Can learning Arabic really prevent terrorist attacks? PML-N surely thinks so

Published: February 17, 2017

A bill introduced by PML-N MNA, Naeema Kishwar Khan, resulted in discussions about whether lack of Arabic teaching has caused increase in terrorism cases. PHOTO: REUTERS

I suppose it is reasonable to assume that the men and women in our National Assembly are mentally fit – people who think and act rationally. We elect them every five years, hoping that they will solve our problems and make us proud of being citizens of Pakistan. But then, one of them says something completely absurd which makes me want to bang my head against the nearest wall and regret not going abroad after I graduated (those were the days when it was very easy to get a US visa).

I am referring to a female member of the National Assembly who claimed that the increase in terrorism is directly related to our children learning English and not Arabic in schools.

A bill moved by the Pakistan Muslim League-Nawaz (PML-N) MNA, Naeema Kishwar Khan, resulted in discussions about whether the lack of Arabic teaching has caused an increase in terrorism cases. To further substantiate this notion, another PML-N MNA, Parveen Masood Bhatti, supported the bill, stating that terrorism was increasing because students were not studying Arabic. According to her,

“We have started focusing on the English language, and parents put their children in English-medium schools and do not bother teaching their children the Arabic language. It is because of this attitude that terrorism is increasing.”

I do not know whether the ladies think that not learning Arabic has caused a rise in terrorism cases or if learning English is responsible for it. I do think that our children need to learn to read, interpret and speak Arabic as it will prevent them from being brainwashed by virtually illiterate clerics and their interpretations, but it cannot be done for the simple reason that we don’t have enough teachers fluent in Arabic in the country, and the ones we could employ from abroad are most likely not fluent in Urdu. In fact, they would probably be able to teach only in English, which means that our children would first have to learn English before learning Arabic.

Furthermore, it is not as simple as it seems. If speaking Arabic really prevents terrorism, how do you explain the fact that 15 of the 19 terrorists who carried out the 9/11 attacks were Arabs and spoke Arabic fluently, not to mention that the al Qaeda founder, Osama Bin Laden was an Arab and spoke Arabic fluently as well. Moreover, there are only a few to zero terrorism cases in countries like Canada, Australia and New Zealand, where no one speaks Arabic and English is the preferred language by most people. Hence, speaking or teaching English does not cause terrorism. In fact, English has been the preferred medium of language in Pakistan since before its inception, and there was no terrorism until the 1990s.

As for Arabic, all madrassa students have to learn it, and some of the arrested terrorists reportedly belonged to such madrassas – madrassas where they would learn and understand Arabic, interpreted by clerics and their understanding of the Holy Quran.

Hence, it is safe to conclude that speaking and learning Arabic, as taught in many madrassas, is where the problem arises. Since they lack translation and interpretation skills, the students believe whatever they are being taught and are brainwashed to believe that they are serving a higher purpose.

Did it ever occur to the ladies to do some research and find out which is the preferred and common language for suicide bombers and terrorists? Is it English? Yes, they do understand and speak English, but have they ever heard any suicide bomber screaming “God is great” instead of “Allahu Akbar” before blowing themselves up?

So, think again, ladies, it is not language that causes men, women and children to indulge in terrorism, but the environment in which they have been raised. Furthermore, I have a suggestion for you, honourable ladies: why don’t you start learning and speaking in Arabic? You will soon find out if it can prevent you from terrorising those whom you come in contact with every day.

Shakir Lakhani

Shakir Lakhani

Engineer, former visiting lecturer at NED Engineering College, industrialist, associated with petroleum/chemical industries for many years. Loves writing, and (in the opinion of most of those who know him), mentally unbalanced. He tweets @shakirlakhani (twitter.com/shakirlakhani)

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Keyboard Soldier

    Irony is that the Arabs consider Pakistanis as “impure Muslims,” despite the fact that they call themselves from the Land of the Pure.

    An Arab and an non-Arab Muslim can never be equal. That is the major reason, why the Turks and the Persians have always been fighting the Arabs to gain control over Mecca.

    As for the South Asians, well, they have always been treated like slaves or blind followers.

    The rest of the world laughs, while Pakistanis kill each other on whose version of Arab-imported religion is better.Recommend

  • AmericanMuse

    Speak Arabic? Why that dying language?

    Chinese or English is the future!Recommend

  • Joking Justice

    Nonsense. Same nonsense as thinking metro bus changes life of country masses. Majority of so called Islamic state fighters (terrorists) destroying graves etc know not just basic Arabic language but is their mother language. Apart from nationalists or separatists, bigger faction of Jehadis all over the world are religious minded. They, at least their ring leaders know arabic well. In Bahrain last week about a dozen schools were vandalised, Arabic is the mother language of these people.Recommend

  • Rex Minor

    Amazingly 80 % of Pakistani Muslims think they are Arabs specially if he
    Hold Shah or Syed you cant offer him for a simple DNA test to prove his
    Arab Origin.

    Regardless of the names, all homo sapiens arriving from the middle east ( the cradle of civilisation) carry a varyfiable DNA matching that of an arab as well as the neandathaler.

    Rex MinorRecommend

  • Furrukh Rao

    The DNA of Arabs and Iranians doesn’t Match with Pakistani/Indian People nor its possible Arabia is very less Population and Indian Pakistani Arabs are populated like Rabbits.Recommend

  • Sane

    Learning Arabic would not help in curbing terrorism. Recommend

  • Sane

    ET: You wiped out the other sentence of my comment. How many terrorist nabbed so far were able to speak Arabic. Yes, they were fluent in Hindi, like Kulbhoshan Singh.Recommend