he story is also a reminder to those who, in the rush of life, have forgotten its meaning. PHOTO: shahidksiddiqui.blogspot.com

‘Aadhay Adhooray Khawab’: Exploring the death of creativity through education

The novel turns out to be a critique on the degradation of creativity in our educational system.

Sonia I Farooq May 24, 2017
Shahid Siddiqui’s ‘Aadhay Adhooray Khawab is like a tangible dream you can hold in your hands. You are a part of a chain and a constellation of dreams, only if you believe in the beauty of the imagination.

This novel is a dazzling critique of educational practices in Pakistan. It distinguishes itself from other contemporary Urdu fiction through its content, diction, and style.

The story follows the journey of a devoted teacher, Saharan Rai, who is selfless and gallant, and uses his heart and soul to fulfil his dreams. This is where it gets interesting. Rai’s dreams are universal and he illustrates the same desire that many in our culture do in understanding the potential of our youth and taking a stand against injustices in society.

The story is an inspiration for young teachers; inspiration to bring about change, not only in society, but also in themselves through a creative approach. Rai realises his responsibility as a teacher, friend, guide and reformer, yet he can see the darkness inherent in this life and world.

The novel proves to be an attack on the dehumanising aspects of education. The mechanisation of education is criticised and Rai’s struggle stirs up the intellectuals, academics, and other social reformers to move towards educational and social change.

Since the need for pedagogical strategies for the development of creativity and critical consciousness are important themes of the story, the novel is specific in pointing out the “perfect dead skeleton” that is the real emblem of our society. Arousing the dead skeleton and bringing it to its true perfection is the aim of the novel. Therefore, the novel turns out to be a critique on the degradation of creativity in our educational system, and it alerts the reader to the commodification and appalling conditions of our educational institutions.

The author has skilfully given examples of teaching by explaining the art of pottery; creative thinking will bring a change in our existing teaching methods by coaching the class through innovation, keeping in mind our cultural and socio-economic constraints.

This story of a much-loved teacher is devotedly narrated by his student Tassavur, and by Imtisaal Agha, who knew of Rai from others before she met him. The story also focuses on the beautiful bond between teachers and students which our current society fails to develop. Yet, the professor thinks:
“Yeh rishtay bhi kese rishtay hen. Jahan humkhayali, mohabbat, aqeedat aur dosti ki bunyaad banti hai aur manzilon ka ishtaraak humein rafaqat ki lari mein piro deta hai”.

(These relationships….what can one say about these relationships....that begin between the likeminded, elevate to love and then to a profound fondness and becomes the basis for friendship. Then, being headed towards the same destination, joins us into the bond of a relationship).

Within the story, we find the character of Agha reading Emily Bronte’s Wuthering Heights’ and the character of Heathcliff intrigues her. Rai, a man loved by so many, would become Heathcliff to her Catherine and this parallel makes the novel a beautiful composition of light and pure romance.

The saga of the emotional attachment of the main characters, Rai and Agha has been woven delicately through snippets of incidents over a relatively short time. The Celestine Prophecy,’ which is what has brought the two characters together, is marvellously presented in the story; unlike most contemporary works of literature where artificiality, glamour, and extravagance are highlighted.

The imagery of darkness and Agha’s footsteps are emblematic and meaningful, for she is the one who is meant to break the darkness and silence all around through her self-confidence. She understands that the unjust social stratification and the deep relationship between ideology and education can change the hearts and minds of those who are oblivious and disenchanted with life. In one of her discussions with Rai she says:
“Mujhe bhi taleem ke critical pehlu se dilchaspi hai. Aik aesi taleem jo neutral aur passive na ho balkay muashray ke dil mein dharak rahi ho.”

(I am also interested in the critical aspect of education. The kind of education that is neutral and not passive, but beats inside the heart of the society)

Rai answers,
“Taleem aur ideology ka aapas mein gehra taluq hai. Taleem ek qaum ko sula bhi sakti hai aur bedaar bhi ker skti hai. Ye muashray ki samaaji aur muashi tafreeq ko berha bhi sakti hai aur kum kernay mein mua’ven bhi saabit ho sakti hai”.

