Sweet victory, sour grapes: Bangladesh’s almost win

Published: March 27, 2012

Bangladesh not only earned a new, highly-esteemed position in the Asian cricket club but also won the hearts of millions that day, including the ones which were supposed to be with their opponent team. PHOTO: AFP and REUTERS

Although he is not my first Bangladeshi friend, Rohaan is definitely the first diehard Bangladeshi cricket fan I have ever met. He reminds me of how I used to be about cricket: crazy, emotional, passionate and frustrated. This March, the Bangladesh cricket team went all out to give their millions of fans, including Rohaan, a reason to cheer; something they have been longing for for a very long time.

At the Asia Cup 2012, the Bangladeshi team crossed all sorts of hurdles to make it to their first big final. On the final ball of a nerve bursting over, they were just two runs short of making their heroic performance a historic one. Pakistan, although more due to their luck than experience, was awarded the privilege to lift the cup, but it was Bangladesh who made an impression that day.

Bangladesh not only earned a new, highly-esteemed position in the Asian cricket club but also won the hearts of millions that day, including the ones which were supposed to be with their opponent team. Facebook and Twitter were both flooded with ‘brotherly’ (though some even insensitive) posts from their newly won-over Pakistani fans praising the Bangladeshi team and cricketers.

Television images of heartbroken players and teary-eyed fans set such an impression in the thousand-mile away West of Sher-e-Bangla stadium, that there were many wishing that Bangladesh had won instead of their own team. The sincere wishes from their ex-Western countrymen were responded to by matching gratitude and wishes by the grieving but proud Bangladeshis. Emotions were so high that nobody seemed to notice that the Bangladeshi premier didn’t show enough courtesy to give the cup to the winning team and left after watching the whole match till the final moments.

However, this entire ‘filmi-style’ climax dropped to its anti-climax in minutes, if not in seconds, only after two days when the news broke that the Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) has decided to formally complain and request the ultimate result reversal. This put the emotion train in reverse gear immediately.

Enayet Hossain Siraj, chairman of the Bangladesh Cricket Board (BCB) cricket operations committee, told reporters on Saturday that Aizaz Cheema had deliberately blocked batsman Mahmudullah in the final over.

“We have seen video footage of the incident repeatedly. It is clear that Cheema blocked Mahmudullah deliberately. We will lodge a written appeal to the ACC very soon and will also give a copy to the International Cricket Council”, said Siraj.

It started with polite and shocked messages like “cry baby”, “sour grapes” and “Oh, come-on!” from the Pakistani side, to be countered with an equal force by the Bangladeshi cybericketers.

All of a sudden, things got pretty heated and the sportsman’s spirit in exhibition for the last few days seemed to evaporate. The heart-gluing role of the game suddenly transformed into the root-cause for a cyber-war.

YouTube videos of the ‘friendly’ Afridi-Mashrafe collision and umpiring decisions of Younis and Umar’s dismissals uploaded as rebuttals for the ‘vicious’ act of young and desperate Cheema. Things got even spicier when our Indian friends started contributing their two cents into an already riled up cyber war.

Watching this swinging emotional pendulum was when I felt something was very wrong. Firstly, sportsmanship is good, but while it may represent some deep emotions, wishing for the other team to win at the cost of your own team is definitely not the spirit the game is played with. Games don’t work the way hearts do and to lift the trophy, you have to play the winning shot (or deliver the winning ball for that matter).

At the same time, it was shocking and saddening to see the response from some of the Pakistani internet-soldiers after the BCB decided to challenge the match result. No matter how much you had disliked the BCB’s stand, the fact is that it is rightfully their choice. Some of us really need to understand that Bangladesh is not East Pakistan anymore.

I agree that one can question the logic of BCB’s move since it has greatly marred, if not destroyed, the beauty of a great match. Bad umpiring decisions are an unfortunate but inevitable part of every game and Pakistan had more of this on that particular day. Even then, the proper place for deciding the fate of a game is in the playing field, not the wooden tables.

These post-Asia Cup events were a good insight of typical South Asian cricket-psyche. Every cricket match between Pakistan and Bangladesh doesn’t need to be taken to 1971. We all know that 1971 was a black and most unfortunate chapter in our history with wounds that are still unhealed. I have no hesitation in saying that as a Pakistani, I carry a feeling of guilt whenever it comes to Bangladesh.

Having said that, the fact is, cricket is a game and like every other game, there is a winner and loser. So don’t let politics destroy what this match has achieved. I hope that in later times when we look back at the 2012 Asia Cup final, we would do it by remembering the spirit shown by the two great cricketing teams and not these issues.

The only things I would like to see going beyond the boundaries of the cricket fields are sixes and fours. For settling ‘historical scores’, cricket grounds are definitely not the place.

As for myself, I have found a new cricket hero in Shakibul Hasan to cheer and to follow with my friend Rohaan.

Follow Ismail on Twitter @ismail_sultan

Ismail Sultan

Ismail Sultan

An engineer and a Fulbright Scholar in USA who loves to read about education, history and sports. Ismail tweets @ismail_sultan.

