Dear Disney, casting Naomi Scott as Jasmine just because she’s brown highlights the Orientalist tendency of conflating all brown cultures

Published: August 1, 2017

The real issue is that Disney was looking for Middle Eastern actors for what they explicitly said was a Middle Eastern role.

Disney recently announced their selections for the cast of the new live-action remake of the 1992 animated movie, Aladdin. The announcement, however, was met with widespread outrage. British actress Naomi Scott of Indian heritage was selected to play Jasmine, and people were furious at Disney’s failure to give the opportunity to someone who is actually Arab.

Prior to this announcement, Disney had disclosed that they had been having difficulty selecting Middle Eastern actors for the part.

“It can’t be easy to cast a Middle Eastern actor as a terrorist but difficult to cast the same people in a leading role,” the journalist Rawan Eewshah wrote for Allure on Friday.

With so many Middle Eastern actors and actresses readily available in Hollywood today, why did Disney make the choice that they did?

It turns out that their cast selection for this movie is only the tip of the iceberg when it comes to their inherent and long-standing racism problem.

The 1992 Aladdin was fashioned loosely after a Syrian tale, and the name of the town, Agrabah, is a mixture of the names of Agra and Baghdad – Agra being in India and Baghdad being in Iraq – and the palace in the movie is clearly fashioned after the Taj Mahal. Marketed as a Middle Eastern setting, this was pretty confusing to people who took the time to think about it. It seemed as though the creators of the movie – a group of six white men who wrote, scored, produced and directed it – simply took a variety of the “Middle Eastern” cultures that they had knowledge of (although India is not in the Middle East) and created a big boiling pot mess of them, presented in the guise of a children’s cartoon, in which even the characters are voiced by white people.

In a way, this live-action remake was Disney’s opportunity to correct the mistakes they had made in the past. Since the release of Aladdin, other Disney movies such as Mulan and Moana have been thought out properly, and have used Chinese and Pacific-Islander voice actors respectively.

Unfortunately, casting Naomi Scott as a Middle Eastern woman just because she is brown highlights the Orientalist tendency to conflate all brown cultures and make them seem interchangeable. In a time and place where Middle Eastern people (and most brown people, for that matter) urgently require accurate representation, it is especially ignorant to assume that any actress with brown skin will do.

Disney’s ignorance can easily be traced back to Hollywood and the general western film industry’s history of subtle and not-so-subtle racism. From using blackface in their first cinematic triumph in 1915, The Birth of a Nationto casting Emma Stone to play a half-Hawaiian and half-Chinese character a hundred years later in AlohaPerhaps Disney finds itself having to make these choices because their white actors (or half-white, like Scott) are better known and sell out more cinemas. Or perhaps it’s because the general western mind-set tends to confuse all brown people for one another anyways, so they thought it wouldn’t be a big deal.

Initially, when Disney announced that they were casting roles for Aladdin, the internet saw people suggesting the likes of Riz Ahmed and Dev Patel for the main role, one of whom is Pakistani-British and the other Indian-British.

The issue here isn’t just that the character is Middle Eastern and the actress is not. In many people’s minds, it shouldn’t matter as long as she looks the part, because after all, an actor’s job is to pretend to be someone they aren’t. Maybe it’s the equivalent of casting a Canadian or British actor to play an American. The real issue is that Disney was looking for Middle Eastern actors for what they explicitly said was a Middle Eastern role, and then they cast a woman who is half British and half Indian, even though they had hundreds of other choices.

There is already so much underrepresentation and misrepresentation of people from the Middle East and South Asia, and it has already caused religious and cultural misunderstandings and violent hatred. What we need more than anything is a platform on which to represent ourselves. White people, however, do not need to go to such lengths to prove themselves and their worth, and they definitely do not need to be taking important opportunities such as this one away from people who really could have benefitted from them. Had they actually cast an obscure Middle Eastern actress for this high-budget Hollywood film, perhaps the fame and recognition she would receive would propel her to a position from which she could speak for and represent other people with a heritage like hers.

Scott, however, will not be able to do that. Either Disney doesn’t understand this, or they just fail to give it importance,  or maybe they really are thinking what Khaled Beydoun claims is their mind-set in his article for Al Jazeera,

“Would a non-Orientalist Aladdin be a success in a country where 41% of the electorate voted for the current president and would vote in favour of bombing the fictional land of Agrabah?”

 

Miraal Habib

Miraal Habib

The writer is a film major at Bard College in New York.

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Saad Salman Zia

    Cultural appropriation in fiction tales? It’s creative license. They are free to create whatever they want to,Recommend

  • abhi

    this is too much now.Recommend

  • Parvez

    Classic example of a …… non-issue.Recommend

  • Katherina Phillips

    Actually Aladdin is based off of the stories from Arabian nights (known as takes of 1001 nights), a mixture of stories..and was set in both Asia and Middle Eastern ….and you want to go P.C, I’m the story of Aladdin he was NOT Arabian or brown skin, he was not a orphan or poor, he was Chinese, he was rich and had both living parents…..our fame villain Jafar? he was never in the Aladdin story and was a good guy. so yeah before you open your mouth, pick up the book.Recommend

  • Saud Umar Khan

    from a recent example, if jake gyllenhaal can be prince of persia then why cant any other white man (poorly suntaned) be #aladdin.Recommend

  • Pam Connell

    I have a very old copy of the Arabian Nights. The original unnamed princess was Chinese. This is a live action remake of a Disney cartoon. Suck it up.Recommend