Why was this Christian boy beaten for drinking water from a mosque?

Published: December 2, 2016

News and images of Pakistani Christians being beaten up or being wrongly prosecuted are not surprising for the Pakistani public, especially since Pakistan ranks number six on the Open Doors World Watch List for Christian prosecution. Verily, one cannot turn a blind eye to such violence when it takes place so often.

With the growing intolerance rate in Pakistan, many members belonging to minority groups continue to pay the price for acts they don’t even know constitute as crimes. And, realistically, they aren’t.

A couple of days ago, a Christian boy was shown to be brutally beaten up in a video for allegedly drinking water from a fountain located inside a mosque. Are these the consequences of him accessing a public facility which provides the most basic utility for survival? Is being physically assaulted in public by self-proclaimed Muslim men who took it upon themselves to punish an innocent person for stepping into a Muslim place of worship and sharing their water justified?

The video shows the boy yelling and screaming from pain after being whipped with wooden sticks and being beaten with shoes.

Evidently, in the Christian context, the root causes of the anxieties of the community owe it to the actions of common Pakistanis. However, there are many other non-violent forms of discrimination Christians have to tolerate on a daily basis, such as poor or no access to education, lack of employment opportunities, and hurdles in social mobility. Many employers prefer Christians for sanitation jobs, and advertise for those jobs as open only to non-Muslims (read: Christians wanted). For instance, the derogatory term “churha” (sweepers) is commonly used to describe Christians.

In fact, it’s important to take into account the impacts of both class and religion in order to understand the discrimination the Christian community faces. Caste-based discrimination has existed in this part of the world for years, so to say that religious intolerance is the only factor contributing to their discrimination is very limiting.

These negative perceptions have created a dangerous situation for the peace and security of Pakistan’s Christian community. The suffering they face and how they are viewed by the mainstream Muslim population can be measured by the horrendous conditions with which they must compete on a daily basis. Forced marriage and conversion to Islam are some of the worst kinds of challenges they encounter.

The mistreatment of minorities is a stain on the wider Pakistani society. Even though terrorists are the most violent troublemakers, it is the public attitude that indicates minorities as targets for militants. Perhaps, Pakistan can be made a safer country by killing militants but ultimately this move will not really change the lives of those who have to live with dehumanising stereotypes every day. Until their fundamental rights are not widely recognised and granted, and such tensions are not resolved, Pakistan will continue to be at the frontline for violating, assaulting and prosecuting Christians.

This video shows one of the many violations that take place against the Christian community in Pakistan. However, other such countless incidents are not reported, filmed, nor made viral on social media platforms.

Therefore, as Pakistan persists to fight extremism, it needs to comprehend that military interventions are not enough.

In regards to the hoopla surrounding the authenticity of the said incident (video), the matter of fact is that the young boy was beaten up by a mob. Whether it was because he drank water from a mosque or stole a car battery, mob justice is not justice. Instead of questioning the reason behind his bruises, a little empathy towards our minorities could go a long way.

Purniya Awan

Purniya Awan

The writer is a Gender Studies graduate from York University, has been nominated as a Global Shaper of the World Economic Forum, is a former member of Youth Parliament Pakistan and is a founding member of Courting The Law. She is a women's rights activist and frequently writes on feminist and human rights issues. She tweets @purniyaA (twitter.com/PurniyaA?lang=en)

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Yogi Berra

    How come we never read these stories in Indian news papers? Why are Indian news papers and media suppressing these human rights violations for years? Is it not double standards?Recommend

  • Zubair Khan

    Mind set problem. Few decades back used to hear “Chouhrra Eisai” So from very outset if you are brought up in a society where degrading followers of other religions is common how things can improve. Unfortunately respect of humanity has fallen so low that no light is seen at the end of the tunnel. As long revolution does not take place in educational system current mind set will prevail.
    Religious clerics who are at fore front to lead such mind set, how they beg and bow their heads to Christians when they are in Western countries is worth seeing.Recommend

  • SRK

    Isolation? Not in Hunza, I am already here … but you are welcome to my abode.Recommend

  • Sane

    Purniya Awan: Please also about how many Muslims were beaten just because they look like Muslim in the country where you live now and how many Muslims were murdered in India just for being Muslim. Please write something about these as well to show you do not have a biased version.Recommend

  • Sane

    Why don’t you talk about hate crimes against Muslims in west and in India?Recommend

  • Sane

    That is called ‘journalism’ in today’s worldRecommend

  • Phil McDonald

    Youtube will block these videos.

    Here are a couple links that still remain online.

    https://youtu.be/D0g8m4xfAgE

    https://youtu.be/lz6PpPAACqc

    Recommend

  • midnighteye

    Because of the huge number of crimes against all non Muslims all over the world. One does not contemplate a single grain of sand when one is confronted by a desert.Recommend

  • Sane

    The boy was beaten for stealing a car battery not for drinking water. Se the video before you write. Also tell about beating and intimidating Muslims in USA, Europe and Canada.Recommend

  • Sarah Sajid

    Doesn’t really justify anything. Not the violence against Muslims nor the Non-Muslims. You cannot look at one side of the coin. Just as much as Non-Muslims are being victims of hate crime, Muslims are victims in majority of hate crimes too. Makes you think what is really going on. It is the human that acts on will, not the religion that is there for guidance, not brutality. We are messed up. As humans more than as Muslims or otherwise.Recommend

  • Eddied

    when last I checked that is not a misrepresentation of the facts…Recommend

  • liberal-lubna-fromLahore

    IT ISRecommend