyone’s life is at stake either for muslim Vs non muslim or for sectarian reasons.Recommend
Pakistan, Pakistan, Pakistan…….
Tell me anyone why Pakistan has importance in all over the world???
Muhammad Ali Jinnah Got Pakistan with his Greatest Passion. There was a lot of forces were creating barrier for Mr Jinnah they did not accept the name of Pakistan. Muhammad Ali Jinnah who was the master mind! He was struggling for his Muslim nation. By God grace He succeeded! My all brothers who has written their comments. They need to think about this just once time Why Muhammad Ali Jinnah wanted separate country?
He could not bear PAIN of the Muslims. He was sincere with this therefore He was succeeded.
My brothers and sisters only write here comments and forget it why? I ask to all of them???
They need sincere leadership, they need for master mind. I know everyone is not Mr Jinnah.
Why because we are not sincere with our comments.
But who talk only about marriage rights, They don’t look circumstances in the Jammu Kashmir who many Muslims kills by Indian Armies, but why???
I write here just Indian Government is doing injustice with Muslim Kashmires and that’s it.
It can change them problems? Never ever!
We need to change our self first. Mr Jinnah told us, we can do everything with (Faith – Unity – Believe – Origination)
I hope for best and i shall be thank full to all of them if,
They don’t talk nonsense about “Mr Jinnah”. You need to make noise for present leaders Muhammad Ali Jinnah can’t do something for You at this time. You have to do by Yourself.Recommend
yasir khan-Haripur..
Dear all, i will not say too much, but will only say that just have look in the history of Holy Prophet age, was there any discrimination in that time??? if there was then u can do it? if we are doing such for our minority then what will happened if our neighbour country will do this with more then 16 CARORE muslims? where they will move? to pakistan? is there any system through which u can handle them like ANSAAR did with MOHAJREEN in Madina????
Decision is in your hand now..!!!!
thanks for reading this….
Jazak Allah Khair.Recommend
@ yasir khan ; sane comments i hear from a pakistani for once. At least one person from pakistan feels Muslims are not treated badly here, which is the truth. They are as happy/sad as rest of indians. We are a secular state. Jinnah wanted pakistan to be one. Hope you guys will respect his vision.Recommend