The views expressed by the writer and the reader comments do not necessarily reflect the views and policies of The Express Tribune.

  • Fahad Raza

    Bangladeshi Cricket will only grow more with this defeat. The appeal had 0.1% leverage which was certainly not enough. On the contrary it would have been much better for them to come n play here. I am quite certain had Bangladesh won the decision of not touring Pakistan would not had been so. On a side note it was quite interesting to see the Bangladeshi PM Exist without giving the prizes to the winners. Recommend

  • farhan karim

    apnara harieo jeetlenRecommend

  • reason11

    cricket has written rules and unwritten traditions. The childish and unacceptable behavior of PM hasina and BCB proves that they are not ready for cricket prime time as a nation, even if their team has shown a blip of success. May be they should keep focusing on local wrestling as a sport. Recommend

  • Belknap

    The fact of the matter is that you cannot appeal a bad umpiring decision after the match finished. If the umpire gives the last man out wrongly with only 2 runs to win, would an appeal have been justified? Nope. The mistake that the author of this post is making is treating both umpiring decisions differently. They are of exactly the same nature. You simply cannot appeal a bad decision after the game. Agreed, the fan reaction was not ideal, but BCB’s appeal made no logical sense whatsoever. Recommend

  • Sabit Sarwar Nadhvee

    I have no hesitation in saying that as a Pakistani, I carry a feeling of guilt whenever it comes to Bangladesh.
    You won my heart by saying that. I have been waiting for so many years to see such comments from a Pakistani. Thanks very much man.
    The other thing is that Remark application was made by BCB, not from Bangladeshis. Bangladeshi people not quite support this decision and BCB also knows that this application wont do anything. We have always seen the negative sides of umpire decision. I thing BCB applied to let ICC and ACC know that its enough and we are not gonna see ourselves as a pray of wrong decisions. Shakib Al Hasan was out in a crucial time by wrong decision of third umpire, can you take that?? third umpire maikng wrong decisions??? I surely cant.Recommend

  • Hina

    so Close yet so far …….Recommend

  • tariq

    Pakistanis should stop looking at cricket (or any other sport) through “Muslims vs Non Muslims” perspective. This is the stupid reason they didn’t celebrate on winning from Bangladesh.
    God help us if we play against Afghanistan or Saudi Arabia, at that time such people will support the opposing team instead of Pakistan and then will make idiotic statements like “Whoever wins the cup goes to Muslims.”Recommend

  • http://www.aliani4u.livejournal.com Elie Khan

    @Tariq
    bro em sure u were sleeping when pakistan won from bangladesh, cox the celebrations people had were more than ever, stop dragging religion into everything, seems a cowardice act, taking shelter behing religion..Recommend

  • Iqbal73

    As the great Trinidadian journalist C.L.R. James wrote, “What do they know of cricket who only cricket know?”
    Cricket for the nation was not so much the issue here, it had more to do with pride and vengeance and the assorted mental baggage of proving a point.Recommend

  • nash30

    Completely agree with everything. Especially the fact that sportsmanship does not mean you feel sorry for a team and hence start wishing they won. I was disgusted after reading several Facebook statuses that implied that Bangladesh should’ve won. Proud of Pakistan. And it’s sad that the respect gained by the tigers was so quickly squandered.
    Shakib is an excellent all rounder though, and Nasir, although he didn’t perform well in the Asia Cup, is also someone to look out for IMO.Recommend

  • Ali

    Sad day for the Indians indeed.Recommend

  • Optimist

    I am Pakistani but Bangladeshi is one cricket team I don’t mind losing from.
    .
    Love to our long lost brothers!Recommend

  • Greta

    We will beat the bangladeshis so bad in t20 wc that they will stop playing cricket,,,thats the spirit we need!Recommend

  • JB

    Poor sportsman spirit from Bangladesh. Such an amazing performance in the tournament. Defeated two world champions and came close to beating a third. But crying after losing the match just leaves a sour taste in the mouth. They lost all the respect they gained in the tournament by filing the appeal. Should Pakistan have filed an appeal against the wrongful dismissal of Younis Khan?Recommend

  • Bin Ismail

    Regardless of the obvious and undebatable fact that the BCB has as much right to hold an opinion as does the PCB, one cannot deny the fact that the Bangladeshi team played extremely well.Recommend

  • Ahsan Malik

    PCB, BCB, BCCI, penalty..no penalty.. Pakistan won…Bangladaish shoud’ve won.. all of these seems sports terms but then at the end putting the cats among the pegion… I am wondering despite of an intial non-political vow why author feels guilty when he visits Bangladaish…? ohh yes i got it over exagerated self-pity..and guilt trip of “3 million” atrocities in span of “9 motnhs” by “buthcher army” of Pakistan…com’on guys…you can’t be serious…
    May be author should’ve only stayed on topic… switching that abruptly from sports to twisted history and feeling guilty about a civil war in which biligerents of both sides commited inhumman acts of brutality is certainly not the way….even it is than guilt should be mutual….not just on part of some random sports journalist..stairing down dhaka airport..Recommend