(Education and ideology have a very deep connection with each other. Education can either make the public sleep or wake them up. It can also help increase the social and economic differences of the society or even decrease it).

Thus, the novel raises issues for all those educationalists and members of the younger generation.

The fast pace of the story contrasts with the calm mood of the main characters. Rai’s calm and pleasant tone is beautifully present throughout the novel, yet the contrast in tone and pace is striking and echoes of Emily Dickinson’s Because I could not stop for Death as the protagonist has promises to keep before he sleeps. The colours and ideas of Rai’s dreams are skilfully woven into the fabric of the story. The story is also a reminder to those who, in the rush of life, have forgotten its meaning. This also brings to mind ‘Leisure’ by William Henry Davies who reflects this quandary as:
“No time to see, in broad daylight,

Streams full of stars like skies at night.

No time to turn at Beauty’s glance,

And watch her feet, how they can dance.

A poor life this if, full of care,

We have no time to stand and stare”.

Colour and passion have been blended beautifully in this small piece of art, with the help of imagery from nature. The writer uses the ingredients of nature, from rain to wind, to parallel the human soul and thus creates a skillful picture for the readers,
“Barishon ki awaz ki apni mosiqee hai jo apnay zor se ghat’ti berhti dil ke taaron ko chairty hai”.

(The sound of rain has a melody of its own, which touches the strings of the heart with its highs and lows).

This integration helps the readers develop self-confidence as the story progresses,

“Khawahish apna raasta khud taraashti hai,

Manzil apni raah ko khud janam deti hai,

Aur tabeer apna khawab khud chunti hai”.

(Desire tends to find its own way,

Destination tends to make its own path

And denouement tends to select its own dream).

Similarly, the dialogues are equally engaging,

“Aasmaan se barf narm, be awaaz gaalon ki surat zameen me jazb ho rahi thi.

Mohabbat ke subuk jazbay ki tarhan jo khawhishon, khawabon aur nazarion ke jalo mein hamaray rag o pae me utar jata hai

aur jab tak humein uski maujudgi ka ehsaas hota hai

woh hamaray jism o jaan mein dur tak phail chuka hota hai

phir bahr ki ruton ka kesa he ulat phair ho

andar ka mausam amr ho jata hai”.

(The soft snowfall from the heavens was silently being absorbed in the soil…similar to the tender feeling of love which, accompanied by hopes, dreams and ambitions, is absorbed into every bit of ourselves.
…And, before we realise its presence, it has made its way so far and beyond into our body and soul.
Then, whatever the furor/storm of the spring nights be…the weather on the inside becomes immortal/eternal).

As a reader of modern and critical studies, I am pleased to find the novel standing on its own merits. The novel is highly recommended for those who regret the shallowness in art and long for the betterment of themselves and society. Therefore, this story is not intended to satisfy the appetite of readers who prefer commercialised texts of mass entertainment because one of the most important features of the novel is unlike other contemporary Pakistani fiction. ‘Aadhay Adhooray Khawab’ does not promote the commodification of life and the consumption of brands, and doesn’t use labels to define one’s social identity.

The reader might initially struggle with the social and political concepts, but they are discussed so naturally that the reader’s interest is peaked soon after he or she begins the novel.

The character of Rai is developed strongly through the memories of his students and the readers will learn a lot from him as the novel progresses. The language is simple and contemporary, giving the story a lively feel. The ending is satisfactory for readers as the author concludes the book with Rai sharing his dreams with Agha, who hopes to take them on.

Thus, the author has maintained an element of hope by sharing his ideas with all the Aghas of our generation. Hopefully, they will play their roles in the story by reading the novel and fulfilling these dreams.
WRITTEN BY:
Sonia I Farooq The author is a Lecturer in the department of English, female campus, at the International Islamic University, Islamabad. She is also working as a coordinator of the Critical Thinking Forum at the university. Currently she is pursuing PhD from Royal Holloway University London, UK.
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.

COMMENTS (2)

TQ | 6 years ago | Reply Excellent review.
Nowsherwan Adil Niazi | 6 years ago | Reply wow. fantastic article
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