Does a 5-year-old rape victim have a future to look forward to?

Rape is the responsibility of the perpetrator, not the victim. The 5-year-old girl's rape is a proof of this.

Maryam Saba October 12, 2013
She was just five-years-old. She still had many more years to go before she was meant to discover that the world is not a nice place and that heinous crimes are committed against innocent people. That life is unfair and some people have to bear more pain than others. That being a girl means what is between her legs would define her entire existence. It was too soon for her to know about all this.

On the evening of September 12, 2013, a five-year-old girl’s right to dream was taken away from her – an evening where her usual plans would have included going to her friend’s home to stitch clothes for her doll or to cook small rotis to be served in her tiny toy cutlery. However, that evening robbed her of her innocence.

It makes me sick to imagine what growing up in Pakistan will be like for her now.

The stigma, the trauma, the misery of an innocent victim; she has too big a burden awaiting her. While her parents, doctors and the people are praying for her to get well soon, I can’t help praying for her future.

I can’t help thinking about what this society would do to her. Would her life, ten years from now, allow her to be glad that she survived? That she got well soon? In a society obsessed with marriage and virginity, how will this little girl pave her way to a normal life, let alone a good one? These are the questions that haunt me and I am sure they haunt her mother too – who is begging the media to respect the child’s right to anonymity, every second now.

A society where the woman is held responsible for provoking the crime against her, how does that society make sense of paedophilia and of this heart-shaking incident?

A woman in a chaadar is no less likely to be raped than a woman without one. A woman who dresses in a modern* way, is NOT giving an invitation to be raped and this is what our society needs to learn. Because a five-year-old, who is not capable of inviting her rapist, was raped. Because we have seen how this disease develops when we ignore the criminal and blame the victim. We have this to deal with now.

A professor of mine once proclaimed in a class on Ethics that an idea is the most powerful tool there is. An idea can construct or destruct an entire people. It is nothing but an abstract idea which sets in motion an atrocious genocide and it is nothing but an idea which fuels an uprising. Ideas are viral and ideas are powerful. It’s time that we use an idea to protect our women and children against rape.

The idea that no woman asks to be raped needs to be instilled. That rape, like murder, is the responsibility of the perpetrator rather than the victim. That the society needs to punish the offender and not the offended, the stigma is to be attached with the rapist and not the victim.

Let’s think about this idea and talk about it, for the sake of this five-year-old. Let’s make growing up for her easier and less painful.

*The author has deliberately used this word in its largely misused context, whereby modern entails Western, a concept which is largely at odds with the true philosophical essence of modernity
WRITTEN BY:
Maryam Saba A graduate from the Lahore University of Management Sciences with a bachelors in Anthropology and Sociology. A novice researcher working in the development sector. She enjoys reading and writing and wishes to travel the world. She tweets @MaryamSaba_ (https://twitter.com/MaryamSaba_)
The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necassarily reflect the views and policies of the Express Tribune.

COMMENTS (7)

Open minded | 10 years ago | Reply "A woman in a chaadar is no less likely to be raped than a woman without one. A woman who dresses in a modern* way, is NOT giving an invitation to be raped and this is what our society needs to learn" I am shocked and amazed when i read this paragraph i am not a conservative person, a women has the right to dress the way she wants to but then she has to bear the consequences of that decision rather then to transfer the blame. A women in a chadar/ abaya is much more safe then a women in a jeans and top. This event does show no women is safe and we need to change the minds of the people but you cant use this event to justify how you dress
Human | 10 years ago I respect your stated opinions but to reason with you, I being a resident of Islamabad, Pakistan, a city where you can find the most modernized verses of women in Pakistan, we here can see the ladies in abaya/chaddars are the ladies selling themselves for money. when i say selling yes i mean being prostitutes. I comepletely agree to the author that A woman in a chaadar is no less likely to be raped than a woman* Ask yourself was this 5 year old girl even aware of the concept of abaya or jeans? was this 5 year old girl provoking men to come rape her? Any women whether in a chaddar or in jeans can be targeted for this insane crime.
Buzz | 10 years ago | Reply granted, rape takes away a girl's innocence. granted- it takes away a girl's dignity. well written article, but you paint a very bleak picture of her life - "how will this little girl pave her way to a normal life, let alone a good one?" Um, there's something called determination. Courage. Oh, and do the words "Mukhtaran Mai" ring a bell? yes, our society is frustrated, and it has many uneducated people, and it dwells on age old customs and traditions of child marriages etc etc. but if women themselves don't stand up to put a stop to it, then what? Be bold, don't sit in sufferring. i know- easier said than done. but Mukhtaran Mai refused to be victimised by this culture of oppression; she stood up and she persisted. And if women don't start speaking up, this horrible act will never cease. it's like tug of war- if the victim doesn't pull on the rope, the rapists *will* cave in.
VIEW MORE COMMENTS
Replying to X

Comments are moderated and generally will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive.

For more information, please see our Comments FAQ